Neither look bad to me, but I think I like the contrast of the dark office chair against the beige large chair and beige rug.

me too

Sure black one.

Choose the most comfortable, but I do prefer having wheels.

The black one.

I see it's a working desk based on the PC sitting on the counter!

If it's not an office and the desk is not a daily working desk I vote for the formal chair, looks way better in my opinion.

The chair with the wheels would work better in an office that gets daily use.

However, there doesn't seem to be a lot of room between the back of either chair and the loveseat. What does the rest of the room look like? Could you move the loveseat somewhere else?

the black one but you need to move the loveseat there is no room. You need curtains too

I like wheels on an office chair those blinds need to go for sure add some nice drapes in a linen color like the rug and if you need light control add some solar shades. Is it possible to move the desk down so the chair won’t hit the loveseat.

Can the desk be placed under the window? The chair would not conflict with the loveseat if the desk and loveseat changed places.

Definitely the darker chair for me.

I'm with the group on the black chair.

The dark one with wheels.

Prefer the linen colored chair but if it will be used as a desk chair (especially a home office) would go with the darker chair with casters.

Navy-- gives color, form, function, incorporates metal element to space, gives better ergo dynamic options, appears more comfortable and appropriate for desk.

The darker one on wheels for sure! Nice contrast and compliments the pillows.

Thro 14" x 26" Jayden Throw Pillow in Teal - Bed Bath & Beyond · More Info

Amazon.com: abstract art throw pillows: Home & Kitchen · More Info

if no art, i would prefer more in your face pillow.