Software
Houzz Logo Print
malia320

Ugly 2-story brick fireplace needs HELP!!

7 years ago

We are purchasing a 2-story contemporary house in a very wooded setting. I see potential for the fireplace, but this super-ugly brick has GOT to go!! My first thought was to update it by painting It white, but a friend said that would cause it to lose its architectural focus. Thoughts?

I also considered faux stone panels, but they’re not cheap, when needing to cover front and back of about 20 feet high. Other suggestions for a budget makeover?

As you can see, the whole space screams 80s!


Comments (27)

  • 7 years ago

    I think I would tackle the kitchen first.

    malia320 thanked decoenthusiaste
  • 7 years ago

    ”Architectural focus” is only important if you like what it’s focusing on. And no faux anything.

    malia320 thanked flopsycat1
  • 7 years ago

    IMO the fireplace brick is a fine neutral that doesn't need change but, the mantel is wimpy. What "screams the 80's" is the wood trim around the windows/ entryway / baseboards which is an easy (but time consuming) DIY project. The floors and upper "bridge" wood are also neutrals. If the interior doors are wood leave them as is, just paint the surrounding trim. There are threads with photos showing what a huge difference this makes.

    malia320 thanked chiflipper
  • 7 years ago

    I agree, the wood trim needs to be addressed first, then the kitchen. if that was my fireplace, I'd paint it white.

    malia320 thanked User
  • 7 years ago

    Thanks for your input! I agree, the mantle is wimpy! I have to admit, I've wondered about tackling the trim first and then re-evaluating the fireplace. Are you saying you would leave the wood bridge railings, if painting the other trims white?

    I like the idea of potentially leaving wood doors and painting trim around. I will hunt for those threads.

  • 7 years ago

    The kitchen reno is definitely on the list too! I guess I was thinking the fireplace fix would potentially be a quick DIY, making an immediate impact.

  • 7 years ago

    Not sure how DIY painting the brick would be without scaffolding.

    malia320 thanked flopsycat1
  • 7 years ago

    I would leave the entire bridge as is until the rest is done, then reassess. When funds allow, that kitchen needs to GO.

    malia320 thanked chiflipper
  • malia320 thanked decoenthusiaste
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I would maybe leave the bridge railings until last and see how you feel. they might look good stained a darker color.

    you're lucky that fireplace has a nice simple look, and the grate as well. at least you aren't dealing with some crazy ugly shapes or shiny brass. not sure if you're into midcentury, but that could work really well with this space.

    malia320 thanked User
  • 7 years ago

    The home does scream 80's contemporary in all the right ways (I love those clerestories). If you think back 10-15 years ago, mid century modern was ugly. I remember when I was in undergrad my university was tossing out fiberglass Eames chairs during a building update. Fast forward to today and those chairs are highly desirable. I'd leave it. In the design world, the revival of mcm has sort of peaked and things are quickly crashing back into the 80s. Pantone's color this year is 80's coral. Color blocking is coming back. You're ahead of the curve with that home.

    malia320 thanked L thomas
  • 7 years ago

    The two things that jump out to me are the kitchen and the grill over the return air. If the grill isn't white (it may be a gloss white but the photo is picking up a reflection), I would paint or replace it for a white one.)


    I like the bridge railing, a lot. Would not change a thing about it. As to staining it darker, that isn't really something that can be done well w/o stripping the finish. Waaaay too much work and, when dark wood gets dusty, it looks dusty! Light & medium tone stains don't scream 'Dust me' so loudly. :-)


    Don't love the brick but I don't hate it, either. Would leave that alone for now & re-evaluate when there is nothing else left to do. IMO, a hasty decision now could well end up not meshing w/ later decisions as to style, etc. on changing the kitchen, etc. If you must do something, I would get a beefier mantel and change the artwork for something larger with no mat.

    malia320 thanked ci_lantro
  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Nothing wrong with the brick fireplace. But the kitchen and the oak trim could be improved up. Also don't treat your fireplace like some small colonial in a Cape Cod. It's a huge back drop for something interesting. Your out in the country.....go pick up a branch The shape and the texture are the perfect contrast for the brick. Good Luck

    Found objects.......nature's art.




    malia320 thanked BeverlyFLADeziner
  • 7 years ago

    Also - what's up with the ghost fan?

  • 7 years ago

    I think the cool white wall color is making the fireplace look worse. A warmer wall color would help it blend in and look more at home. Not a color expert but maybe something more toward beige, off-white, or greige.

    malia320 thanked Nancy R z5 Chicagoland
  • PRO
    7 years ago



  • 7 years ago

    Thank you for more input!

    Also, these are the listing photos. We are not actually in the house yet.

    I’m not at all sure about that fan, lol! The vent stands out to me too, so it will def get painted.

    I really need to sample various whites to get the color right.

    I definitely like the idea of incorporating rustic elements. I don’t really have mid century mod furnishings, but love an eclectic bohemian look so could maybe incorporate some.

    I plan to take the bulkhead and hanging cabinets out of the kitchen & potentially rework the layout & possibly add an island.

    Sounds like after painting trim & possibly making kitchen changes, I can re-evaluate the fireplace. Will definitely need to change mantle regardless.

  • 7 years ago

    I would not paint the brick. There is absolutely NOTHING wrong with it. And at this point I wouldn't do anything except move in and hang your art. Why? Because you need time to let the house tell you what needs to be done. I can't tell you the number of times I've moved into a new place thinking something was awful and needed to be redone or something I didn't like because of color, material, etc and after living with it a while, realized how it worked with the house and that wasn't the real problem.

    Live in the house for 6 months and then reassess.

  • 7 years ago

    Modernize it by painting the brick white, and doing away with the mantle and the hearth.


    malia320 thanked okibujp
  • 7 years ago

    I totally agree with Nancy If the wall colors were changed the brick would be fine, at least for the immediate future. Stark white walls rarely work, and though "modern" they often read cold. Enjoy your new house it looks like it has a nice feel to it!


    malia320 thanked rnonwheels
  • 7 years ago

    Would not paint brick. Anything painted will, inevitably, need to be repainted.


    Instead, add a mantel you like and add paneling (that goes well with the stairs) or other drywall you like either covering all of it above the mantel -- or, perhaps, all of the brick above the ceiling height as if it were a part of the adjacent wall to the left.

    malia320 thanked suezbell
  • 7 years ago

    A better idea might be to live with it a while and see if you decide you want to embrace the brick and use it as a backdrop for something interesting that reflects your own personal hobby or interest. Agree with Beverly FLADeziner about that.


    malia320 thanked suezbell
  • 7 years ago

    I would leave fireplace alone for now. Get rid of all orange stained oak. The trim and rails would be easily painted. Then a wall color that compliment the brick. Those r quick cheap if u paint diy. The kitchen needs updating the most. If money is tight then just get a quart of white that marches your cabinets paint over the oak trim ( take of door go to paint store n get a match . Then when u get a better idea on your style n home start the big ticket make over The orange n the brown brick is what dates it.

    malia320 thanked User
  • 7 years ago

    Love contemporary’s! Looks like a lot of potential there! Fun! Easy fix for that ugly brick to make it more contemporary is to paint it white and put on a simple big chunky mantle. Next up looks like you got yourself a kitchen makeover and staining all that orange wood.

    malia320 thanked MaWizz
  • 7 years ago

    I don't even think it needs a new mantle, just a giant piece of art.

    OP, since you said you like boho, I do still think the fireplace should be painted for that look. if you look up inspiration photos, boho rooms tend to have solid color backdrops since the decor is so full of color and patterns. (those brick colors look really 80s to me, not the best backdrop for the current boho look IMO.)

    however like the others said, you might want to wait. paint the trim, decorate, live in the space for a while. it might grow on you.

    painting brick is super tedious. you'll want scaffolding because you'll have to stand up there for many hours. I'm a DIYer at heart but would 100% hire somebody to do that one. so you might want to give it some time and see!

    malia320 thanked User
  • 7 years ago

    Love it, dont paint it until everything else is done and you're SURE you hate it as it.
    I agree with a larger mantle, painting out all the oak trim (try leaving the rail wood, you can always paint it later). I love the idea to leave the interior doors wood with a nice white trim, awesome.

    malia320 thanked Terra S.
Sponsored
Bella Casa LLC
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars17 Reviews
The Leading Interior Design Studio in Franklin County