Software
Houzz Logo Print
foram_gandhi43

short paved vs tar driveway

7 years ago
hello,
I am building a custom home in a fairly conjusted area. the lot is only under 10k SQ ft. my contract with builder says to build paved drive way but he is recommending to go with asphalt driveway as my short driveway and paved walkway stairs and patio as paving driveway and walkway will just look like a sea of pavers and take away from the beauty of of the custom home.

my home will be at the top range of the spectrum in the town. now I am torn between looks and resale value 10 years from. now when I do plan to sell.

Comments (9)

  • 7 years ago

    ^^ Agree. I would also take poured concrete over asphalt all day long.

  • 7 years ago

    I am going to disagree with the previous two posters and say that asphalt can be the better bet.


    One of the primary benefits of asphalt is cosmetic. It has a smooth, black finish and as long as you regularly maintain and repair it, it keeps that snazzy look throughout its lifetime.


    Asphalt is typically also cheaper to install vs concrete. If well maintained, asphalt can last up to 20-25 years. Asphalt repairs are also easier and less costly than concrete repairs. You can also drive on asphalt immediately whereas concrete can take up to a week to cure.


    Here's my source on this information. The choice you make depends on your needs, budget, and environment. It's just always good to have choices.

  • 7 years ago

    Concrete - if poured correctly - seldom needs repairs. And asphalt gets soft and squishy in sun in warm climates, whereas once cured, concrete is as solid as a rock. ASphalt will often ooze a gooey tar-like substance indefinitely. Asphalt requires routine maintenance to keep it in good condition while concrete is pretty much maintenance free.

    Concrete can also last a lifetime.

    IOW, there are pros and cons to both but in my view, the pros of concrete far outway both its cons as well as any pros asphalt might offer. Really just the economics but that might well be eaten up by routine maintence and replacement costs.

  • 7 years ago

    Actually... it really depends on what climate you’re in because concrete isn’t always the best option. What is your climate?

  • 7 years ago

    I also think it’s hard to go wrong with pavers. My neighbor across the street disagrees, he has a multi-million dollar home (in an area where that’s top of the spectrum) and has a huge paver driveway. We live in the Midwest, and he has complained about how often he needs to have people out to repair it and reposition the pavers. I personally wonder if they just did a total crap job to begin with because I see other neighbors with paver driveways and I never see repairs needing to be done to them... but I just keep my mouth shut. Me? I have an asphalt driveway. We recently had I completely redone because the large retaining wall supporting it started failing, it was a huge project, and we strongly considered a concrete drive (only because we knew we just could not afford pavers, too far above our budget) but the annual maintenance needed for concrete in our area was just as much as for asphalt, and we felt that if there was a problem, asphalt is more diy friendly.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    The original post for this thread is almost two months old now... I wonder what the OP chose to do...? It’s an interesting question relevant to a house on our street. They are nearing the end of spending what must be a small fortune to do a very large paver driveway for the house - which was a tear down-and-rebuilt-big-new-house in an older area. It’s a very common situation in our neighbourhood. Two things affect paver driveways here in our climate - freeze-thaw causing unevenness, and weed and tree seeds blowing in and germinating between the paving stones. There is informal betting about how long it’s going to take before the driveway at this house looks a weedy mess! Concrete lasts a bit longer but usually eventually succumbs to cracking from freeze-thaw and is a big job to tear up and replace. Asphalt has the flexibility to cope better with freeze-thaw and so resists weeds a bit better too. When it does need replacing, it is easier, faster, less expensive to replace. Many ‘high end’ new builds in the neighbourhood compromise by using a paver ‘ribbon’ on the sides with asphalt as the main surface. The ‘ribbon’ does get weeds germinating but at least is a smaller square footage to weed! So I think climate and regional tastes make a difference from practical, cost, and resale implications points of view. So, I don’t think there’s a clear ‘winner’ that applies everywhere.

  • 7 years ago

    Another thing in favor of asphalt, at least in this specific climate, is that after small snowfalls it can be 'self clearing'. Anything under an inch will melt the next day after the sun warms small openings in the snowcover. Last winter, we only bothered clearing the driveway if the accumulation was more than a foot. Otherwise, the cars just drove over it until it started clearing off.

  • 6 years ago

    thank you all for your valuable inputs. I went with the asphalt driveway simply for the looks in my case it added the variance in the material and color that adds to the overall aesthetics of the front yard. also, I got pavered patio and porch as part of the deal for 10k extra. it was a fair deal considering all things. as you all said it depends on the situation. my question was never about better material but to make a choice based on the situation. the driveway is still not done yet will post a pick once it's all said and done. thank you all for your valuable inputs.