What a magnificent house. I would take a look at Benjamin Moore's historical color collection.

Here are some I like.

I think I like the last one the best.

A light-to-medium clear yellow (no tan or green overtones) is just as historical as darker tones.,it would definitely make a cheerier addition to the neighbourhood. Trim would be stark white.

Most beautiful !! Typing error !

I would go a medium-light yellow, keep white trim, and add red door. What a gorgeous house!

I too would keep it all white , or a warm white and keep the white trim around Windows . Then you can call it a " two toned White House "

Check with your local historical society and see if they have earlier photos of the home. Perhaps you can identify what colors it has been painted, or learn from them the appropriate colors for your home. Gorgeous, stately, and elegant! Keep us posted on what you do!

White.

If you want to keep the siding light I would not go pure white. I think it would be better to do a warm off white with white trim to showcase the windows and all of the stately feature.

Here are three combinations. I like Lancaster Whitewash and Edgecomb Gray the best.

Ivory white would work on the trim instead of Edgecomb Gray.

Edgecomb Gray would look good on the base.

A Blue or Grey would look beautiful!

Following. Be still my heart. Love your house.

How about a deep blue and white white trim to really show off those beautiful windows. And maybe brick steps and a path? It’s a gorgeous house!