Software
Houzz Logo Print
future_retiree

Miele refrigerator water filters vs. third-party brands

6 years ago

It’s a question asked often here but never clearly answered: Why are Miele refrigerator water filters so expensive when substitutes or alternates are priced so much less, sometimes 1/3 or 1/4 the cost?


We know Miele practices universal/unilateral pricing (UMRP), meaning no retailer can price any item for less than the price Miele sets. How do other brands sell a “substitute” or “equivalent” for so much less? For the record the Miele part number we’re talking about is KWF1000.


I believe I see part of the answer, and it involves the specifications of the filters.


Miele filters meet two NSF (National Sanitation Foundation) standards, Standard no. 42 and no. 53. For substitute filters that I’ve seen, from amazon, discountwaterfilters.net, etc., not all of them meet Standard no. 42, and none (that I’ve found) meet no. 53. Which leads to the question, what do the NSF standards cover?

  • Standard 42: Filters for visual effects, things you can see and smell, chlorine, particulates, taste, odor.
  • Standard 53: Filters for health effects, things you cannot see. Sometimes described as: 1) reduces specific health-related contaminants, and 2) these filters use carbon filtration.

NSF and these standards are easy to search and look up.


Is filtering water to this level overkill, do you need to filter your tap water given that municipal/ commercially supplied tap water meets mandated restrictions and regulations? I think this is something to be answer individually. In my case, since Miele specifies their filter as the filter to use, and even there’s some price escalation in the mix I’m going with it and for now do not plan to use the substitutes.


How did I find this? I installed a new Miele filter and looked closely at the Performance Data Sheet included with the filter, and then looked at the specifications of substitutes. The substitutes obviously do not want you to know to what level the filters perform, some of them use words like ‘uses carbon paper filtration’ or meets clean water standards, without stating what standards are actually meet. Stating it this way is purposely misleading, IMO, the third-party manufacturers want you to believe their filter is the exact same and still sells for less.

Comments (9)