Software
Houzz Logo Print
turnby

Will this tile work??

6 years ago

I need input/ opinion regarding our kitchen backsplash. As you can see we have matte white slab front perimeter cabinets and a Navy blue island. The "bar wall" also has navy blue cabinetry down below with matte white "handmade looking" subway tile which is laid in a herringbone pattern . Our countertops are Silestone Calcutta Gold Eternal.

Initially the Calcutta Gold was supposed to be used for countertop and backsplash. Unfortunately the installers did such a crummy job on the backsplash that we’ve ended up having them remove it and decided to find something else. I'm wondering what others thoughts would be about using the same tile and chevron pattern on BOTH the bar wall AND the backsplash...but maybe use the gloss version of the same tile or a mixture of gloss and matte tiles (Example will be below) so that the backsplash would stand out a little more. ( I also think a little more shine might be good) Or do you think it would end up looking too drab and sterile. I tend to like monochromatic schemes and I feel like anything with a very variegated pattern or a darkish tile would be too much of a contrast for me. The woman at the tile shop thought I should bring in grey, which I can see where she is coming from with that, it would probably bring out the veining in the counter. But if I can somehow accomplish sucessfully the look Im going for I would prefer to go that route. I'll post picts of my inspiration images.


Here is an example using both matte and gloss of the same color tile.



Comments (21)

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    What a beautiful space.

    I’ve advocated for the use of gloss and matte tiles together before, but not with this kind of tile in this type of layout. You want one eye grabber. Yours is the herringbone layout. I would use the same tile in the same layout in both areas. I’m sorry using the counter material for the bs in the main kitchen didn’t work. It would have been great.

    turnby thanked eam44
  • 6 years ago

    Here are a few samples of inspiration kitchens. I probably should mention that the house is contemporary modern.












  • 6 years ago

    I would use the same tile.

    turnby thanked wolfgang80
  • 6 years ago

    Eam44 - So I should keep the backsplash same matte tile/ in the same pattern? Would you say doing the backsplash all gloss (instead of mixed) would be a bad idea as well? Do you think I'll be able to achieve an aesthetic similar to those above, or do you think that with the slab front cabinetry there won't be enough interest. I was figuring on using accessories to add more interest. Also, the cabinet handles are silver right now. We want to change them to either Gold or Black. Any thoughts there?

  • 6 years ago

    I would have the tile extend all the way up behind the range. As far as where the window is would you have it go all the way up there as well or would you end it somewhere near the bottom of the window?

  • 6 years ago

    I’d take the tile up to the soffit behind the range and around the window. For your cabinet handles, consider brass, like you have in your lighting fixtures. I think the look with the slab cabinets is beautiful. There is plenty of visual interest there. You’ve really done a lovely job. I would use the same matte white tile - it gives you plenty of visual texture.

    That said, you should do whatever you want. If you’d rather use a gloss tile there, go for it. You’ve made a lot of great choices already. Go with your gut.

    turnby thanked eam44
  • 6 years ago

    Thank you so much for your input!

  • 6 years ago

    Would it be ok/noticeable if the grout on the perimeter tile is a bit darker than the grout on the bar wall? On the bar wall it is light grey. I had considered some Thassos mosaic tile but most all of what I saw that I liked was out of my price range. I actually don't care too much for the blue ceramic tile with the white cabinets. With the blue cabinets I like it better...I tend to like monochromatic. Are you thinking that if I use the white tile it will look too plain-even if I use grout that's a bit darker?

  • 6 years ago

    I did consider one of these

    OR this oval

    OR this "pencil tile" mosaic


  • 6 years ago

    no, I was saying don't use white grout w/the white tile since the design will disappear.

    you could use a darker gray grout if you like. or use the same gray.



  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    I wouldn't use any marble from Floor and decor, Tile shop or HD.

    They all use a lesser, cheaper quality marble from china.

    you have a beautiful high end kitchen. I know tile can get expensive, but please don't use that cheap stuff. (after all you've spent on that kitchen, what's another 1 or 2K ??)

    If you have to save up for another year to afford the real Italian marble, then do that and just wait. The cheap stuff yellows, rusts, and just looks horrible when placed in a kitchen of your quality. ya know what i mean?

    one thing else about the TileShop, don't ever get their additive to their thinset mixture. it turns the marble yellow

    turnby thanked Beth H. :
  • 6 years ago

    I would do exactly the same tile in either a herringbone or a brick pattern. Keep the same color grout.

    turnby thanked houssaon
  • 6 years ago

    I wish we could have kept the Quartz. There were six seams just along the back wall, several of which were done poorly. There were several nicks along the cut lines which they tried to fill in with caulk. I have a feeling didn't buy enough quartz to get the job done properly and then pieced together the backsplash out of remenants. So disappointing.


  • 6 years ago

    Beth, I know exactly what you are saying about the marble. I totally agree. Our builder originally had us shopping for tile at Floor and Decor. So much variation between samples, lots of yellow tones. I very quickly realized that it seemed to be the "Walmart of Tile". Didn't know that about The Tile Shop.


    Houssaon just suggested possibly doing a brick pattern. What are your thoughts on brick pattern? Or brick pattern with maybe a row of pencil tile every 3 or so rows? Like a mother of pearl or a glass tile??


  • 6 years ago

    I’d say go with the first picture Beth posted-gorgeous! I saw a mix of honed/polished tile at Ann Sacks I should have taken a picture. That adds the interest I think you’re seeking without cheapening it. I don’t think you should combine pencil/brick.

    turnby thanked hemina
  • 6 years ago

    I would keep the grout color the same as well. There’s plenty of definition already.

    turnby thanked wolfgang80
  • 6 years ago

    I think it would be so pretty to put a navy herringbone tile on the back/hood wall. @celerygirl - Can you do your magic and photoshop something like the navy herringbone tiles @Beth H posted above? To the back wall in this picture? 🙏 please! 😄

    turnby thanked hemina
  • 6 years ago

    Stunningl kitchen. The slab look was your first choice, and you may regret not doing it. Hire another fabricator ? I love the solid slab backsplash, especially with your modern kitchen. Very elegant and easy to clean.


    I love your herringbone tile as a feature wall. Just enough contrast. It is a brighter (light reflective) backsplash.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Resist the temptation to use a different layout or even a different tile. You’ve already tiled half of the space. Having a different tile on the rear wall will not look bespoke, it’ll just look like you ran out of tile. I know you want it to sparkle - it will look beautiful when it’s done. And if you really want another tile in there you can make an accent beneath the range hood (I wouldn’t, but you could). But the field tile should be consistent matte white tile in a herringbone pattern.

    turnby thanked eam44
  • 6 years ago

    I think if you really want it glossy, it can work, with a few caveats. Use the same tile, same grout only change gloss level. Use the same pattern everywhere. The other wall is on a different plane and enters another space, so I feel like it can withstand a minor change. Bottom line it's up to you. Gloss is easier to clean IMO. I personally love high gloss tile. It sparkles ;^) and adds another level of finish.

    turnby thanked heatheron40
Sponsored
Wannemacher Interiors
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars26 Reviews
Customized Award-Winning Interior Design Solutions in Franklin Cnty OH