Software
Houzz Logo Print
opaone

Measuring exhaust fan performance ?

7 years ago

When we remodeled our bathroom some years ago the new 130 CFM inline exhaust fan didn't seem to be working as well as it should. The HVAC contractor turned it on, put a bit of bath tissue on it and said that since it stuck it was working just fine! I asked him if he had a table for converting what % coverage of tissue paper remaining stuck equaled what CFM. He didn't


I made a quick test thing with a 3' bit of 8" duct and stuck a pitot tube in it from a manometer. IIRC I was getting about 50 CFM. HVAC guy said that was about right that no blower delivers the full CFM because of static pressure issues. I just happened to have the fan curves for the inline blower in my pocket and discussed with him how he could reduce the static pressure in his installation... which he finally did. We ended up with 110CFM which seemed about right.


So, two questions:


1) Is what I did likely the best way to measure exhaust fan performance? I sold my manometer (it was actually for auto work that I was no longer doing). Would a short bit of duct plus something like a Kestral 5200 work?


2) What is a reasonable expectation for performance? Is 90% of rated CFM too much to expect? 80%?


2a) How many HVAC folks install rigid duct rather than flex duct for exhaust fans? Rigid is rare in MN though becoming more common.


Thanks,



Comments (5)

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Use the Norwegian Performance Test (NPT). If you can sit in the bathroom (you know where) while your spouse takes a shower, and neither one of you smell anything offensive and the mirror doesn't steam up, you got the right CFM no matter what the duck is.

    (Anyone catch the malapropism?)

  • 7 years ago

    Got it, Mark!

    Opaone, I must say that I am very impressed that you went through the trouble to find a way to measure this in the past, and perhaps more impressed that your contractor worked with you on improving the efficiency of your fan! Or maybe he was just shocked that you measured the output.

    I think that the word is finally getting out that we need smooth-walled rigid ducting for fans. I have run into several workers who expected it.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Opaone you're well on your way to becoming an HVAC nerd!

    Let's begin at the beginning: a bath vent fan is intended to ventilate both moisture and odors. It needs to be sized so that it does both effectively. You can consult Home Ventilating Institute (HVI) recommendations when selecting a fan.

    The performance test that Mark Bischak proposes is actually a good one (yes, really.) If you'll supplement it with a check of relative humidity in the space, you'll have a pretty good indicator of whether the fan is doing both jobs it needs to do. I recommend running a bath vent fan for at least 20 minutes following a shower so check relative humidity in the space periodically for at least 20 minutes.

    If the fan is performing both functions, then measuring air flow is academic, really. If not knowing air flow is keeping you up at night, you can measure the static pressure and refer to the manufacturer's fan curve from which you can infer air flow with reasonable accuracy.

  • 7 years ago

    I am with Mark. The actual CFM is not the important question, unless you already have an answer to the question "How much CFM do I need?"

    If the mirror and window don't fog up after a long shower, your flow rate is sufficient.

    Mark, if it looks like a duck...

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Yes, but...

    If it doesn't perform correctly after we move in then fixing it could be massively more complicated than if we measure it now and fix it while walls are open.

    And in one case we have a 300 CFM inline blower to better exhaust hairspray. If that vent is not performing well then we may have a bigger problem. If it's not performing and the vent is exhausting 280 CFM then that's on me for not choosing a larger blower. If it's not performing and the vent is exhausting only 200 CFM then the HVAC folks have some work to do.

    With rigid duct you can calculate the SP and get a pretty decent idea of what the performance will be. That's not the case with flex duct.