Software
Houzz Logo Print
jiggette7

Please Help Date a Pie Safe

6 years ago
last modified: 6 years ago

Hi all! I purchased this antique pie safe from someone off of facebook marketplace. The guy I bought it from said he got it from a woman who said she took it off a farm in East Texas. It was in pretty rough shape when I got it. The top wasn't fully secured to the bottom, several hinges had snapped, there was thick crud in the mesh, a layer of grime, etc. I cleaned it up as best I could, secured the top and replaced several of the broken hinges. It still doesn't stand completely straight, but I think that adds to its charm (for now).


From what I can tell, the bottom, and drawer bottoms were recently replaced. The back and one of the sides were very warped and clearly water damaged at some point. There appear to be a few layers of paint. There were also blue flower stamps on the shelf top that looked to be straight out of the 70's. I debated whether or not to keep them, but decided they didn't quite go with my decor (ha!) so I cleaned them off. We're now using it has our liquor cabinet and it adds a fun pop of color and history to our dining area!









BEFORE AND AFTER (you can see how much grime was on the mesh in comparison)



Drawer knob


Inside pie safe



(yes, I need to dust our vents lol)

Comments (15)

  • 6 years ago



    Underneath cabinet





    Bottom of drawer



  • 6 years ago


    Inside drawer



    Top of cabinet




  • 6 years ago





  • 6 years ago

    That's not a 'pie safe" that's a kitchen cupboard dating from around 1930. the screen was originally glass and used for dishes. A primitive hutch...or step back cupboard. Looks like it could possibly be oak under that turquoise? or maybe just tree wood....as one old times said when asked.
    A classic pie safe was a straight front cupboard with punched tin panels either on the sides, the front or occasionally both. A rude crude piece often with 2 drawers on tip of bottom that usually sat on the entry way and was meant to hold baked goods and other commodities that needed air and to keep them safe from mice.


    jiggette7 thanked lindac92
  • PRO
    6 years ago

    It is not a “pie safe” as you have learned from Lindac. I just hope you didn’t pay the price of one. Try stripping it…. one horrible paint job.


    jiggette7 thanked JudyG Designs
  • 6 years ago

    No I definitely didn’t pay anywhere close to what I see pie safes listed for. And I actually like the paint job haha! It’s rough, but I like the color and the character. To each his/her own!

  • 6 years ago

    The color is great! And it's probably lead paint so leaving it in place is nice and safe. :)

  • 6 years ago

    Oh my gosh, right I didn't think of that! Paint stays haha

  • 6 years ago

    Lots of those old paints had arsenic of lead in them which is what gives the paint a green tint. Not certain what kind of test can be found commercially to see. The paint was pretty but it also killed bugs that touched it.

  • 6 years ago

    Well, just don't lick it and wear a mask if you do decide to refinish. :)

    I suppose it could be waxed for extra protection (for you and IT) if it starts flaking with use. I don't normally care for distressed furniture but this one is really appealing and the paint is a big part of it.

  • 6 years ago

    That's not arsenic green....and the chemical is copper arsenate....also called Paris green....and ti's a yellow green. I'll bet that paint is "Kemtone" an early latex paint.
    Lead paint really isn't going to kill you....don't sand it without a good mask and clean up any dust with a wet cloth.....and keep your little kids from eating paint chips....
    Lead compounds taste sweet.....that's one of the reasons it's so dangerous for kids.
    And while Paris green was used as an insecticide, any of that pigment in dry paint wont have any affect on bugs.....But I used to be able to get the most wonderful ant killer....it was called Gramma Green's Ant Killer....and it was green. You put a dab on a cotton ball and leave it on your counter over night. the ants crowded around and took it back to the colony and that was the end.....but alas no more! Been outlawed....and DDT took it's place....and that was outlawed and Clorodane took it's place.....and that was outlawed.....don't know what poison is currently used.

    Back to the cupboard......the sides are probably oak fronted ply wood if the supports are oak. What are those red knobs made of? Wood? Or bakelite?

  • 6 years ago

    Great info, thanks! So far my kids have been completely uninterested in the cupboard so hopefully they continue to steer clear. My 3 year old is through wanting to randomly lick things haha! That was a weird phase...


    The knobs are wood.

  • 6 years ago

    Terro makes a boric acid liquid ant bait that does the same as described above, but it's blue...

  • 6 years ago

    I have that terro liquid ant killer on my kitchen counter this minute.......and it sort of lessens their numbers, but doesn't wipe them all out overnight like that old stuff did.