Just did Grey in my kitchen and wast have a very simular problem. Grey can change colors on you depending on the lighting and other finishes in the room.

The modern Grey is most likely going to look more beige than grey with all the cream and beige you already have in your counters and cabinets. The Agreeable Grey will look more grey (if that is what you are wanting) and I think that the cream and beige in your counters and cabinets will tone down the blue quite a bit. That is the color I like the best from the sample photo you posted.

I would get enough paint and try doing an entire wall (so the paint somes up to the cabinet and counter), then look at it in different lighting situations. Daylight and night lighting can really change the look of grey paint. The first grey that I loved looked great in the daylight but was a muddy brown/purplish mess in our night lighting.

not grays with this counter top

Curious if you made a decision?

Which color did you end up using? What is the top/first color?

I’m curious what you chose as well! We have similar colors in our kitchen with our cabinets and countertops .. I’m considering accessible beige or realist beige… the agreeable gray felt too blue in our kitchen but I know the lighting changes everything in one home to the next

Pretty!!!

Very pretty! What color are you cabinets?

We have revere pewter on walls with similar cabinets and counter top. There is not much wall showing but it looks good. There is a sherwin williams tool that allows you yo pain your room virtually. Lord knows i need my island painted. The island is painted using the color pallette tool.