Dsnason. Lovely home. Love your fireplace wall. I would just offer that based on the L shape of your sectional, a round coffee table will only be accessible by folks sitting on the center part of each section. The square is more practical. But it’s your home so just offering a “been there done that” opinion.

To be useful for your feet, the square shape you have is best. I would look for a medium toned brown leather, which would be durable, provide some warmth without clashing with your other colors, and coordinate with your wood floors and wood window trim.

Lakeview Pied - a - Terre · More Info

I like your ottoman. may be just paint it? or upholster?

Great suggestions! Thank you all so much!