Software
Houzz Logo Print
db01473

HVAC replacement quotes, are these reasonable?

6 years ago

I live in Central Massachusetts and I have two zone of hydro-air that are 20 years old. I am planning on replacing the outdoor AC units and the two air handlers. I have gotten 3 quotes so far. Two of them came in around the same price and the other one was much lower. So I am concerned that either the two high quotes are trying to get over on me, or they are correct and the low quote has no idea what he is doing. The work will be the same in all quotes as far as removing the old air handlers, old outdoor units, and replacing it all. Also the two outdoor units are 2.5 ton AC units. The first two quotes below are using the exact same air handlers from First Co. The prices below are the total for both zones. Thanks in advance.


1. Goodman GSX160301 2.5 ton 16 Seer Condensor, First Co. 30HBXB-HW air handler, $11,500 total.

2. American Standard 4A7A6030J 2.5 ton 16 Seer Condensor, First Co. 30HBXB-HW air handler, $18,700 total

3. Bryant 113ANA030BNO 2.5 ton 13 SEER Condensor, Aspen ABM304-000-WC3SL air handler, $19,500 total.

Comments (7)

  • 6 years ago

    Honestly, I'd go with the first guy. The other two are charging $7000 - $8000 more, pretty much all for labor as there's not much difference in the equipment pricing. The numbers just don't add up for me.

  • 6 years ago

    I don't know where you are. I'm in Charlotte NC and replaced my unit and moved to another location with American Standard 2.5 Ton 16 seer with a variable speed handler for $8200 approx after rebate.

  • 6 years ago

    Did you ask the contractors why they are proposing a First Co or Aspen air handler and not the matching equipment? Is the thermostat and line set being replaced in each quote?

  • 6 years ago

    Thanks for the replies everyone. Mike_home, no I never asked why they didn't have the matching equipment. I never really thought about it. Do all companies have an air handler that does hydro-air? I was thinking maybe that was the reason that the First Co and Aspen have an air handler that have everything already needed in the air handler? But I will ask them that. Also I got 2 NEST thermostats for a discount on the energy site MASS_SAVE. So they were going to just install those for me. As far as the line set. Only the most expensive quote was going to replace it. The other two were going to use a flush kit to flush out the lines and re-use them.

  • 6 years ago

    I missed the fact you have hydro-air systems. That would explain the choice of First Co and Aspen air handlers. I don't think any of the other manufactures have hydro-air air handlers.

    You need to find out why the first guy is so low in price. Does he have a good reputation as an installer? Is he a small shop and the other two are larger companies? Is the low priced guy going to be around in the future to service the equipment and resolve problems?

  • 6 years ago

    Ya, I guess hydro-air isn't too common. But where I live in Central Massachusetts it seems like quite a few people have it. So I actually got the name of the first guy from a co-worker. He basically gutted his house and put on a large addition. He had the first guy do all of the HVAC work for him. Put in heat pumps, ceiling cassettes, air handlers, etc. He was very happy with him. He also referred them to two other people he knows and they did work for them. They were happy with the work too. But they are a very small shop. I think there are only 3 of them. The middle quote is a large company, and the highest quote is a very small shop too. I hear you about being around to service it and resolve problems. That is a concern I have.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    It's always nice to have a relationship with the guy who installed the equipment for future service needs. But HVAC has become a commodity, gas-n-go, "profession". Finding a good company is a crap shoot. There will always be someone around to service any equipment you get installed and you can get a lot of service labor for $7000 - $8000!