Software
Houzz Logo Print
leslie_baker20

Red Oak Floor Color

6 years ago

We have natural cherry kitchen cabinets and large built in (20 feet) cabinet for books and tv in our open concept kitchen/family room. We are going to refinish the red oak floors, but I am struggling with what color to go with. We may paint the uppers in the kitchen and leave the lowers and island the natural cherry to match the built in cabinet. Any suggestions on colors for the floor?


Comments (10)

  • 6 years ago

    I am not a person who says don't paint wood, but your cabinets are beautiful. Initially, I was going to say don't paint them and make everything else white ( white walls, counter top, and backsplash), but I looked around for an example and realized that you are going f for this look:

    https://www.houzz.com/photos/pines-home-transitional-kitchen-denver-phvw-vp~2500272

    Leslie Baker thanked traciel
  • 6 years ago

    Can the refinish wait? You seem to be 'up in the air' about the cabinets and the rest of the colour story in your home. When it comes to installation and/or renovations the floors are done LAST. That means floors WAIT. Floors are large and EXPENSIVE projects. A sand/refinish averages $5/sf.


    Not only are they large projects they take a HUGE amount of effort go have everything taken off the floors (sofa, love seat, chairs, shoes, etc) and all the soft finishes removed (all the drapes, paintings, etc). It's a lot of work.


    Paint sprays. Paint drips. Workers damage floors. Counter tops have been dropped on floors. Screws that have embedded themselves into the tread of a boot have cause tens of thousands of dollars worth of damage. When it comes to renovations you are SAFE if you EXPECT your floors to be damaged in some way.


    What I'm seeing is a nice kitchen with no pizazz. You have soft brown on soft brown sitting on soft brown with a soft brown (beige) on the walls. I call this the 'brown blahs'. It was very popular in the 2000's. An update for the kitchen could be as simple as a STRONG WHITE counter with natural red oak (as seen here) and new paint (I love white) and a new backsplash.


    I would love to see the hardware updated to give a bigger statement. You have lots of brown going on. I feel the hardware is less than impressive (nice, but nondescript).


    Natural cherry LOVES to work with blues = crisp white. The 'whiter' the white the bluer it is. The reds in Cherry spring to life with crisp white or blue slate/soap stone.


    Before you decide to forever cover up the cherry finish (the expensive wood chosen to create this kitchen in the first place), please look at the OTHER elements. Kitchens are made up of 7 elements. The floors are one, cabinets are another. That leaves 5 other elements that can be updated before messing around with the COLOUR of these two.


    Remember: floors are done LAST.

    Leslie Baker thanked SJ McCarthy
  • 6 years ago

    What the first commenter said I agree with because I’m guessing you don’t like how warm everything is??

    Leslie Baker thanked J D
  • 6 years ago

    Lighter and brighter counters and backsplash


    Ipswich · More Info


    Leslie Baker thanked chispa
  • 6 years ago

    Thank you all for your comments. I should have provided more details. This is part of a much larger project (addition of an enclosed patio, master bathroom gut and redo, addition of a new bathroom to a bedroom, and wood floors in two rooms) and we really didn't intend to do anything with the kitchen other than paint the walls. Since we are adding new wood and the floors are 15 years old we have to sand and stain them so I really want to change the color b/c I am tired of the yellow/gold color. The kitchen isn't the major part of the remodel so I don't want to spend money on replacing the granite counter tops. I really like the cherry wood and am inclined to leave them stained, but thought painting some of them would brighten them up if I go with a darker floor. I had not thought about leaving the floor natural.

  • 6 years ago

    What you are missing is contrast in the kitchen. You have brown on brown on brown with brown paint. There is nothing that delineates the cherry. Nothing.


    Painting out the kitchen (white makes cherry pop...especially if it is blue based). A very pale red oak (sanded down and then a HIGH END water based polyurethane like Bona Traffic HD or Loba 2K Supra At) floor looks VERY good together.


    The gold tones in the wood is not the wood. It is the oil based or oil modified polyurethane. The oil based polys will turn ORANGE all by them selves. In the flooring world we call this 'ambering'. Others call it ugly. Your call.


    A water based poly is CLEAR and COLOURLESS. When you sand down the red oak (which works REALLY WELL with cherry BTW) you will see how lovely the 'wheat' colour is. You can keep that pale buttery colour by STAYING AWAY from oil based finishes.


    A PALE floor will allow the cabinets to pop just as much as dark floors. But the REAL difference, in the kitchen, will come from a new counter top and paint.


    Your traditional red oak floor planks will be SUPER EASY to match. That's the beauty of sticking with a traditional wood floor. It is readily available and is relatively cheap to purchase. At 15 years of age, the floors can be redone with the newly installed hardwood. You are correct it is just about time for their refinish so might as well do it all at once.


    Good luck with your renovation. Remember: Floors are done LAST.

  • 6 years ago

    Ok I’d go ahead and paint your walls a soft white. I would also be inclined to change the countertops to something brighter and not brown. For the flooring, choose a stain that’s considerably browner than the current one HOWEVER I wouldn’t go darker as it would look strange w the cabinets IMO.

  • 6 years ago

    I actually like the color of your current flooring, but since you want a change, I’d go browner but NOT darker

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    The "problem" is the 20' built in cabinetry we can't see. Consider white or a color for that. Consider a change of counter top and backsplash.

    It's a "whole lotta "WOOD: )

    Red oak in it's natural unstained state is fine with cherry. Show the rest, and consider the rest

Sponsored
Hope Restoration & General Contracting
Average rating: 4.7 out of 5 stars35 Reviews
Columbus Design-Build, Kitchen & Bath Remodeling, Historic Renovations