Software
Houzz Logo Print
laura_larosa

Miho wase vs unknown mandarin (from Dave)

Let’s see if I can post this. I’m going to post photos in comments so I don’t risk losing the post entirely. I harvested a small mandarin from a cutting Dave sent me a while back. The tree is still tiny, but it did produce one fruit of remarkable quality. It was more tart than the miho, but it was not as ripe either. I really liked both. If I had to pick, I’d take the unknown mandarin because I prefer a little tang. The miho fruit were larger and very juicy. Both were seedless and easy to peel. Unfortunately, we ate the many kishu fruit my little tree finally produced or I would have posted photos of those as well. Those were spectacular but much smaller, which I do not mind. They were also easy to peel and seedless. I’ll post pics below. I wanted to show everyone what I harvest to help anyone decide if they want that variety :)

Comments (10)

  • 6 years ago

    Miho tree

  • 6 years ago

    Guessing correctly, especially when mandarin are involved, is a difficult task, especially when the fruit has the common color of yellow. Therefore, I will give it my best GUESS. IF as you write, the taste is as you say, exceptional. Looking at the size, plus the shape of the leaf, it could well be a page mandarin. The page mandarin is to many people the best of the best, most especially when made in to juice. Its only draw back is it small size..

  • 6 years ago

    About time you let us know about your assortment of the finest, mine are just changing colors. Can’t wait to evaluate mine, just have to wait.

  • 6 years ago

    I just planted Miho Wase inground two weeks ago. I am a little worried since it seems like you enjoyed Kishu and even an unknown mandarin more.

  • 6 years ago

    I have a Miho Wase finally coming into its own ( I almost killed from overwatering it then pruned it hard for further delay), budding and shooting now, has enough framework where I'll let it bear, more of an upright habit than owari - still weeps

  • 6 years ago

    Ok... since I posted this I’ve eaten several more miho wase and they were absolutely excellent. I think those big ones were a little over-ripe for my taste. The others I’ve eaten have had a little green on them still and they were awesome! I honestly can’t say which I like better now. Jodi, I hope Dave from NVA chimes in because he sent me the little cutting (I sent him an oro blanco). I don’t think he has page mandarins. I’m bummed because I do have a page, but it is the only tree from Harris that has not done well. I bought it years ago and I think the graft is bad because it has slowly deteriorated. I think I’m putting it in the compost pile this winter because the last branch is dying.

    So bottom line...I highly recommend the miho. My son is visiting from college next weekend and I told him I’d guard a couple for him to try. My youngest daughter stripped the kishu tree ;)

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Hi Laura, I didn’t know at first whether I was the 'Dave' you were referring to. I believe the mandarin I sent you was Armstrong satsuma. I didn’t have any others at the time. Armstrong has gotten so-so reviews by some. Mine are excellent this year. They are seedless. They sweeten and improve with cold nights. I also prefer a bit of 'tart'. Sometimes mine are best left to hang into late November and even early December. They seem to be earlier this season. Also, this season they're not as 'zipper-skinned' as usual -- that is, the skin is a bit more adherent, but taste is better than when they get 'puffy'. More mature plants tend toward alternate bearing. And few mandarins attain perfection until tree gets a bit older. Glad you are getting one already! That's what it's all about!

  • 6 years ago

    Thank you for chiming in Dave! So Armstrong it is then. I really liked both.

0
Sponsored
J.Holderby - Renovations
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars4 Reviews
Franklin County's Leading General Contractors - 2X Best of Houzz!