Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_582526304

countertops for new kitchen

7 years ago

Hi. I am doing a kitchen with white shaker cabinets, subway tile with gray grout and light Oak wood floors. I am stuck on the counter tops. I like( not love) the quartz that looks like marble - not too busy ( Calcutta Clara MSI} I like the leathered black granite look, if it is a real rich black. I want something current but not too trendy that it will go out of date quickly( because then I won't like it any more) Any help , advice or pictures would be great. Thank you

Comments (37)

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    You've just described 99% of the kitchens on Houzz, and probably most of the questions on the Design Dilemmas pages about kitchen counter tops. Do a search and read what has already been said. There are so many marble-look quartz products now--go to a design center and get samples. Make up idea books with photos of what you like--many times the question has been asked and answered on what counter top was used.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    I'm trying to hazard a guess as to how many visuals of that exact kitchen may be on this site......................................................my guess is not less than multi thousands.

  • 7 years ago

    You might try selecting a quartz vendor and doing a houzz search on that vendor to find pictures that you like. you could also search black granite. Both your options sound pretty.

  • 7 years ago

    I have to admit, I am having trouble finding the pictures. Any links someone can suggest. Thank you

  • 7 years ago

    I understand. It took me a while to figure it out. You can go to Photos- Kitchen-Browse Photos


    In the Filters, for style you might select contemporary or modern or leave that blank. Cabinet style - shaker and Cabinet Finish - White.


    Here are some that I found

    Leathered Antique Brown Granite and River Valley Granite in Vienna, VA · More Info


    Forest Getaway · More Info


    White Traditional Kitchen - Old Westbury, NY · More Info


    Kitchens · More Info


    Traditional Kitchen · More Info


  • PRO
    7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago


    Interior Design Work · More Info


    2017 ARDA - Custom Homes - Royal Oaks Design · More Info












  • 7 years ago

    thank you!!

  • 7 years ago

    Okay so I think I like . A marble quartz outer countertop. And then a black island countertop. With white shaker cabinets and subway tile. Any pictures like this. Would that work? Then what material should the island be?

  • PRO
    7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Sweetie, you have a computer. And at SOME point, you do need to use your imagination. Down load a photo above, print it, take a sharpie and color the island top black. You have my permission on this one.

    Your best bet? USE your Google : " Beautiful white shaker kitchen images"

    https://www.google.com/search?q=beautiful+white+shaker+kitchen+images&tbm=isch&tbo=u&source=univ&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwj3nfrl8qHfAhXOpYMKHY_5Cd4QsAR6BAgFEAE&biw=1920&bih=877#imgrc=G33YjAYIfdC5KM:





    Interior Design Work · More Info






  • PRO
    7 years ago

    And then when you find a counter top brand and style/pattern/color you love, post a design dilemma asking if anyone has installed that specific one and would they post photos of it.

  • PRO
    7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Yes, true as Diana said. But in all honesty, unless a "marble" has strong veining? It will read white, and black as black in any photo.

    You are warned on faux marble with any bold veining at the kitchen perimeters.........if you have turns, and seams. you will not get matched veining. Don't PLAN on matched veining. Reserve a bolder vein for a seamless island...or make VERY certain at laser template , you know what you will have with regards to seams at the perimeter.....and WHERE they will be. ......

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    AND realize that any highly veined marble-look quartz can look very fake. Personally I'd stick with a very muted, subtle pattern that reads white from a distance. But I'm not a fan of any stone with strong veining, so take my opinion for what it's worth.

  • 7 years ago

    I am a die hard lover of white kitchens, and even I am getting very tired of the same old combinations. I would avoid marble looking quartz like the plague. Consider slab cabinets or applied moulding or some other different elements. Eschew the ubiquitous pendants. Gather lots of interesting images and see if you can make some changes to the standard elements when you adapt the look for your space.

  • 7 years ago

    So what would you pick Besides faux marble? I like simple

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    I don't think there's anything wrong with wanting that look, or with faux marble. Just because it's been done doesn't mean you shouldn't do it if you like it. As I said above, I would stay away from the heavily veined faux marble. Or do butcher block and/or honed Jet mist (black) granite.

    Here is a beautiful kitchen with both Jet Mist and butcher block counter tops:

    Historic District · More Info

    Another nice granite is Costa Esmeralda--it's a muted green stone that looks great with white cabinets. Here it is in a kitchen by Crisp Architects:


    Massachusetts Farm House · More Info


    Another suggestion is solid surfacing (aka Corian), which comes in a lot of colors and patterns.

    http://www.corian.com/-colors-of-corian-r-


    I love the look of red laminate with a metal edge, a la the 1950s--very retro and cool. Here's my favorite:


    Retro Kitchen · More Info


    HU-582526304 thanked Diana Bier Interiors, LLC
  • 7 years ago

    I like soapstone or honed Virginia mist, Negresco, or Via Lactea granite- those will mimic ss for less money and be hardier- no patina. I have white slab cabinets with soapstone myself.

    I love Anglophilia's palest gray cabinets with Glacier White Corian, and marble subway tile backsplash.

    Here is my kitchen:



    Here is a white kitchen with thick, gorgeous butcher block counters. Not something we see every day:



    If anyone has pictures of Anglophilia's kitchen it would be great to st them here too. I tried looking and failed.





  • 7 years ago

    thank you for being kind and helping. I looked at soapstone and not much was avaliable to see. What I saw I didn't like. Black granite is interesting to me. However I thought granite was outdated and quartz was the way to go? Butcher block I love the look. But how is the upkeep.


    I love carrara marble, but have little kids, so I am not sure what to expect.



  • 7 years ago

    Diana I love the first picture!! With the black granite and butcher block , How is the upkeep with Butcher block. I have small children and we are a messy family. Meaning we use the kitchen and don't clean up till after finishing eating.


    Pretty much they are tearing up the kitchen today and I need to decide in the next couple of days.

  • 7 years ago

    Busy granite with small patterns all over is out of favor. Marble looking quartz has been used a great deal for the past ten years, so it's a good bet it will be going out of date soon. Quartz in general is not my cuppa, so I don't have much to say. Personally I think it is a very expensive product for the benefits it offers. Others love it.

    English houses have butcher block counters quite commonly. Some people here do too. I know you need to seal the wood and if you get a nice tight end grain you should be golden.

    Perhaps start a thread asking for people's experiences with butcher block.

    If you love carrara marble, and don't mind patina, then go for that. Marble will etch- staining can be avoided with a good sealer. Some people will say marble has been used for centuries and etching is a good thing (me,) others will want counters to look showroom new all the time- those people should not get marble.

    Some Greeks christen their marble countertops with lemon juice to get over the etching issue right away.

  • PRO
    7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I love butcher block, but not near a sink or water. It gets ruined from constant water--I had it in a kitchen and had to replace it on the perimeter, but I kept the piece on the island. Even though it gets scratched, it's fine, and doesn't have any water damage.

    Speckly granite was never anything I liked, so whether it is in or out is irrelevant. I prefer laminate over it.

    Dark honed granite is beautiful and doesn't look anything like the builder grade stuff.

    I have the Jet Mist and it's fantastic looking and very easy to care for. But I've heard homeowners on Houzz complaining of "water spots." Sometimes you get spots from oil or water, but they seem to fade over time.

    Marble is only for people who don't mind "patina" which is code for etching and scratching. Mine is honed Olympian White Danby and has lots of patina! I have a love/hate relationship with it. And the urban legend of pouring lemon juice on it to "get the etching done" is silly and wouldn't work even if anyone tried to do it. Etching is a wearing away of the stone, so even if you evenly applied vinegar, lemon juice, or any other acid, the next time you used any other acid and got a drop on it, you'd have an etch on the etch, meaning it would wear away more of the stone.

    Quartz can be fake looking, and it also chips and can get weird looking spots on it, especially from hard water. You also cannot place hot pots on it as you can melt the plastic in it.

    So as one of my teachers used to say "you pays your money and you takes your choice." Nothing is bullet proof, you just need to be informed and pick the material that works best for your family and your budget.

  • 7 years ago

    In my case it's no urban legend. I have Greek friends here (not in Greece) and they did indeed squeeze lemon haphazardly on their counters- there was no material reason for doing it- they knew it would not stop more etching, scratching or spalling- they christened the counters for psychological reasons- so they get over the brand new shiny perfection of the slab and embrace the patina from the get-go.

  • 7 years ago

    thank you everyone.


    Do you have a picture close up of the Jet Mist Granite? Thank you

  • PRO
    7 years ago
    I would consider Zodiaq Gravel. It pairs well with white cabinets and white subway tiles with gray grout. It is not a stark contrast like black, and doesn’t get lost with all the other white like a marble look quartz would. And because it is a granular pattern instead of having lots of movement, seams should be relatively unobtrusive.
    HU-582526304 thanked Hal Braswell Consulting
  • 7 years ago
    I don’t think the fact that quartz has become increasingly popular means granite (or any other alternative) will soon be dated. There will always be product evolution, but what is an improvement to one person will be a loss of character to another. Case in point: just because you can engineer diamonds in a lab, doesn’t mean the natural stone is considered any less timeless - it just gives people a new (less expensive, but more ethically defensible) option to consider :) For what it’s worth, my sisters black countertops are her biggest regret because every water ring, etc. shows. That being said, the pros and cons of any countertop choice will depend quite a bit on budget, individual preference, and lifestyle. Once you find a look you like, research the care and maintenance required. Good luck!
    HU-582526304 thanked Kirsten E.
  • PRO
    7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Here's a photo of Jet Mist with white swirls. Keep in mind that natural stone has variations, so you need to see and select the actual slab for your project as it may differ.

    Charmed Country Kitchen · More Info


    Regarding your friends, Rita, I understand what you're saying, but as they did the lemon juice for "psychological" reasons, I rest my case.

    HU-582526304 thanked Diana Bier Interiors, LLC
  • PRO
    7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    You will be no more "decided" here on these pages than you were when you began. This top, whatever it is, must be seen in person, selected in parson, INSPECTED in person. . Any of them.You are looking for "magic" in both of the threads. Get thee to a stone yard.

  • 7 years ago
    I agree with above - get off the internet and look at things in person. Look, touch, fall in love (after you have thoroughly vetted your ‘match’). And I always get a little nervous about finish questions when that is the cart before the horse - has the PLAN been as well thought out?
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I keep going back to what you said in your original post...that if you pick something that goes out of date quickly you won’t like it. You’re in danger of that happening anytime you pick stuff that’s in style right now. Everything you mentioned in your kitchen design is currently trendy and will be replaced by something else in the next 5-20 years. Some changes will be dramatic (the crystal ball in my head says arched cabinets are coming back) and some will be more subtle. But if you need your kitchen to always be up to trend, my advice is to pick the cheapest options possible because you’re going to hate them in a few years. I hear the “natural stone is classic and never out of style“ people clearing their throats. :) Tell that to everyone with Verde Butterfly and UbaTuba shiny granite with fancy edge treatment. That natural stone was going to be eternally timeless in 2004 and now It’s hopelessly dated...EXCEPT for the people who picked it because they loved it and didn’t care if it went out of style. If somehow we could shield ourselves from advertising, trends, and peer pressure we could pick things we like and just love them till they wear out and have to be replaced. That won’t happen, of course. But, OP... I urge you to get out and look at counters and fall in love with something. Pick something that makes your heart sing...maybe even a lovely bright laminate like the one pictured above. Or get quartz if it looks and feels beautiful to you. But pick because it’s your choice, not because it’s never going out of style.

    HU-582526304 thanked SapphireStitch
  • 7 years ago

    I have a wood counter with a sink, it’s been fine. My favourite counter with sink tho, was a stainless all in one, absolutely bullet proof, I found an enamelled cast iron all in one, it’s so nice to wash dishes at.

    HU-582526304 thanked J Williams
  • 7 years ago

    ^^What SapphireStitch said. If you're that influenced by what's on trend and what's "dated," then just do something as cheaply as you can so that you can throw it out and replace it when you get tired of it. Your various threads on this forum thus far imply that you don't have a strong design sense of yourself. There is no one thing that you truly love and never get tired of. So you're asking the internet to bring you the Unicorn Kitchen - that is magically on trend forever. Such a thing doesn't exist. There is no perfect black countertop - honed granite shows fingerprints and water spots, soapstone tends to scratch or chip. quartz will melt if you put a hot pot on it. Ditto for white countertops. And butcherblock. Or anything else. No one surface is everything to everyone.

    Ergo, you have two choices:

    1. Sit down and create some visual categories of things you really love. Use Pinterest, or Tumblr, or whatever medium helps you capture images to review. What things keep cropping up? What do you dislike? What would be appropriate to the rest of the house? What sort of upkeep are you willing to do, or what sort of patina are you willing to accept? And then style a timeless kitchen using those elements.

    2. Pick out the trendiest design elements from the upcoming avalanche of webicles entitled "Bold New Kitchen Trends of 2019!!!" and put those into your house as inexpensively as possible. Rip it out and do it all over again in 2025 when those trends are passe.

    I suppose there is a third option:

    1. Build the One, True Kitchen of 2015 (white, grey, shaker, marble, black granite) and then lament for the next 15 years that it's become dated, limits your ability to follow other design trends as color schemes get warmer (most of these kitchens don't necessarily work all that well with the terra cottas, bright greens, yellows, and blonde woods that are starting to trend NOW...). Spend more money changing hardware, backsplash, and painting the island until you can bite the bullet and rip the whole (much more expenisve) thing out and put in the One True Kitchen of 2035. Whatever that will be.
    HU-582526304 thanked Holly Stockley
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    HU-582526304 - here are a couple of photos. Note that this stone is called both "Jet Mist" and "Virginia Mist" interchangeably, so go to stoneyards and ask for both. You can also Google "jet mist" and "virginia mist", then go to the Google Images tab and see a ton of other pics.

    Note that this granite varies tremendously in the amount of "powdered sugar" it can have. This is a matter of personal taste whether you like it with more of the sugar or less (I like more!).

    P.S. Can you please give yourself a real name? It is just easier to want to communicate with a poster with an actual name, not HU-582526304.

    I am definitely not advocating a two-level counter (or a double-bowl sink for that matter); this was just a photo on the internet that shows Jet Mist/Virginia Mist with a lot of the powdered sugar effect.



    Here is a photo of Jet Mist/Virginia Mist with less of the sugar effect.


    HU-582526304 thanked Miranda33
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    @ HU-582526304 Marble won't be durable for a kitchen, especially with little kids. Some people in this thread love their Corian countertops, but be aware that Corian scratches more easily than you might expect. It can be repaired but it's a hassle. Quartz discolors in sunlight, so avoid if you have sun shining into the kitchen. You can also burn quartz with hot pots since it is mostly made up of resin. Granite comes in all different qualities and thicknesses. Some people have trouble with cracking and chipping granite while others have had it last years, but it does need to be sealed periodically and can stain since it is a natural, porous surface. If you don't clean up spills until after the meal, as you said, you should probably avoid butcher block since moisture must be kept wiped up quickly to prevent damage. Butcher block can be sanded and re-oiled, but again that is a hassle. Have you seen the newest line of Wilsonart 21 Soft Silk laminate surfaces? They have just been released in 2018 and mimic marble. These are beautiful, soft finishes, and you might be surprised how pretty they are. With laminate based on 40 square feet of countertop you would be looking at possibly an $800 countertop instead of a $4000 to $8000 one in granite. And laminate is incredibly durable for a household with kids.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    "but it does need to be sealed periodically and can stain since it is a natural, porous surface"

    Nope, not true. A fallacy from people who do not understand, or who do not have the knowledge, that there are many different granites available, and they have different "densities". Some granites are more porous, typically the lighter granites like Imperial White. And some granites need sealing just once a year, a 5-minute process that anyone can do. And some granites are very dense and never need sealing at all. I believe "virginia mist" and "jet mist" fall into that category and are so dense they don't need sealing.

  • 7 years ago

    @Miranda33 Within the granite densities, could you go with a 2 cm vs. 3 cm thickness to reduce cost and still get a more dense granite that wouldn't crack or chip despite a thinner application? There are lots of sad cracking stories out there even on brand new granite installations.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    When discussing a stone's density, it's actually about its absorption rate - how easily or not that particular stone can absorb liquid. For example, marbles in general have a high absorption rate, and will stain easily unless sealed frequently. It doesn't matter how thick or thin a marble counter is; it will absorb stains just the same. There are so many granites available--thousands--and they vary in absorption rate. You can sometimes find the absorption rate on the internet for a particular granite. Or just ask on this forum if anyone has that granite, and what has been their experience in staining. Whether a 2 cm or 3 cm thickness has nothing to do with the stone's density.

    Some granites are so dense (Absolute Black for example, but there are others), that sealing them would be harmful to their appearance. Those stones are so dense that the sealant won't absorb, and just sits on the surface of the stone causing haze and streaks. You will sometimes see complaints from people about their counter's haze and streaks, cause they didn't realize their granite is so dense they should not have sealed it.

    Fissures are a completely different issue, not having to do with density. It has to do with what the granite is made up of. For example, some granites have a lot of mica. That mica makes them sparkle and be beautiful, but mica tends to flake, and where there is a bigger vein of mica, a fissure could develop. When choosing your slab, look for those fissures, and also talk to your fabricator about them.

    Of course, mishandling a stone, whatever the type, can cause cracking. You need to hire a good counter fabricator.

    You also need to go the slab template layout. Don't miss that, and make sure you go.

  • 7 years ago

    @Miranda33 Thanks for all the excellent information on granite densities and fissure precautions. I would expect anyone investing in granite to be involved in templating. Hard to understand why someone would miss that, but I make apparel patterns for my work so I guess I'm biased toward wanting to be involved in anything that involves a pattern. There are always so many little decisions to be made when any pattern is being created.