Software
Houzz Logo Print
hawami

Hard wired security system before insulation and dry wall?

7 years ago

We are building a house and will put in a security system. Builder wants to schedule the hard wired system (DSC) before insulation and dry wall.


What are the pros and cons of this system vs ADT type of system after the house is completed?


Thank you for your help!!!!

Comments (14)

  • 7 years ago

    We have an ADT security system, monitored by ADT. We purchased our home (a tract home) when it was in the framing stage. The builder included pre-wiring for a security system (it was a standard feature).

    If you want a hard-wired system, it needs to be wired before insulation and drywall. If you want a wireless system, it can be done after the home is completed and you move in.

    I've never had a wireless security system, so I can't give pros and cons. All I can say is I'm glad our house was pre-wired. We have two control panels - one by the front door and one in the master suite. Even coming in through the garage we have plenty of time to get to the front door to disarm the system before it goes into screaming alert mode. We can have windows/sliding doors open to a specific point before the alarm goes, or we can opt to bypass zones on the control panel.

    Someone who has had both types of systems can weigh in on the differences.

  • 7 years ago

    Pre-wired allows you to have small inconspicuous magnets sensors installed in the door and window frames .

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I've always hardwired and, when it became available, used a cellphone monitor. That way, intruders can't simply cut your phone lines rendering the system useless if you're not home. Last place we lived in, I advised both neighbours and the buyer to use cell. But the $25 monthy charge deterred them. Their homes were subsequently ransacked and the burglars had free run.

  • 7 years ago

    Not quite your question but. We just bought a SimpliSafe and are doing the continuous signal coverage should we ever lose WiFi. I liked all of the extras I could add: freeze sensors, water sensors, glass break, normal alarm plus ridiculously loud alarm to wake the dead. Really easy to set up. Will report back with more use. I like that we aren’t locked into this environment for life; if it sucks I’ll sell it off and try a new system.

  • 7 years ago

    But yes, we had the option and it was before insulation and drywall. Also wire for any home av/low voltage/ automatic window coverings now too

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    wireless sensors are large, tacky and likely will not blend in with the frames you attach them to.

    Wireless is made for the easy after market sales pitch.

  • 7 years ago

    1.75”x3” is large?

  • 7 years ago

    In the current house we used wired vs wireless. Had a wireless at one time. The battery last about 3 years, after that you start getting notices to replace batteries. With wired typically uses CA1240 12V 4Ah SLA lasts about 5 years but about the same price as x number of wiress CR*.


    I prefer the recessed reed sensors for windows and doors vs surface mounted. for ex Honeywell 944TRE and Honeywell 956RPT. End to end wireless and wired and very competitive systems. The industry is moving toward the wireless solutions. You can also purchase converters from wired to wireless. If you are using black windows those white wireless sensors look bad imho.

  • 7 years ago

    @Jeffrey R. Grenz, General Contractor and @BT the sensors are all paintable as well (and condoned by the company as such). I'm not saying wireless is the way to go, but the systems have really come a long way in the past few years (and yes, they are aggressively marketed) and are continuously being updated with new sensor types and hardware/software.

    I just got our system on sale for about $500; I also got quote for wired and they couldn't touch that price by a mile.

  • 7 years ago

    "Pre-wired allows you to have small inconspicuous magnets sensors installed in the door and window frames ."

    Yes. Exactly what I meant when I wrote, "We can have windows/sliding doors open to a specific point before the alarm goes ..." The wireless sensors that @NYCish posted, even when painted to be the same color as the window frame, stick out like a sore thumb.

  • 6 years ago

    I said I’d circle back on this. We’ve installed our simpli safe (it is dead easy to install). I painted some of the sensors (we have black/white windows going on on our main floor.
    I don’t notice the sensors at all. They were easy to spray paint. They are super small. All in, for our 3000 sq ft house with multiple points of entry, large swaths of glass, lots of freeze and water sensors,
    Co2, smoke (we already have hardwired smoke alarms but these are connected to monitoring), glass break sensors,cameras, motion detectors, 3 keypads, a few fobs, etc. it was less than $500. I won’t argue that this is the superior option by any means, but it is budget friendly and flexible. And no it’s not truly invisible. But I was pleasantly surprised! These are quick snaps at night so the sensors will show more than daytime, but no sense in trying to trick anyone.

  • 6 years ago

    I moved into my current house about 15 years ago when it was about 3 years old. The first thing I did was have ADT give me an estimate for a wireless system. Even though I prefer the better reliability of a wired system and prefer to not have visible sensors everywhere, the house has cathedral ceilings and is on a slab and has no attic so hard wiring was out of the question: there were just a bunch of places I couldn't snake a wire to. When the ADT guy started looking at where I wanted stuff installed, he noticed that every one of my many doors had a 1/4" hole drilled into the headjamb, which I'd never noticed before. As we investigated, we found the the house was entirely pre-wired for security, and all the major rooms even had wires hidden in the walls for motion detectors and other devices. I got a toner and figured out where every wire pair was. In the end, I had no need to install any wireless devices, which pleased me greatly. I recently did a trial of a small addition to my security system that was being offered by Comcast. I had it for precisely one week before I ripped it out: one of the three sensors failed within 2 days, I got false signals twice, and the monitoring unit itself kept disconnecting from the sensors.

    So here's my advice based on over 40 years of owning homes with installed security systems:

    1. Go with a wired system.

    2. Pre-wire the home since it's fast, cheap, and easy to install security wiring during the building phase.

    3. Provide wires for every door and window, and think about more wires for things like glass break detectors, motion detectors, and rate-of-rise temperature sensors for fire warning. Also, don't forget to wire your garage for these specialty sensors/detectors.

  • 6 years ago

    Have you considered using wireless security systems? It's much easier to install, no need in extra wiring, and you don't need to plan it before ending your renovation. I myself use Ajax systems to protect my house. Installers placed the system quite fast and then configured it. Batteries in detectors last for 5-7 years so no need to worry about them. I think such wireless solutions are the best choice so I recommend you to search for security companies which offer such systems.