Software
Houzz Logo Print
tuesday_carter

planned to self destruct

I had a learning experience these last couple of days when my Shop Vac suddenly stopped working. I plugged it and flipped the switch and it ran for about three seconds and went off.

Tried all the most obvious solutions of different outlets, different extension cord, etc...

So, I began to take it apart and came all the way to the motor. Rigged wired the switch. That did not work. Cleaned out everything. Nada.

So, I got online and found a few guys who talked about repairing these things and the one thing a number of them came to is that there is a fuse, of sorts, that is in the wiring. This is, according to a consensus of opinion of these guys, not really a proper fuse that reacts to a sudden overload on the motor. Instead, in their collective opinions, this little fuse is not a proper fuse, rather it is an inexpensive little element that is planned to fail. Ostensibly, yes, it is a fuse. In reality, it is not and there is not really one required. One pointed out the fact that they could, with some legitimacy, say that it is a safety feature. But, the reality is that this little part is a cheap little thing with quite another real purpose.

So, I went further and got it down to where that part was, and, sure enough., There it was, obviously compromised.

Basically, what it amounts to is a piece of metal, aluminum maybe, that is 1/4" long and about 1/16" diameter. For that, the machine quit working. For that tiny piece of metal that, had you dropped it on the floor you would never find it, the whole machine could have ended up in the trash.

What I did, was to bring together two tiny wires to bypass the little built to fail part. These two wires were only about 1/16" apart, a tiny gap. I bridged that gap and put it back together and now it works.


One of the guys took apart a machine like mine and and older machine that he had. The older machines did not have these little parts that are built to fail, and had no proper fuses, either. If your machine overloads, it should throw the breaker in your breaker box. I have repaired vacuums before and have never seen a fuse in a vacuum.

So, we will see.

The only other thing that I can see is there is a possibility that a bushing on the motor shaft was not as it might should be. That could possibly have caused friction that caused the motor to draw more power. I fixed that, too, by reseating the little bushing.

These machines are not really very complicated, but it took a learning curve on my part to find out what it might be. It took only very simple and ordinary tool, too. That is not always the case. Sometimes these things are put together so that you cannot get them apart.

Last year I had to get rid of an electric oil filled radiator heater. Sometimes it worked. Sometimes it didn't. I looked around a bit but did not have the time or energy to put into it at the time, so I got a new one. Only after some time was I browsing the subject again and I learned that there is a little float mechanism in them that can get stuck and it does not allow them to come on. I wish that I had come across that information before I put it out. I might have been able to fix it.


Electric coffee makers have a little inline thermal element that goes out and unless you are knowledgable about such things, it is not replaceable. So, out goes the whole thing complete with carafe, basket, etc....all because of one tiny little element!


We will see how long my repair works.

I also repaired the Lazyboy recliner with some well placed srews at strategic places. We will see how long that lasts, too.


We ought to have some standards for these consumer items that offers us some repairability.

When I thought I was going to have to buy a new vacuum, I went to Amazon and began to read some of the reviews for different ones. Many who purchased new vacs had two outstanding criticisms The first was that the product is not built with as sturdy features as is the old one that they had for fifteen years and are now replacing.

The second was that they did not last very long and many died in short order.

I think the assertion by some of these folks who are making these "how I repaired my vacuum" videos that these things are designed to fail has a substantial amount of credibility.

Comments (5)

  • 7 years ago

    Recently I repaired and refinished a small dinette table I found in the garbage on the street. I was saying to a colleague who is a carpenter that I felt a little sheepish, because I spent nearly as much on equipment and supplies as it might have cost to buy a similar table. (Of course, some of that equipment will be useful for other projects in the future.)

    He responded quite vehemently that he thought I'd done the right thing. "We need to have fewer things going to the landfill," he said.

    I think that repairability and durability are now ECOLOGICAL issues.
    And there is a move afoot from industry to make it harder for people to fix things themselves, and also a counterpush to require manufacturers to make it easier for people to repair their own stuff.

    Right to Repair


    Wikipedia's report on the issue; the usual disclaimers apply.


    There's also the idea that to hire someone else to fix things can be hard, or too expensive.

    I fixed two broken Nintendo DS's (I had to send a third one to a repair service because I couldn't get the parts, but they could salvage them).

    My friend fixed her vacuum and her stove and was really energized by the sense of accomplishment.


  • 7 years ago

    Thanks for the link to the right to repair movement.

    One thing that is an obstacle to repairing something is that the parts are considered to be "proprietary" , meaning that they cannot be sold as parts. Therefore, you cannot get that one little thermal part for your coffee maker. Not only does that keep you from repairing it and insures that you will have to buy another, it also protects the company from liability in case you injure yourself by trying to replace it

    Some appliances have what are called capacitators in them and if you come into contact with them you are likely to receive a nasty shock. That is why there are warnings on the backs and bottoms of things such as a microwave, for instance. Televisions would be another that has them. It makes the appliance always in a "on" state for instant activity. That is one reason you might encounter screws or fasteners that are not removable without the right tool and you will see that little shock warning emblem.

    There are some legitimate obstacles to repairing some things yourself.

    But, there really should be some legislation that prevents manufacturers from building in easily failed, and designed to fail elements deep inside the machine. If a machine is required to have a fuse, that fuse should be easily accessed and easily replaced.

    Like this vacum of mine. It is a wet/dry vac and one might assume that the fuse is because it could be exposed to wet. That is not a valid safety feature. A more valid safety feature would be like the GFC that is on my power washer. In case water and electricity make contact, it will shut off. And, it has a switch that it can be reset.

    I really am inclined to believe that I have seen for myself a major deceptive practice that very likely creates a lot of cast off, non decomposable or recyclable garbage and generates a lot of sales and profits. This little part is probably a tiny fraction of the cost of building this machine and probably pays off many times over for the company. Seriously, I make no exaggeration when I tell you that it 1/4" long and 1/16" diameter! And, it is hidden under the housing of the motor which would inhibit some to take it apart that far.

    These are the kinds of things that Consumer Reports does not reveal or account for. They do not go that far into the obscure parts of the appliance to find this out.

    I see so many people who complain that the new things do not last as long as the things of the past.

    I think that things like this are a major scam on consumers.

    I have seen lamps from Ikea that have an inline fuse on them. I am not sure why or if they still do. It may be a safety feature in case they fall over and the hot bulb comes into contact with something. That is how I found out about it. I had a floor lamp fall over and it would not come back on. It was only later that I discovered the little in line fuse. It is not hidden. It was right there, but I did not know what it was. And, this was one of those torchiere lamps that came to be seen as a hazard. So, that could be why.

    It used to be that there were local repair options. But, not anymore. There are probably too many different things that are all different. Used to be that a TV was just a TV, a phone was a phone and etc.....


    There ought to be a law against making things that are designed to fail.




  • 7 years ago

    I find it sad that I can take a 4 block walk and find enough tossed appliances to outfit several homes. I have a relative who can and does repair anything and everything. What a wonderful talent. He often finds parts (some parts are used) on E-Bay. Apparently some people instead of throwing away a broken item takes it apart and sells it part by part. Sometimes even the tiniest little screw. He says this is how he repairs most things. He then gives these items away. Unfortunately it is sometimes hard to find a home for everything. People want new only.

  • 7 years ago
    A number of years ago I went to open the door to my expensive built in microwave and... nothing. The door wouldn’t open. My engineer hubby finally got the door open after he unscrewed a bunch of stuff and it turned out that there was a tiny little latch that popped the door open when you pressed the button, except the latch was really flimsy and had snapped at the end. I distinctly recall my engineer hubby exclaiming “what!? They engineered this latch to fail!” Anyways, he went online to order a new part, but you couldn’t get just the little part by itself, it only came in a kit but they wanted something like $130 for the kit, it was just a ridiculous amount for a tiny piece of plastic! My disgusted hubby snorted and said “no way!” and he went upstairs to raid our kids’ Lego box. He ended up using epoxy to glue a couple of flat Lego pieces to the plastic lever that had snapped off at the thinnest part and Voila! The door was fixed! That microwave lasted quite a few more years before the electronics finally fried themselves, but that door still worked just fine! (For what it’s worth, we have never gone with a built in microwave since then...)
  • 7 years ago

    skmom, I will bet that there are a lot of people who can relate an experience much like yours. Only they might not have as determined a person to rig a fix for it as you have.

    That is so infuriating and it should be just down right against some law to manufacture anything with such. How many otherwise good things are cast aside and replaced like this everyday in this country?!

    The manufacturer refers to these types of parts as "assemblies". You can't buy that one little screw or doo dad. You have to buy the entire piece that it is enclosed in.

    The plastic in the Lego that your husband repaired it with was probably a better quality plastic than was in the original latch.


    And, hcbm, It is evident on garbage day just how many things are thrown out. If you are so inclined you can pull all kinds of things out of the garbage. Some of the folks that I watched on video repairing vacuums had rescued them from the curb.

    I have seen people throw away vacuums simply because the bag was full or had burst and was clogging up the filters.


    I feel pretty confident that the little "fuse" on this one that I repaired is not really a needed part. I have never seen a fuse on a vacuum. It is still possible that something did actually cause the machine to overheat. I might still have to address something, but I will

Sponsored
AIS Renovations
Average rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars15 Reviews
Custom Craftsmanship & Construction Solutions in Franklin County, Ohio