Hey all. I’ve been reading (too much probably) a ton of info after getting a few estimates on having our 22 windows replaced here. Currently have Anderson’s that haven’t been cared for before we bought the house and they’re in rough shape.

We’ve gotten prices on Anderson 400, Soft Lite Imperial LS, and Marvin Integrity. The Integrity are priced at the top, 400’s next, then Imperials. We are planning on staying in the house forever and windows that need no attention are at the top of our list next after durability.

We’ve got a lot of oversized windows but the we’ve gotten are as follows (all double pane, low E installed)

Imperial LS 25k
400’s 28,500
Integrity 32,500 (and 36). The only overlapping quote.

We trust both installers. Established and local. One has done a little job for us before and the other my neighbors house. No issues.

I’d love to hear any thoughts. I’m leaning Imperial because of the reviews I’ve read and the price. Avoiding Wood interior is important so that would send the 400’s out since nothing stands out performance wise but the existing Anderson’s have been here for 32 years with no issues mostly other than human error (painter windows closed). Integrity doesn’t seem worth the price upgrade and the reviews are hit or miss much more than the other.

Thanks!