Software
Houzz Logo Print
cori_dang

Rev-A-Shelf Compo waste container

6 years ago

Hi,


Does anyone have any experience with the Rev-A-Shelf Comp waste container? https://rev-a-shelf.com/17535?


I'm remodeling our kitchen cabinets and trying to decide how to add this compost bin to our layout. We are having (1) waste+recycle bin cabinet pullout. Then thinking of adding a 15" pullout for this Rev-a-shelf Comp container. But before I do that, I want make sure this product works well.


I was hoping to have the Compo bin fit under my sink, but it's too big.

Comments (15)

  • PRO
    6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    It looks good but I find a small compost container under sink is enough for me since I don’t like compost stuff or trash in my house longer than a day. We have a composter out where our garbage bin is so easy to deal with both.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    I don't have experience with this particular product, but I did my due diligence researching composting options for my kitchen remodel, and my own personal conclusion was that putting trash and recycle in cabinetry is risky enough regarding crumbs and spills, but to put compostable items in the cabinet is just too much. Unless that compost bin is sealed to the level of something like--forgive the comparison--a diaper pail, you are going to get smells absorbing into your cabinetry. There are some smaller compost bins that can be set on the countertop and emptied more regularly. If you absolutely must have a compost bin in the kitchen cabinetry, I'd highly recommend a much smaller one than the one you pictured, one that is removed daily. Here's one I particularly like because it has a flexible silicone base that can be turned inside out when emptying, and it doesn't waste liners because you can just rinse: https://www.containerstore.com/s/polder-kitchen-composter/d?productId=11008118&q=compost

  • 6 years ago

    Bottom line the more compost... the longer it is in the kitchen ....the more unpleasant it becomes to open the cabinet door ...a small plastic diaper pail with a lift lid ..in a small regular cabinet by the sink...has worked for me for many years...so one ...easily liftable ..compost bin...carried out (when it begins to smell) is much easier and more pleasant to deal with ..no need to be too scientific with this..just make it a little chore to perform as needed...we usually empty it in a compost pile since we have more property to hide one behind a garden shed..

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Thanks everyone. The thing that I liked most about this Rev A Shelf Compo bin is that it is like a diaper pail: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z7x-oNjHq2c It has a clamp mechanism (like a diaper genie), when you open the lid, the clamp opens so you can dispose your waste. When you close the lid, the clamp closes to seal everything in. I'm guessing they made it this large because of the mechanical parts and so that it can be used for regular waste OR compost.

    I agree that having 24 qt container for compost is too big, but we would empty it out every 3 days. I wish they made smaller compost bin with the clamp mechanism!





  • 6 years ago

    @CD It's your kitchen, your sense of smell, but many diaper pails are far more sealed than that. Odor control when you have powerful waste goes beyond a lid. Granted, waste in a diaper pail is going to outstrip any compost with odor, so maybe this will work for you depending on how often you empty and what you have in it.

    CD thanked Aglitter
  • 6 years ago

    @Aglitter Very good point. I don't like keeping compost for more than few days but the compost bags for these are really big, so it feels 'wasteful' to only fill it up 1/4 of the bag. I guess I'm just more sold on the clamp mechanism in hopes that it prevents odors and flies more than regular ones do. My husband doesn't think it's worth building a cabinet just for this, because if it doesn't work out - we're stuck with an extra 15" waste pullout cabinet.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    @CD 3-gallon bags are a good size and not too wasteful even if you have smelly waste to be taken out more than once per day. You can buy the cheapest liners on a roll and have the roll last a few months, or re-use your grocery plastic bags.

    It's not only the clamp you're looking for with extreme smells, it is the level of sealing properties making that lid-to-barrel connection airtight. Anything less than airtight will allow the wood inside your cabinetry to absorb smells, and no one is going to guarantee for you how easy odor removal will be if you discover it's a problem later. Your kitchen, your choice.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    We have a open-topped compost pail about that size and shape in a pull-out lower cabinet beside the garbage pail. Have had it for 20 years. With our small family, we empty it only once a week for the weekly pickup. It does not smell and we have never had insects. (Even my mother, who has a nose like a bloodhound, says it doesn't smell.) We only put plant and dairy materials into it. Animal products like meat bones, meat scraps or gravy go into a plastic bag in the freezer, which gets emptied into the container just before we take it out for pickup.

  • 6 years ago

    @partim that's an interesting method - to freeze the meat waste before disposing. Do you still store fruit/fruit peels in the compost? May I ask which container you have?

  • 6 years ago

    We also freeze meat scraps...and tho‘ i think your proposed can looks like it will work well.. i also question the need to have a big special pull out cabinet...as well as how heavy/stinky a really big bag of compost can get ...even our small one gets pretty heavy.... i sort of think these new kitchen ideas are kinda space hogs in most cases...more conventional storage is more useful to me...our little can under the sink works great for us...

  • 6 years ago

    In our freezer i keep a plastic shoe box on the bottom shelf and toss in meat scraps packed in little plastic baggies

  • 6 years ago

    A second box is for chicken scraps...and another for vegetable scraps...when they get full i put them in a big stock pot for the best chicken stock ever...

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    This is our setup. The slightly smaller front bin is for compost, the back bin for garbage. We've had this set up since 1996 so who knows where we bought those bins. Yes, we put in fruit peels, pits etc but don't get the fruit flies in there. If we have fruit flies and put the fruit in the refrigerator, they go away. They like the real thing, not the peels LOL.


  • 6 years ago

    @btydrvn To my utter surprise, I came to your same conclusion after much research for organizational features for my small kitchen, "I sort of think these new kitchen ideas are kinda space hogs in most cases...more conventional storage is more useful to me . . . ."