Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_216622249

Builders and Designers Roles

7 years ago

Hello, we have been in several of the nice "luxury" home in our area and found that a few builders always seem to have the finest home and high quality cabinets, tall ceilings, high quality doors ect ect.

The question I am having is selecting these "high end" homebuilders they subcontract out all of the work and help select high end finishes with interior design.


What I am struggling with is could you have a good quality builder who maybe does not typically do these "high end" homes still build a luxury high end home with fine finishes? If we have a interior design and high budgets for all of the fixtures/allowances wouldn't the builder in essence just be an installer at that point following the designers direction on material and design?


I have a 160k difference between the two builders we are considering with all materials and allowances being equal. I think the lower of the bids builds a very nice quality home on the outside his choices for finishings on the inside are not up to our taste. That is where we are hoping Interior design can help make the proper selections / materials to our taste and our builder at that point really is more of an installer.


We own our lot, have beautiful architecture and and bid set done just looking to pull the trigger on builders now.


Sorry for the new home builder question. Thanks

Comments (28)

  • 7 years ago

    If you think your builder is "just an installer" than you should build yourself. And then check back in a year and let everyone know if you still think a builder is "just an installer".


  • 7 years ago

    I definitely do not think the builder is just an installer as he builds a great structural home but what role does a builder have in finishes that we choose with a designer?

  • 7 years ago

    There are extreme differences in the quality of craftsmanship of different builders, even with identical materials. A will use engineered studs in any location where a perfectly straight wall is critical, B will use standard 2x material. A has subcontractors who have the skill and take the time to do tight joints, B has subs that don't spend the time and so joints are not as tight.

    Even the same sub will do different quality for different builders as they know what each expects - and they charge accordingly.

    There are a gob of decisions that have to be made. Upper end builders (and interior designers, ...) will understand and guide you in the direction of higher quality while the next level down will guide you towards the next level down. After you move in it doesn't look quite right and that's when you find out how many little decisions come together to create something and how something as minor as shutters that are 1" too tall can make a nice house look cheap.

    Ray Finer thanked opaone
  • 7 years ago

    Thank you both for your comments. This is a tough one, nothing has been proven to me that either does not do a quality job. One has a lot more overhead and marketing the other little overhead, one charges 10% the other 15%. I can put more insulation upgrade to the 9ft windows and doors ect for that difference in fee's. And the more expensive is not always better? We have talked to homeowners of both builders and they all are very happy with the given builders.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Have you seen the finished work of both builders? Have you been able to take the time to examine and compare the finished work of both builders?


    The fact that homeowners are satisfied with the work of both builders means nothing unless those folks have built to the level of quality you desire, and that these folks have enough knowledge and skill to properly evaluate their finished results.


    As others have already said, builders and their subs can use identical materials and have vastly different finished quality.


    And then there's the issue of how bidding, the construction contract and construction will be handled.


    How complete will your construction drawings and specifications be? Will you have your own architect or inspector during bidding and construction to represent your interests? Or will you rely on the chosen builder for on-site decision-making during construction?


    What sort of construction contract will you have? Will you have a large or small range of allowances? How will Change Orders be identified and handled?


    There are so many issues to consider before selecting a builder. Good luck on your project.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Ideally an "artisan" builder would take pride in what he does. Here's how I am going to go about hiring a builder.

    Hire a good designer:

    Criteria - understands your your design aesthetic, flexible, has completed some high end/custom homes before (it's important!), you like his/her previous work

    Hire an artisan builder:

    Criteria - Someone who is passionate about his work, been in business for 10+ years, has built high end homes, has patience and knows his craft very well.


    I have worked with both high end builders and general contractors directly, and in my case, general contractors knew more about their craft than the builders.


    Also, you will save more by hiring the right GC :)


    Good luck!




    Ray Finer thanked AK Design
  • PRO
    7 years ago

    To be sure, you've got a difficult task.


    The challenge with comparing builders with different overheads is assessing the added value to the customer from those additional overheads. Do they translate to better communication and less frustration? A faster construction start? Less rework and a more rapid completion? Better communication during construct? Less worry for the client? A better warranty?


    The limitation of testimonials from satisfied clients is that each had the experience provided by a single builder. They can't really compare the two.


    Good luck with your task. Best wishes for a successful project and many years of happiness in your new home.


  • 7 years ago

    Following this thread as we are in the builder/GC hiring stage for a custom architectural drawn home. We've been in the planning stages for 2 years. I know my strengths and me GCing this build is not going to happen. I've built a custom home before and learned so much in the process. But, not enough to GC this project.

    Now if I could just find that little thing called trust we may be able to start this build in a few months.;-)

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    $160K less but we don't like their materials..." because they are typically part or most of the reason for less cost.

  • 7 years ago

    HI Jeffery, as I said we have picked all plumbing fixtures, appliances, flooring, tile ect ect. Those are the same materials for each builder. The bid spec from my architect is pretty simple for any builder to follow. They are bidding the lumber and windows from the same supplier, the concrete work is done by the same subcontractor. The "cheaper" GC has 10k more in his cabinetry costs.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    I misread this: "his choices for finishings on the inside are not up to our taste." and don't understand it then. Is $160K a few percent or 20%?

    The cabinetry costs should be explored. Are they both custom cabinets, finished offsite and delivered to the project interior? Is installation labor separate or included? etc.

    If all the finishes are selected & included, then $160K is hard to explain IF both are fixed price contracts, however if they are both cost plus contracts you might need more information. I have a set of architect plans in front of me with lots of OSBI line items ("owner supplied builder installed") which won't be included in my price.

    I've seen plenty of low bidders become the high cost provider for consumers. Understand the fine print and practices of each builder. Talk to previous clients.





  • PRO
    7 years ago

    I recommend to my clients to:

    • Check with people who've worked with a particular builder. (Which you've done)
    • Hire someone you get along with and trust.
    • Find out who exactly will be handling your project. You will likely meet with the owner of the company who you will find quite charming, but your day to day interaction will likely be with a supervisor. See if you can meet that person.
    • Look for a contractor who has great relationships with subcontractors. You'd be surprised by what that kind of mutual loyalty can bring to a project.
    • Educate yourself about the different kinds of construction contracts to make sure the contractural relationship works with your risk tolerance.
  • 7 years ago

    I think we're a little confused - you said that the cheaper builder's finishes are not up to your taste, but you also said that the finishes have been selected and are the same for each builder. You need to really examine where that difference comes from.

    We have built two different houses, with different price structures due to various reasons (our choice). One builder was more accustomed to build higher-end houses than ours; there were several features that he simply did what he usually did, and we ended up with some higher costs (but still within what we wanted to spend) in areas where he did what he usually does, such as a fancy coating on the garage floor. The other builder, also of custom houses but not quite so high-end, didn't include quite as many bells and whistles. For example, their projected costs for the lighting / electrical didn't include any dimmers. To us, it would have been "standard" to include some dimmers. Obviously, smaller items such as dimmers is not going to equal a $160K price difference, but there could be a number of items like that, that your more expensive builder feels are standard but the other builder does not.

  • 7 years ago

    We will have a designer pick the materials to use with either builder. The each have the same allowances for Tile, flooring, ect ect.

  • 7 years ago

    I believe the OP was saying that the finishes in houses that the builder has already built were not of the level he/she would prefer in their own house.

    I would just make sure that the builder you choose feels comfortable with the level of finishes that you want him installing. That is to say, it might be a new product he's never seen before and would have to learn how to install it per manufacturers instructions. If he and you are both comfortable with that it seems like an ok thing to go with. But make sure that they are comfortable with that. I had a builder keep trying to push for things he was more comfortable with in the past. I think he just didn't want to learn about a new product.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    For many builders, its a learning process to change and/or build to an architect's or interior designer's finish specifications. That is why many architects will refer clients to a stable of builders who have proven the ability.

  • 7 years ago

    I've been on two projects in which a mid-range GC worked on a luxury home and neither went particularly smoothly. They ended up fine in the long run, but both ran over budget and timeline. GCs have their go-to subs that they use over and over again on projects. Luxury GCs tend to use the most talented (and expensive) subs available in your location. It doesn't matter how expensive your finishes are if they're installed improperly. I highly advise using a GC whose previous projects are similar in caliber to what you're expecting in your new home.

  • 7 years ago

    The interesting thing is the "luxury builder" subs out everything to the lowest sub contractors (Many of whom are the same), and the other builder has his own crews for framing and insulation and uses the same subs on all projects. The luxury builder did not answer my question on if they use engineered studs for pocket doors and cabinet and tile walls. The luxury builder also was going to insulate our house incorrectly buy having a moisture trap having a vapor barrier then batting then only 1 inch CC Spray foam. :( These things have made me trust the "lower cost" builder. The lower cost guy simply does not have as much overhead, the Luxury builder is doing real estate and many other projects and needs to make 15%.

  • 7 years ago

    Did you get any referrals from your architect? Apologies if you've already answered this question and I missed it.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Just curious why the two builders proposed different insulation. Didn't the plans specify how it was to be done? Are you sure there aren't other areas where the approaches differ?

  • 7 years ago

    Yes it was spelled out on the bid set, they said they prefer a flash and batt method which I agreed with but you must have more than 1 inches of CC foam to prevent condensation on the side of that wall.


  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Lack of response regarding insulation is odd. Also don't like the "other projects" used as a justification for a rate/cost. Its possible that the "lower markup" builder likely has plenty of mark up in the labor they are providing directly. You are leaning towards the lower priced builder, so you want to understand how costs will be billed (there are no standards, only contractual definitions). Are the allowances marked up? Is there a single mark up at the bottom line or multiple? $160K for a $1 mil build indicates a significant difference in approach. For a $3 mil build less so and I know builders who can work with different mark ups depending on risk, time, etc. Meet with cheaper builder and discuss finishes you want in detail that are different than they've previously installed to get comfortable. Make sure the builder knows how and who will be providing decisions.

  • 7 years ago

    Understand the change order procedures. That can break any budget. Understand that using materials that a sub has not used before slows things down and makes it more expensive. If your plumber is assuming Delta fixtures and you give him California Faucets, he can't work on autopilot. I'd suspect that many of the lower priced builder's subs bids are not truly taking into account your actual higher priced materials. Expect change orders from that. The labor often is NOT "the same".


    Which is why you need to understand the change order process intimately. And you need to understand that contract type and what everyone's actual obligations are too. All too often people do not understand their building contract. That is a source of huge friction. All because they didn't spend the extra 1K to have it reviewed and explained by an attorney on the front end.


    Expect changes. Expect inadequacies in allowances. Expect inadequacies in communication. Expect a builder to build, and an architect to design. Expect to hire an Interior Designer to help you with the 12,679 decisions that you will need to make. That can eat up a chunk of that 100K difference if the more expensive guy has that design help built in on staff.


    Expect the worst, plan for the best. The more time that goes into that planning, the fewer surprises happen during the build. Surprises and changes are still the norm in any construction. Prepare yourself contractually and psychologically for that.

  • 7 years ago

    Both builders work off cost plus model. The more expensive builder has several line items in their bid for General Labor 5k, Misc Labor, 7.5k, Misc Tools 1k. Project completion 8.5k, Printing 1k it all adds up to about 25k.

    I asked the "lower priced" builder where those fees are with him and he laughed and said those are fees all included in his "10%" GC fee. We just went into another home of the lower priced builder where the clients did not use the lower cost builders "designers" and the home was beautiful. We are not looking at saving money but with the lower cost GC we were able to put all of our windows and interior doors back to being 9ft instead of 8ft which was how the house originally was designed. Spray foam entire house, and possibly move to the Marvin Modern line for our 2 16X9 patio doors.


    The "supervisor fee" was also 2.5% of the total and GC fee was 15% of the total build for the higher priced GC. The Lower cost builder is 1% supervisor and 10% GC fee. I see all invoices and my funds are paid directly to subcontractors with the lower priced builder.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    In the "cost plus" model, is there a guarenteed maximum? Do you have a sharing arrangement if the final cost is below the guarenteed maximum (50%-50%) ?


    Is it clear to you (and in writing) how allowances and change orders are handled?


  • 7 years ago

    If he's only charging 10%, all of his overhead has to be in other lines. 10% doesn't cover that at all.


    The whole ole point of any cost plus contract is that all of the subs bids are transparent to you, but the GC retains control of the hiring and firing and payouts. Having you being involved paying subs is a Big Red Flag. That tethnically makes YOU the GC, and him just a construction Supervisor or Consultant.


    I think you need to be talking with a construction lawyer. I don't think your first guy is doing Cost Plus if you aren't reviewing the documentation. And I don't think your second guy is really GCing your job if he doesn't handle the money.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    The only subs I paid directly for were the well digger and the landscaper (and the latter appeared after the GC was essentially done, and yes, I really wanted to vet out and deal with directly the landscaper choices in the area without the GC). Landscaping I consider a totally different ball of wax.

    I didn't bring in a designer. Where things didn't matter to me, the GC chose. Where they did, I chose. I did purchase some of the actual items myself (major appliances, living/dining/kitchen lighting fixtures, front door, tile, kitchen hardware/faucets/sinks), and on the Home Depot items I did get his builder's discount.

    Supervisor fee? Wasn't one.

    Change Orders... he didn't do them as in charging for them. If I was willing and able to get something different without modifying essential structure, he put it in. Mind you, he wasn't the greatest, towards the end he decided to SLOW DOWN because he was no longer interested in constructing and seriously wanted to quit and retire. He also tried to cut some construction corners along the way.


    Just to note: My home is not "high end". It is a modified log home from a kit, where I'd say about 80% of the changes from original specs were made for the kitchen. I know how I like to cook, and how things so didn't work at all for me at the previous home, so I didn't feel any need to bring in a KD. Other than the semi-minor things the GC didn't listen to, it is an absolutely a marvelous kitchen! (I will note GW was a great help at that time....)