Software
Houzz Logo Print
mcoan_91

Contractor over budget...looking for advice

7 years ago

I am looking for advice on what to do in the event of a contractor going very over budget on new construction. It was a cost plus contract (contractor fees were 20%). There were no written change orders as the contract stated were mandatory for changes with payment up front for any increase past the budgeted amount. We were not ever given any notice that we were over budget or given options to choose materials that could have saved money. Any time we ask if we were within budget we were always assured that we were. Until about 2-4 weeks before our final inspection we were told we may be a little over budget. Then the day before receiving the final bill told it was more than expected. We were given a bill for about $40k over budget. What would you advise doing?

We have been told by some people to sit down and talk with him and try to come to a reasonable agreed upon price. (Some suggested 50% but that still seems high considering the house isn't completed). Other suggested not to pay anything else or seek out the advice of a construction attorney. Have any of you been in similar situations or have any advice to give?

When I say the house isn't completed, we have received our CO however there is a temporary hold on the roof for a leak that they have been promising for months to fix that hasn't been done, it is only caulked and the rest are cosmetic things.

Comments (36)

  • 7 years ago

    Sorry you are in this situation. What was the total budget?

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    You need more information from the builder.


    $40K may be a crisis or a miracle depending on your process, budget & expectations. Since I mostly do fixed price contracts with some allowances, my clients are usually well aware of their allowance issues but often forget.


    Usually you would get a list of overages/underruns by line item and explore from there. My experience is the higher the budget, the less attention clients are willing to pay to selection budgets.


    Did you make any last minute changes? My last three clients have made 5 figure changes while impacted trades were in process on projects. Very difficult to process without stopping progress.



  • 7 years ago

    Yes, before you settle on a plan to negotiate them down to 50% of their overage I think you (and/or we) need to better understand what caused the cost increase. If you do not already have it you need a breakdown of what exactly increased in price and why. Did you make any changes to the project design, finishes, fit-out or anything else that would have caused an increase? Is this a case where the specified finishes and materials came in more than what the contractor anticipated? Then knowing this, how does this relate to the process outlined in your contract?


    Based on the nature of the overages, when should your contractor have known that you were over budget. Is this related to items in the last phase of the project, or has the contractor been withholding overages over all phases of construction? Also what percentage of the total budget do these overages represent, and is that reasonable for the backup that you have been provided? All of this is very important to know before walking into negotiations.

  • 7 years ago

    Our budget was $312k. We didn’t make any major changes during the building process other than extending our porch 2 ft on the depth. Otherwise all changes were made in the very beginning and he knew about them when we first met. After reviewing monty bills and receipts it seems to me that he under budgeted every subcontractor. He had our plans for several weeks and said that during that time he was getting bids on our project but after seeing the allowances vs final cost I think he estimated or compared to an old job. For example, electrical was budgeted $17k and was $23k. Huge difference. Concrete, block work, etc was way under budgeted. From what I can tell the only thing we went over budget on that I would have had any control over picking out was the window and door package which we were aware that I selected something more expensive and he told us since we had decided to paint the exterior of the home that made up the difference on our allowance sheet. But otherwise it were things like electrical, plumbing, grading, things like that that we didn’t really have control or knowledge of that were over budget.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Cost plus is you pay for what you want. You don’t have a hard budget. You do t even really have allowances. You have a soft estimate. You pay for what you choose, no matter what it costs. It’s not a fixed fee contract with a hard number. And there are no ”change orders”, other than if something is 100-% specd out in the original contract. There are merely choices that you pay for, plus the contractor percentage.

  • 7 years ago

    Also, before finalizing with the bank we had to get lein waivers signed by everyone and he took it to be signed by all contractors and himself included so we were quite shocked after getting the final bill that he signed a lien waiver knowing he was that far over budget.

    Maybe he didn’t know...he always says his wife takes care of all that stuff and putting the bills together. But in my opinion we paid him 20% to manage our project and advise us along the way. So some of the overages may be because he isn’t as involved in watching the bills come in and discussing with subcontractors If they go over what they had initially estimated.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Attorney up.

    Doesn't sound as good as lawyer up. I have done 3 cost plus builds in the last 10 years. Always at budget outside of our change orders. He did a poor job of budgeting which is not your fault. And, most importantly, he did a poor job of communicating the overages. Now it has been a rough couple of years for construction inflation in most areas

    How much money do you still owe him and have you got all the waivers? - although all this is for an attorney.

    I would start negotiations at 25% so that he would make $30k instead of $60k for the job. But all depends on your leverage.

    As an aside, I find 20% to be on the high side but every market and situation is different. I paid 20% for a more budget build like this that had special challenges.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    MR C, thank you for expanding on that. That helps us all understand your situation that much more. How much of your interior finishes, fixtures, appliances and equipment were selected prior to the initial cost being determined? If most of those were also settled on, I would say that there is something amiss with the process of the build. Grading and block work have been done for months now, and the subs for those trades have probably already been paid. Your builder had to know that there were cost increases in some trades for some time now even if unforeseen conditions occurred. I assume they also bid out each of the trades rather than letting them all work on pure time and material? There should have been a period near the beginning of construction when many of these overages should have been known. Did any of your bills during the process come with an accounting of how much had been spent versus how much was owed?

  • PRO
    7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I had a client who was hit with $100k in miscellaneous hourly fees from his builder at his third draw. They fired the builder and lawyers got involved. In the end, he still had to pay for the majority of the cost because of the wording of his contract. He was blindsided because he couldn't find any negative reviews of this builder before starting the project. And then he discovered the reason...the contract he signed also stated that he was not allowed to disparage this builder on social media.

    Moral of the story...read your contracts before signing them. And then hire a lawyer and have them read the contract.

  • 7 years ago

    How much of the $40k is your upgrated doors/windows and the extra wide porch?

  • 7 years ago

    This is why, if you want to stick to a budget, is to go always, always, always with a fixed price contract. Make your selections ahead on every item required and pay for all upgrades upfront. Do not make any changes ever. Even then, nothing is guaranteed but at least everything is mostly known and transparent. Let us know how it turns out and good luck.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    If you want the advantages of a Cost Plus contract with better cost control, add a Guaranteed Maximum Price (GMP). Most large construction projects are done that way often with a Shared Savings. However, that adds to the project management duties of both parties. Cost Plus contracts with no GMP are for very wealthy owners.

    What the OP needs to do now is determine if the Contactor breached the contract in any way. Of course, we can't help without seeing the contract.

    The OP also needs to ask for all of the Contractor's cost documentation, then see a lawyer to help determine if there is any grounds for negotiating a settlement. I would avoid having the lawyer contact the Contractor before you know where you stand.

  • 7 years ago

    I've always assumed that in residential construction coming in at less than 20% over budget was a huge win. With a cost plus contract and no GMP (and it sounds like very little management/oversight) it's a miracle.

    You need to read your contract, carefully, if you haven't done so before. Chances are excellent you're on the hook for the whole amount. Asking for an explanation of the overages is certainly not unreasonable.

  • 7 years ago

    The contractor isn’t over budget, YOU are over budget. Which is typical and expected, especially with a cost plus contract where you are a kid in a candy store picking out your dream products. That’s what a contingency budget is for. And it’s what an design professional as an owner’s representative is for. It keeps you on track in more ways than one.

  • 7 years ago

    For what it’s worth, our cost plus build was also way over budget, but well below the fixed price bids we received. We had reserve in case that happened. Over time, we have decided it was well worth it, however, when presented the overage bill, we were livid! Poor communication and bookkeeping out of our control led to a big surprise near the end.

  • 7 years ago

    This build is over budget less than 15%, that's pretty good for any build job. Correct above^, the contractor is not over budget, the OP is the one over budget as it's their house and their choices are what is driving the costs. Owners have significant responsibility in keeping to budget in a cost plus contract, if that's their goal.


    Budgets are best guess estimates, even the best builder who has pretty good pricing knowledge is going to produce an off target budget with home owners who aren't very clear about what they want, change a lot of things, and "just add a little here and there" to get their desired home. Most home owners report they are going to "keep it simple" and "not make any changes", yet........they all do the opposite. The builder is not responsible for paying for the homeowners want list.


    OP needs to re-read their contract, get help if it's poorly written and has a lot of gray areas. In no way should this build be compared to what happens on large construction projects, it's apples to oranges. Many small builders aren't going to agree to a GMP when working with a home owner who generally has zero knowledge about how their choices impact price. The knowledge base changes when dealing with large projects, or business to business interactions. We do both, and by far business to business projects are the easiest to deal with as the other party actually understands and takes responsibility for their side of the equation.


  • PRO
    7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Expanding on some of the recent comments above, residential construction contracts are the way risk is assigned to an owner and to a general contractor.

    There are three common types of contracts:

    1. Fixed cost or lump sum: This is where general contractor proposes a single sum to cover all materials and labor for a project. Since all of the financial risk is on the general contractor, he includes a substantial contingency amount as part of the fixed cost amount.

    2. Time and Materials: This is where the general contract is paid an hourly rate for the time for labor, plus reimbursed for out of pocket materials and fees. This places all financial risk on the owner, and frees the contractor from cost responsibility.

    3. Cost Plus Fee (and most effective when a GMP, with savings sharing below the GMP, is included). When negotiated by a knowledgeable owner and general contractor, this approach may have the greatest potential for equitable risk between owner and builder, using the GMP with a shared cost sharing when the project is completed below the GMP.

    Time and again we see postings from owners who don't understand construction contracts and find themselves in situation which could have been avoided had they understood the possible effecta of different types of contracts, especially poorly written contracts.

  • 7 years ago

    Virgil Carter - thank you for that explanation. OP- During our build in 2009, the cost of lumber and concrete varied significantly over the length of the project. Also involved in the guesstimate is the number of subs, their labor costs, and their relationships with the GC that is hard to accurately estimate. For example, one group made a mistake and GC had a fit, making them correct it at no cost. However, when skirting the deck, they scribed the dirt and proceeded to make intricate cuts where it would meet dirt. I think they charged it as a 10 hour job for 3 workers. The GC was quite open in admitting they may have made their money back for their mistake, but he’ll never use them again. So, who paid for it all? Yep, the homeowner. You may have some leverage because of the change order stipulation in the contract though.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    To the OP -

    I think you have some valid and possibly actionable concerns and I think a couple of hundred bucks to engage the services of a construction attorney might be money well spent. However, I don't think the concerns are egregious enough to warrant starting a real legal battle and think your best bet is to offer some reasonable settlement that sees everyone share a little bit of the pain but not too much.

    There are certainly duties that the contractor seems to have neglected here, such as a duty to keep you informed of costs, but depending on the contract he is probably going to have a bit of leeway on that front, so in the end the recovery just may not be worth the effort.

    Best of luck.

  • 7 years ago

    I feel like we are about to go down the same rabbit hole that we have been down recently, but there is just a lot of misunderstanding about what a contract is, what it can do, and what it can't do.

    A cost plus contract is not a blank check, in fact, it creates a much higher duty than a fixed price contract. So the idea that the contractor didn't overspend, the homeowner did is not quite right. Having said that, single family construction is a lot like the Wild West, everything is allowed until someone is willing to stop it. So I don't find it odd that contractors treat cost plus contracts like a blank check and don't adhere to the higher duty.

    When looking at a fully specified construction project a cost plus contract should be openly convertible to a fixed price contract after excavation. The idea behind a cost plus contract is control of quality through subcontractor selection, but it isn't a blank check for subcontractors. In a properly functioning cost plus contract the contractor will get bids from subcontractors and the job is awarded to subcontractors after consultation with the owner. However, those bids should represent fixed price bids in the contract. In other words, you might receive three bids for electric, but each of those bids is a firm offer. So a bid from an electrician on a fully specified house for $17,000 would require a signed change order to get up to $23,000.

    When we bid the project that we are finishing now some things the G.C. bid out to multiple contractors and some things he only bid out to one, but even then he disclosed why he wanted that subcontractor and why he didn't care about how competitive their bid was, but in all cases those bids were fixed unless there was a change order. Some bids are disclaimed for a reasonable period of time, our lumber package was a firm offer but that firm offer had an expiration date and we were notified that items we committed to after that date might have some market adjustments, but items that we were willing to commit to in the beginning were firm even if delivered later.

    -----

    I realize that a lot of contractors ballpark things and use unit pricing rather than getting detailed bids, however, that heightens the duty to be price conscious, rather than makes it go away. A contractor can't just estimate $17,000 for electric based on similar experiences and then pay $23,000 and expect the owner to eat the difference without any communication. Every cost plus contract is going to create a duty that costs be reasonable and expected. There should be no surprises and a contractor is specifically barred from telling you that your project is on budget when he knows or should reasonably know it isn't. That is considered a deceptive business practice. Does that happen? Sure, all the time and it is going to keep on happening until someone makes it stop.

    Please note, that I am not advocating that the OP be that person, in fact, it is a fools errand, but neither do I think that people should simply stand by and write checks for whatever amount the G.C. can write down on a piece of paper.


  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I agree that consulting a lawyer before decided your next move is a good idea. Before you do, gather copies of your contract and any communication you have with the builder, particularly regarding budget. If, for example, he assured you in an email or text that you were well within budget a few weeks or even months ago, I would want to make sure to let the lawyer know.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Before contesting, ask for more information.

    Most residential consists of 50-60 major line items. These should be organized into columns "budget" "actual" "variance" to analize from the data.

    Whether fixed price or cost plus most businesses do this.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    If you've got a CO, I'd move in and stall. Watch how fast he gets reasonable without an attorney.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    While I can't advise the OP on the best course of action, there is learning here that might be helpful for others considering building a new home or remodeling their home. At the risk of hijacking the thread (which is not my intent) I'd like to clarify the difference between a "budget" and a contractor's "estimate."

    A home construction "budget" is the amount of money a client is willing and able to invest in the construction or remodeling of their home. It might be broken down by category, but it's based on a number set by the client and/or their lender--not the contractor. Stated otherwise, the contractor doesn't determine your budget; you do.

    By contrast, an "estimate" is a good faith breakdown of costs likely to be spent on each aspect of construction. The estimate is (or should be) based on detailed construction plans and specifications. Typically, estimating begins by performing detailed takeoffs of the quantities of materials and labor required to construct the home. Those materials and labor requirements are then submitted to one or more suppliers and trade contractors who submit proposals to furnish the materials and/or trade labor. The estimated construction cost for the home is the sum total of all material and labor costs plus the builder's mark up for overheads and profit.

    For a given set of plans and specifications, the client doesn't determine the estimate. The price is largely baked in. For that same set of plans and specifications, the contractor affects the estimate only through the selection of suppliers, trade contractors, and the contractor's mark up for overhead and profit.

    Aligning the client's budget and the contractor's estimate is an exercise which should take place in the design phase-- when changes can be made in the plans and specifications--not during construction. More typically, the alignment is sought by seeking competitive bids from contractors or some variation of "name that tune."

    In the OP's case, the contractor has exceeded both their own estimate as well as the client's budget. This may be due to a poor estimating effort on the part of the contractor or a poorly detailed set of plans and specifications or changes during construction or differences in the cost of the client's selections versus cost allowances or cost escalation beyond the contractor's control (e.g., tariffs.) The difference between the actual cost for the OP's electrical installation, for example, may be traceable to a lack of an electrical plan or specifications (pretty common) or a failure on the contractor's part to seek a proposal from an electrical contractor or the client's specific selections of fixtures and appliances. We don't have sufficient information to know which.

    Producing an accurate construction cost estimate is critically important to a successful project outcome. Homeowners will be well served to explore how a contractor arrives at an estimate and seeing one before putting their faith in the number given.

    Producing an accurate construction cost estimate takes considerable time and effort. While many contributors here on houzz.com who get paid for their design efforts will insist that contractors provide free, detailed construction cost estimates, I submit homeowners will find it worthwhile to pay for a cost of a professional estimate that you can, well, take to the bank. It should keep the lawyers sidelined, too.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    Charles, in your view, is an estimate the same thing as a bid?


    Should a general contractor be prepared to sign a construction contract based on his estimate?


    Or is an estimate non-binding?

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    @Virgil,


    A contractor's estimate may be the basis for a bid, but it's certainly not the same thing.


    The extent to which a contractor's estimated costs would be binding would depend on the terms and conditions of the construction contract with the owner. That's lawyer territory, not mine. What I can say is that in the case of a cost-plus or management fee construction contract with a guaranteed maximum price, there is clear linkage between the two; the contractor has a clear incentive to produce an accurate estimate or risk overruns coming out of his/her pocket. If the contract price is open ended (i.e., no GMP,) the contractor's only incentives are preserving their corporate reputation and their relationship with the client. For a company like ours with a long history we value our "brand equity" and our relationships enough to take our estimating responsibilities seriously whether or not a GMP applies. I know we're not alone.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    From postings here, I think there may be confusion on the part of consumers, especially first-time builders, over an estimate and a bid.


    Many consumers may think they are the same thing, when they are not.


    Estimates may be detailed, as you describe, or they may be pulled out of thin air.


    The best question a consumer may ask is, "are you prepared to sign a construction contract for this amount?"


    If not, the estimate isn't worth very much.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    To be fair, I think many people in the industry don't understand the difference between an estimate and a bid, largely because they are not simply headings on a piece of paper. The firmness of an offer will be based on the underlying elements of the offer and not whether you call it a bid or an estimate.

    An estimate based on a fully specified and detailed electrical plan will carry more weight than a bid based on a floor plan without any lighting detail. So really to know whether you have something that is an actionable firm offer you have to know the specifics of the underlying items.

    You really just have to use the reasonable person test to determine the difference between the two. Would a reasonable contractor given that information be able to produce a detailed estimate and would a reasonable person given that estimate rely on that estimate as firm?

    --------------

    Just to be clear, my previous post was not an attempt to say that the OP received a bid on electrical, it was only to dispel the myth that a cost plus contract is necessarily a blank check for the contractor, it doesn't have to be. There are many well designed cost plus contracts that could be converted to a fixed cost contract once subcontractor selection has occurred without any additional costs.

    In the OP's situation, the problem wasn't whether or not this was an offer or a bid. The actionable problem would be the contractor's failure to communicate overages. A contractor in a cost plus contract has a affirmative duty to communicate cost variances to the client. You can't tell people everything is fine and you are on budget and then hit them with a $6,000 overage that you knew about when you told them everything was fine and on budget.

    I know that it makes for some uncomfortable confrontations, but that is the nature of these arrangements.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    @bry911--I agree, completely.


    @Virgil Carter Fine Art, a contractor may be prepared to sign a construction contract based on even a poorly prepared estimate knowing there are ambiguities in the contract, ambiguities, errors or omissions in the plans and specs, and the ability to exploit all of the above. Then there's the perennial problem of allowances where some builders will invoice the client a mark up on overages. These same problems can exist with competitive bids.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    "It was a cost plus contract (contractor fees were 20%). There were no written change orders as the contract stated were mandatory for changes ... "

    Change Orders are for work beyond the scope of the documents and they change the Contract Price. They only apply to Lump Sum contracts and Cost-Plus contracts that have a Guaranteed Maximum Price.

    Whatever is going on with your project, you either have a faulty contract or you have yet to tell us what it really is.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    A very good point RES.

    porch... change
    doors... known selection overage
    windoes.. known selection overage
    electrical... ?
    grading... overage
    concrete... overage
    block work... overage
    exterior paint vs_____? savings

    did the site have more slope to it than what was represented on the original plans? was a civil grading plan prepared?

  • 6 years ago

    We are in the process of reviewing our contract. There have been lots of comments (thank you all) but for some clarification we paid directly for 90% of the grading, rock work, plumbing fixtures, tile, and exterior paint. Those things were in our allowance sheet. We did not have an allowance for light fixtures or appliances so paid for those things directly too. According to our allowance sheet we paid $19k directly ourselves. So it has been challenging to understand how we paid that much off our allowance sheet and the contractor still went that far beyond our estimated amount. I do have better clarification now regarding the type Of contract we had and realize we could have prevented a lot by having a max amount set. The porch extension was material only cost and the window/door package overage was less than $5k over. So in my mind we made up for that in the $19k we paid off of allowances. Also, we were Never informed the electrical bid or any bid for that matter were over budget Until the final bill when all subcontractors Sent him final bills. So we were never given the opportunity to change Things to save. I just have a hard time grasping that cost plus means we don’t have to be informed and he has a blank check. It is taking advantage of a situation unless we had consented to an endless budget or overages

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Allowances are essentially a small Cost of the Work contract within a Fixed Price contract and they require Change Orders to resolve the final prices up or down.

    In a Cost of the Work contract, everything is an Allowance so that term isn't usually used.

    If it's a true Cost of the Work contract, you might be seeing bids or proposals for portions of the work and you might be asked to approve them but there would not be any Change Orders because there is no Contract Price to be changed. Basically you and the contractor keep a close eye on the buyout processing in order to determine whether you are over or under the original Budget. Its a very effective way to control costs if its done right and both parties have skilled managers. I've never seen it done without someone representing the Owner.

  • 6 years ago

    19K owes $3800 in markup to the contractor. It’s outside your loan, but not outside your contract and his supervision. So you might go through and tack on that markup to any other expenses and known overages as well. You can’t leave off that obligation.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    There would be no reason for Allowances if you had a Cost of the Work contract. All work would be carried as Budget items. Your contract is just as mysterious now as it was in your first post.

    If your contract allowed you to buy certain materials yourself then you only owe the contractor a markup on the installation but that must be made clear in the contract.

    You should get to the bottom of this issue because its likely to be the only path to a negotiated settlement.