i actually like the 3rd rug, not plain but not too strong.

You may love orange, but I think a big dose if it on the floor would become tiring after a short while.

None of the above due to the boldly patterned chairs. I know you're asking about a rug, but you have some color problems in the room you might want to address before getting a rug. The main issue when I look at the wall color is that it's a creamy yellow, correct? Against that is a beige sofa--same color value but not in harmony at all with the walls. Consider changing the wall color to the same beige family as the sofa--you can go lighter or darker but basically the same tan.

If the wall color were more on the neutral tan spectrum, then the chairs would stand out. You'd have all kinds of choices with the rug then get art or an ottoman in a bold color. You could do a version of this:

Minnesota Residence · More Info

.

Bay Head Indoor/Outdoor Carpet, Home/Patio Area Rug - DUNE, Square 9x9' · More Info

Safavieh Cape Cod Collection CAP353 Rug, Natural/Blue, 8'x10' · More Info

Augusta Storage Ottoman, Crimson Red · More Info

I am no designer - so take this with a grain of salt. But I actually like the red and blue rug! Pattern on pattern can be fun! Maybe remove the gold pillows, add some pillows that pull colors from the rug. Leave the walls neutral. You don‘t want it looking like a circus. Unless, of course, that’s your thing =)

We agree with housegal actually. It seems the chairs you have are quite bold, and they will need a rug that calms the area. However we need to look at the issues in the room first to help with the rug. Would you be open to perhaps painting the room? Or maybe changing the lighting? It looks like the sofa and wall colors are clashing at the moment.

Upscale Family Home: Living Room · More Info

What is your taste in the rest of the house? A couple of your rug choices make the room look very boring and dated. IMO. Do you have some more exciting choices you could show readers?

I really like the oriental, but you could pare down the brightness a bit?

Try a few more subtle patterns as mentioned above.

Rugs USA - Area Rugs in many styles including Contemporary, Braided, Outdoor and · More Info

Rugs USA - Area Rugs in many styles including Contemporary, Braided, Outdoor and · More Info

PDT-2305 Rug from Presidential by Surya | PlushRugs.com · More Info

Nourison Karma Blue Area Rug · More Info

Saw this one just now, only $237 for 8x10 it's different! https://www.rugsusa.com/rugsusa/rugs/rugs-usa-floral-ogee-fringe/Blue/200KHMC01A-P.html

Rugs USA - Area Rugs in many styles including Contemporary, Braided, Outdoor and · More Info