Software
Houzz Logo Print
chazas

Different cooktop/rangetop worth it?

7 years ago
I’m about to pull the trigger on an offer on a new house. It’s builder spec house, albeit a nice one. Great kitchen, except for the all-Jenn Air appliance package with an induction cooktop. Nothing wrong with it, exactly, except I’ve always wanted a BlueStar range. Clearly, I’m not getting a range. The builder says they could run a gas line to the cooking area, so I’m wondering whether it’s worth it to do the work that would be required to either replace the cooktop with a BlueStar drop in (looks like it requires a bigger cutout) or do even bigger cabinet surgery for a rangetop, which would be my preference. Given that the existing cooktop is induction, maybe I should just get over it - I’ve never had induction, maybe I’ll like it. Thoughts?

Comments (13)

  • 7 years ago

    Try induction. Once you figure it out, it's pretty awesome.


    If they can run a gas line now, that means you can also have run one later if you just can't learn to love induction.

  • 7 years ago

    I am not going to be terribly helpful, aside from to say induction is great- I have both and much prefer induction for the ease of cleaning up (wipe with spray cleaner of choice and done.) But Blue Star is pretty easy to clean as well thanks to those open burners and seasoned cast iron grates.

    If you have any other places you would like to spend the money right now, just get the gas line and be prepared to get the range top later. I would definitely skip the gas cooktop- I don't think that is the full Blue Star experience.

    You might be surprised at how much you like induction's lack of heat radiating out from the cooking surface, how low it simmers for sauces and chocolate and how well it cranks up the heat inside the cooking vessel.

    PS Plus it is the more environmentally friendly choice apparently (I am not convinced of this argument, but the NYT was just making it today. It depends on what your power plant burns.)

  • 7 years ago

    Just personally, I love my induction.

    I've used my brother's gas range (which was pretty modern) on multiple occasions, and induction heats up just as well. And when you turn the heat down to low, induction seems to be much more reliable at holding that temp.

    Since I have propane heat, I could have gone gas. I simply chose not to do so, and am very happy. Much more efficient than standard electric cooking.

  • 7 years ago

    An induction cooktop is great. Less heat, 80% more efficient, very controllable, no gas fumes. What I did was forgo the range totally and get a Bluestar wall oven. No bending over, less space taken up when the doors are open, and I can still cook if one needs service.




  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Thanks, Jerry. Nice kitchen! The house I'm looking at has a JennAir wall oven/micro (or convection micro, I can' t tell yet) combo so I'm stuck with that, and probably wouldn't spend the money to change it out until it dies. Not my first preference but it's fine. Clearly I don't want to do any extensive cabinetry reworking at this time (other than maybe cutting to accomodate a bluestar rangetop or cooktop). Since the builder jumped at the idea I'm going to make the offer contingent on them going ahead and installing the gas line for future possible use - couldn't hurt - and leave it at that. Thanks, all.

  • 7 years ago

    I guess I can chime in. I have a 36" Blue Star range in my NYC apartment. The oven is good--the size especially--but the open gas burners are just unbelievably wonderful. I just love the range. I love that there are no electronics. There is nothing to break. After getting the BS, we bought a country home where no gas service is available. I wanted to replace the range and fridge immediately, if not sooner, so instead of having a propane tank installed, I stayed with electric and got a Bosch induction range. Honestly, I really like the induction. It is crazy fast, doesn't give off heat, and all the other things that people like about induction. I do miss the gas flame sometimes,, but we grill outside enough such that I can get my flame fix that way. But there are those electronics. We now have a propane line to service the pool and the outdoor kitchen. If my control board breaks, I will not buy another induction. I will run the propane line to the house and buy a Blue Star.


    So there you have it. Experiences on both sides with BS and induction. You can't go wrong getting the gas line and preserving your optionality.

  • 7 years ago

    if you cook a lot, get gas... blue star vs builder grade Jennair induction no comparison...

    have them drop the gas line and leave the space open

  • 7 years ago
    Thanks everyone. The house is already completed and has been sitting on the market, so I can’t tell them to leave the space open. To install a BlueStar would require stone cutout for a cooktop, or cutting a section out and reworking the underlying cabinet for a rangetop. I will probably ultimately do the latter but not via the selling builder, who just wants to get out of the project. Wish I had a better close up but you can see it here. He did agree to install my gas line. Not idea why he decided on induction in this house vs gas, the house next door has gas.
  • PRO
    7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I do dustless top alterations regularly. Expect to pay $500.00 or so. Appliance on site or I'm not coming.

  • 7 years ago

    I just heard Joe offering to come to your house :-) Take him up on that offer. Judging by the photos that he has been posting, he is a God when it comes to reworking countertops and existing cabinets.


    Unfortunately, this is a really big country though; so, you'll probably have to look for somebody local. I wish I had a local Joe...

  • 7 years ago

    Yes, I checked out his location. I’m in Northern Virginia so it would be quite a service call....

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    PS to Joe. I went with the cooktop and the cutout is a different size. The appliance company is providing the install and their charge for the stone cuts was - drum roll - $500. The builder jumped at the idea of installing the gas line because they had already done it. :-)