Software
Houzz Logo Print
nathan_oltmanns

Flooring Help SPC vs Laminate Vs Engineered

7 years ago

I am ripping out all the floors in my downstairs and have gotten a ton of different out looks on the three floors above. I was orginally going to do a vinyl plank/spc, but the last two floor stores that I went into said they were having several problems with various brands. They said the locking mechanisms were coming apart in several brands because they are so small and the detail of LVP actually were showing signs of scratching and wear. Are these legit issues with these floors. One company showed me a cortec floor that was dented from furniture. The last two companies both reccomend a manninton or mohawk laminate over LVP./SPC. It was actually cheaper than SPC/LVP. SPC is fairly new. Has anyone had any issues with these floors? I have 3 kids and looking for something with durability and looks good.
I read several post and havent heard if these issues. Is laminate a good choice? Or would SPC vs LVP be a better choice?
Thank You for any advice.

Comments (11)

  • 7 years ago

    A high-end vinyl floor (out of Germany or Switzerland = $4-$7/sf) will do the trick for vinyl SPC (the SPC is for the CORE of the product...not the top which you step on).


    A high-end laminate from just about anywhere (I still like to look to Europe) = $3-$7/sf will also do the trick.


    You will notice the price points are VERY close. The one thing you want to be aware of: underpad. Laminate allows MANY OPTIONS. It allows thick, thin, high-end or bottom of the barrel (don't go low...the floor is only as good as the thing it is sitting on).


    A vinyl product (SPC or not) will have limitations as to what can sit under it. If you are in a cool/cold climate, that could mean the difference between a chilly SPC or a warm/quiet laminate.


    A high-end laminate is still a high-end product. Just because it is "laminate" does not mean it is junk. It just means it has a photograph of "something" on top. Then it is covered in HIGH end finish = makes it one of the toughest wearing floors on the market. Laminate does NOT have to be $0.79/sf garbage. You can access some IMPRESSIVE Swiss products for a mere $5/sf. And that Swiss product will kick @ss when compared to mid-range vinyls (same price).


    Ask yourself what is important about the floor (ignore the graphics...like all forms of beauty it is fleeting). Do you want quiet? Do you want warm? Do you want longevity? Do you want water PROOF? Because water proof will cost you! Big time.


    If you want water PROOF, then pick floors that work for the wet areas (kitchen/bath/entrance/mudroom) and then work with something less pricey everywhere else. It will work out cheaper in the end.

    nathan oltmanns thanked SJ McCarthy
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    SPC is not LVP. LVP can be brittle, especially the thinner click locking mechanisms. SPC is a solid vinyl product that should perform well and having sold it for roughly 2-3 years, am unaware of any consistent problems with them. As far as finish wear on vinyl, again some of the more cost effective products are likely only finished out with a few coats of polyurethane but many of the better quality materials are finished out with polyurethane PLUS either a ceramic-bead or aluminum oxide finish which make the finish more resistant to scratches. Newer vinyl products are being referred to as "RVP" which stands for Rigid Vinyl Plank and are also well-performing products. I do not think you'll have issues with furniture denting SPC or RVP-core products - LVP, yes if it's heavy enough.


    Laminates are also solid materials. They are similar to vinyl in that they are not real wood (rather they are digital prints - pictures of wood) but quality products will hold up to wear-and-tear nicely. They can scratch but not easily but most laminate products do not perform as well with respect to moisture. The core underneath a laminate is fiberboard which is essentially sawdust (wood) and a few other things - wood swells with moisture and most laminates will do the same. The newer water-resistant categories will perform better with respect to moisture however they are not waterproof so if they are exposed to moisture for a prolonged period of time some swelling will occur (though most say it is marginal).


    Engineered is "real" wood - it is not a digital print. Big win is you get more return on your investment come resell time as you can advertise real wood when you sell the home but they will likely scratch easier and wood does not hold up to moisture quiet as nicely.

    Let me know if I can help in any other way.

  • 7 years ago

    Thank you... this was super helpful... what flooring would you suggest... a waterproof laminate or SPC... or RVP

    .. its it's a big investment and I dont really want to mess it up... I think engineers hardwhardwood is out of my price range...

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    So, to be clear... SPC and RVP are one-and-the-same. The core is a blend of limestone and some other stuff. Different retailers call it different things.

    Generally, price-wise the lams will probably be a tad more cost effective but in most cases, installation requires more effort if you want to realize the waterproof properties.

    The vinyl products can just be laid without much extra effort but will likely be marginally higher in terms of cost. You can check my profile and contact me if you have any other questions.

    nathan oltmanns thanked floorfreak
  • 7 years ago

    What is the price of the square foot of the AtroGuard?

  • 7 years ago

    I have a SPC vinyl plank in our home, and I am pretty sure that it would hold almost anything, without damage. It's very strong, as it has stone in the center.

  • 7 years ago

    Nathan, I have been quoted prices of $3.25 and $3.49 sq. ft. for the 12 mm AtroGuard. We really like the lighter colors in the AtroGuard. On their website, it states that AtroGuard has as many as 30+ different plank patterns in each color. Most laminates don’t have half that many. It will be much easier to have a floor installed without seeing too many pattern repeats.

    I think BPI is the sole distributor for AtroGuard. You can google BPI and find one in your part of the country, and they should be able to tell you who sells it in your area.

    nathan oltmanns thanked Jamie Pace
  • 7 years ago

    Im looking at the Republic SPC flooring now... It looks really good... Will check out that laminate as well.

  • 7 years ago

    Have you read all the comments on the Houzz forum “Anyone heard of Republic Flooring?” There are a number of comments about the SPC and the laminate.

    Good luck in your flooring search. I’ve found it to be a somewhat daunting task.

  • 7 years ago

    I read that whole thread. The floor looks really nice... I have stairs in my house and thats another issue I am trying to figure out. Thanks Again..

Sponsored
CHC & Family Developments
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars6 Reviews
Industry Leading General Contractors in Franklin County, Ohio