shauna_nep

Would you keep this green countertop?

Shauna Nep
last year

I know that darker kitchens are oh-so-in, but what do you think of these countertops? Would you keep and build a remodel around them, or replace?





Comments (92)

  • zmith
    last year

    I would definitely keep it for two reasons; 1) I love green and 2) I'm not afraid to go against the grain and do not follow trends if I can help it. :)


    The backsplash looks like it clashes. Maybe IRL it's not so bad? But that's what I would want to change.

  • Mandy
    last year

    An idea for that stone: I love the colors in this kitchen. If I had your kitchen, I'd paint the upper cabinets a similar color as these pictured (a light grey) and I would re-stain your lower cabinets a similar wood color, to add warmth without being really dark. I'd also add gold pulls and knobs to the cabinets, and replace your kitchen floor tile with lighter tile/grout, or replace with wood look tile, or wood, but just keep it light. The green color of this Island would be represented in your kitchen with the stone. It could be really pretty. I would keep a neutral backsplash because your stone is pretty but busy.

  • aprilneverends
    last year

    Agree with many others.

    I'd design around them. Way too cool, this stone is. Cabinets are too, wouldn't paint the cabinets. Especially if the counters stay.

    Flooring would be the first to reconsider.

    After deciding on flooring I'd look into changing backsplash..I'd want something more reflective, with more green to it

    Having said that-stones are very personal. If in doubt- leave by all means. If you hate it with all your might...that's a tad different story.


  • PRO
    Glo European Windows & Doors
    last year

    Countertop is gorgeous! Replace backsplash and floors with hardwoods.

  • PRO
    The Cook's Kitchen
    last year
    last modified: last year

    Green is my favorite color, so of course I’d keep them. It would be like a treasure hunt every day looking for things I hadn’t noticed before in all of those inclusions. It’s like having a mossy stream flowing through the house. You can’t get a stronger inside outside connection to nature than that!

    Id start by replacing the floors, and unitizing them through the house. That’s much easier to do before you move in. Then relax and live with it for a while to see if the splash grows on you or not. That’s a smaller job and doesn’t require so much disruption.

  • Kendrah
    last year
    last modified: last year

    Regardless of what others say, you have to love the kitchen. What do you like or dislike about the counters, backsplash, cabinet color, and floor now? Don't keep something just because it is expensive. You can have these counters removed carefully so they can be reused by someone else via donation or craigslist.

    Also, what is. your budget? These look like really nice cabinets that merit a very good paint job, which can be quite expensive. If budget is not an issue, then go for it. A good paint job can rival the cost of new cabinets sometimes.

    Personally, I think this kitchen with a new light wood floor is perfection. I love that it isn't cookie cutter and trendy. I think the counter and backsplash are gorgeous. But is your home and you have to love it. The only upside of discovering we needed massive foundation work was it gave me an opportunity to redo the only 5 year old kitchen in our newly purchased home. It seemed really wasteful, but we donated every single piece of the kitchen. A met an awesome Haitian immigrant on craigslist who reused all of our cabinets and was even grateful for our very old appliances.

  • Sue Locke
    last year

    I would definitely replace this countertop. The stone is beautiful to look at on a slab but is too busy for a work space in a kitchen where I believe one needs a peaceful background for cooking and enhancing your culinary creations on plates. This stone will rule the room. So unless you LOVE it....get rid if it.

  • ILoveMod
    last year
    last modified: last year

    No quartz! No more fake products. Please. Remember Corian???

    um, real stone goes out of style too. certain types of granite that so many people want to rip out now. or imagine a beautiful marble counter that has sink and edge cutouts that are outdated. really, there is no "stands the test of time" that everyone can agree on. I say let people do what they like unless they're designing to sell.

    on the flip side, I've seen white corian that's super gorgeous. and quartz that's so convincing, I'd never know it's manufactured. if certain styles of manufactured counters are eventually deemed outdated, at least it didn't break the bank. and really, I'm not loving the type of mining that has to happen in order to get a giant seamless slab.

  • aziline
    last year

    I love the counter tops and cabinets! The counter tops remind me of slabs you see on top of antique furniture. Please for the love don't replace it with a light/white *insert product here*. That's just the current trend and it'll be on it's way out eventually too.


    Replacing the floors would do wonders

  • PRO
    Debbi Washburn
    last year

    So there you have it - tons of suggestions conflicting and agreeing... ultimately it is up to you to choose. Half of us will tell you we love the top and half will say get rid of it... I think the question is what do you like or dislike about your kitchen? We don't live there - we can suggest and educate but at the end of the day it is your decision...

    But please do not change this space because of trends or what you see in magazines - change it for yourself and your time there.

    Best of luck!

  • Shauna Nep
    Original Author
    last year

    Thank you everyone, this advice is so great. A resounding "change the floors" is definitely a takeaway here. May live with the kitchen for a while and then see what actually bothers me about it vs. what doesn't match my pinterest boards. Much appreciated! This community is amazing!

  • Grace Reed
    last year

    Shauna, maybe I missed it but how do YOU feel about the countertop? And, if it was all the rage, would you love it or leave it?

  • rachann61
    last year

    Ok Shauna, you have tons of advice. But do you like the granite? Do you like the cabinetry? Is this a new home you have just moved into?
    Inquiring minds want to know...it is time for you to give us some more input

  • PRO
    Kiyohara Moffitt
    last year

    I would definitely NOT keep those countertops. Of course, it's subjective, but that type of stone (if it is real stone) is what I call "luncheon meat" stone. Not attractive. The color is fine, and great with the cabinets as they are complimentary colors. But that particular stone is not something to design around. Even a black leather finish absolute granite would look good.

  • chispa
    last year

    As I mentioned in my post further up, I had this exact stone and decided to get rid of it. It was just too dark/somber for the space and I have a huge skylight and live in sunny CA. I have never liked very dark counters.

    I hated that you could not see the dirt on it. With kids and a DH that doesn't always wipe the counters, I hated to put something down, only to find out that it was now covered in crumbs or sticky stuff.

    The pinky/salmon tones in the stone are a color that I don't decorate with. I also ended up gutting the kitchen because the cabinets were not of great quality and the fridge was jammed in a corner.

  • rachann61
    last year

    To Shauna
    After those last two posts I am sure you may be regretting asking for advice
    I would hope as professionals they could tone down the negativity. I would not like working with that
    Shauna you do what you want and I’m sure it will be what you want. If you want to stop this I surely understand

  • biondanonima (Zone 7a Hudson Valley)
    last year

    I happen to LOVE green, so I would keep them. The cabinets too. To my eye, the flies in your ointment are your floor and to a lesser extent, the backsplash. Luckily it should be cheaper to change either or both of those than the counter or cabinets!

  • Carie Saad
    last year

    the green countertop looks HORRIBLE!. a black with brown or cherry & tan swirls/marble would look GREAT!

  • Carie Saad
    last year

    plus a lighter floor would look great. match the floor with the backsplash.

  • Shauna Nep
    Original Author
    last year

    Based on all of this feedback, we are definitely redoing the floors (still deciding between light or dark, thought a dark wood might also be beautiful!) and replacing the countertops. I don't love them and agree that even though they are expensive/special, they are not my taste. There is still a small part of me that would love to lean into a "moody" kitchen and put in black backsplash (see inspiration below), but I think it would still bother me. I'm hoping to decide what we'll do by next week but it looks like we are leaning towards replacing it. In fact, it may be cheaper to replace the countertop than paint the cabinets!



  • cpartist
    last year

    Shauna, before you replace the countertops, I would first just replace the floor and then reevaluate. If you still dislike the counters, of course then you absolutely should replace them but in this case while I normally thing one should coordinate everything, since you're still not 100% sure about the backsplash even, I'd wait till the new floors are in so you can come up with a counter that you'll truly love.

    Are the cabinets cherry?

  • Shauna Nep
    Original Author
    last year

    @cpartist they seem to be cherry. I don't actually know! I'm so new to this. All I know is I can't stand the red accent of the wood, unfortunately...

  • Shauna Nep
    Original Author
    last year

    But they are beautifully made! The house was renovated in 2009.

  • shirlpp
    last year

    Just because it's expensive does not mean it meets your eye 'beauty is in the eye of the beholder'(as evidenced by the responses).

    I'd replace the countertop and try to salvage it for use in one of the bathrooms or give it to someone who really loves it.

  • groveraxle
    last year




  • Zalco/bring back Sophie!
    last year

    Ugh, as much as I love the look of that counter, chispa killed it for me. No countertop that camouflages crumbs and spills. Yuk.

  • ILoveMod
    last year
    last modified: last year

    LOL, when I buy a new kitchen counter, I actually want a slight pattern to hide a little bit of stuff. not trying to mask absolute filth, but I also don't want the counters to look messy every time somebody fixes a pot of coffee or makes toast. I consider it a marriage saver. but we don't have kids so it's kind of a different situation.

  • Mandy
    last year

    Whatever you do, don’t be in a rush. Spend some time(months/years) to really get a feel for what you like/want, before you do anything. Planning is key. You’ll save yourself from wasting money/time, and stress. Good Luck!!!

  • Kristin S
    last year

    I think the stone could be cool, but I'm also not a fan of the red in the cabinets. As an option for leaning in to the dark and moody kitchen, what about painting the cabinets a dark charcoal and keeping the green stone? Then a classic medium brown hardwood floor, and a light backsplash.

  • rachann61
    last year

    You do not know the power of the dark side

  • ILoveMod
    last year
    last modified: last year

    Mandy is right. it's not fun, but waiting will do you a ton of good. when I moved into my house, I wanted the kitchen reno to happen asap. now that we've been living with it for 2 years, we've come up with SO many different / better ideas for what we want done to it.

    my friends were 100% correct when they said we'd get used to things we thought we'd hate, and might wind up hating things we thought we'd love.

  • lucky998877
    last year

    Can you relocate the counters to a laundry room, outside, garage etc....even if they aren't your taste for your kitchen, they are great and could be a fit for another area.

  • PRO
    Debbi Washburn
    last year

    Just a thought - since you really don't like the red of the cabinets And you are going to change the countertop And you are going to change the backsplash And you are going to change the floor... why not find out how much more it is to paint or redo the cabinets and then wait until you have your budget and do it all in one shot since you are basically changing almost all of it already.

    Take the time to live in there for one year and save save save, then do the kitchen the way you want.

  • Shauna Nep
    Original Author
    last year

    @lucky998877 the laundry room is in the kitchen lollll

  • Grace Reed
    last year

    I strongly echo everyone suggesting you live with everything including the floors. I’m a retired kitchen designer and I’ve had clients come to me 2-3 years after doing this and realizing the cabinets and / or layout isn’t working for them. The changes will complicate a remodel immeasurably. I’d wait a year before doing anything.

  • PRO
    Aqua Kitchen and Bath Design Center
    last year

    The countertops look nice, but what are they? Is it granite? Looks matters, but are you happy with their resistance, durability, and care requirements? If you decide to keep it, I would go for a cooler palette and paint cabinets white to let the countertop really pop. If you want to keep the cabinets, then I would replace the countertops and go with something lighter to let the cabinets take the central stage. Like this, it seems to me that cabinets and countertop are competing with each other. Also, I don't feel that the flooring works with the current setting.

  • StephanieM
    last year

    It’s so important to evaluate the layout of your kitchen over some time before jumping into anything. I was eager to change flooring, add a backsplash, etc in the kitchen when we first moved in. I spent $900 on having the island professionally painted for example, only to find the layout was very undesirable, so we did a major remodel after about a year of living there. Good luck!

  • RedRyder
    last year

    Since you already said you don’t like the countertop, then you should start another thread asking for ideas that discard the countertop and keep the elements you want. However, living there for more than a year will help organize your thoughts on keeping or painting the cabinet color, keeping or changing the layout (a completely different question) and what countertop/backsplash/floor combination.
    I love green so I would have kept it. When you take it out, find out if someone wants to buy it and reuse it. It’s worth money you can put towards your changes.

  • mnmamax3
    last year

    I think with grover's sexy dark green backsplash and the right floor, you might find out you can get your moody kitchen with the counters you have.

    Did I miss what flooring is in the adjacent spaces? What is the trim color? You will need to take that into consideration when you choose the flooring. If you are just moving in, definitely be sure you like the layout first. Then explore ALL your options for each element... It's truly overwhelming.

    Another easy fix is lighting - choose bulbs in 3500-4000K for a cleaner white that might complement your current setup better.

  • Shauna Nep
    Original Author
    4 months ago

    We ended up painting the cabinets a light grey/ cream and keeping the countertops

  • mnmamax3
    4 months ago

    Looks great!! Did you end up keeping the same floor?


  • Shauna Nep
    Original Author
    4 months ago

    Yes! For now.

  • Rachel
    4 months ago

    Looks great! FWIW, I like the counter tops.

  • felizlady
    4 months ago

    Much better. The red-toned cabinets and red-toned floor were in conflict. This is lighter and fresh.

  • RedRyder
    4 months ago

    This looks fantastic! The color of the cabinets goes well with the green countertop. Good choices.

  • ljptwt7
    4 months ago

    Beautiful! So glad you kept those counters.

  • HereWeGoAgain (Z9)
    4 months ago

    Looks wonderful.

  • ILoveMod
    4 months ago

    wow, that is a major difference! well done.

  • PRO
    Debbi Washburn
    4 months ago

    That looks great! I am so glad you kept those unique countertops!