Software
Houzz Logo Print
lwfromny

Honing marble after polishing?

6 years ago

I’m considering using Rhino White marble for my countertops. However, the slabs I have access to are polished and I really want honed. The stone yard rep told me they can be honed, but that it isn’t cheap and will change the appearance of the color and I’m stuck with it once it’s done. Does anyone have any experience with going from polished to honed? Here’s a picture if it matters. Not great light so the color looks more brown than real life. Also, is leathering preferable to homing first any reason? Thanks!

Comments (28)

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    Hi there: can they hone a small ie d for you so you can see the difference?

  • 6 years ago

    There is a dramatic difference in the look. Mine are honed and on an episode of This Old House someone had the same stone but polished. The polished stones colors were brighter. I still like mine more but if you love them now they won't be the same. Just think of polished and honed black granite. 2 very different looks.

  • 6 years ago

    I have honed Calacatta gold marble in my bathroom and love it. I always liked it better than the polished. But for the kitchen we used Montclair Danby marble and I didn't like the honed but loved the polished. I think you need to see a slab of honed Rhino white marble in person. Especially in the case of the Danby, the colors of the honed marble looked very different from the polished.

  • 6 years ago

    @sharon brindley designs Hmmm I hadn’t thought of that. I will definitely ask.

    @aziline that helps. I think that would actually be a good thing. I would like the colors to be softer - I really love the look of honed so much more than polished. I have only found a few photos of this granite, and I love all of them, and they are all honed. The color is much subtler. But I’ve been reluctant to assume that the difference is from being honed vs maybe they were just a subtler color to begin with. My designer knows my taste well and has assured me they will look great in the space even if they are polished. I think my biggest concern is that it looks too creamy and won’t look the way I want with my white cabinets, and won’t work with the tile I want for backsplash. I’m going to go back this weekend and have them show me more slabs - I may find that I feel more comfortable with others. There’s just very little in the way of marble slabs in my area, and even this stone yard is getting rid of all of it for good. But after looking at real marble quartz just looks plasticky to me (even though I have quartz and am happy with it in another home) and quartzite is even more expensive than the marble. Plus I think the corner seaming will look better with the marble because it’s not as linear as the quartzite.

    Are you happy with your marble? Everyone thinks I’m crazy to consider it but I feel like I’ve prepared myself for how it will behave and I’m willing to make the trade off of a bit more work in order to get a true natural stone.

  • 6 years ago

    @Shasta I wish I could. So far we’ve only found seven lots of marble in the whole city. Five we ruled out for various reasons. One is the Rhino White and it’s all polished. And one is a gorgeous blue marble - I’ve never seen anything like it - but it would force a significant change in the design plan that I don’t want to consider. My designer has called every stone provider in the city and this is it. To see more we would have to go over an hour away. I haven’t ruled that out though - that may be what I need to do.

    To exacerbate the issue, my alternate plan is Cambria Ironsbridge quartz, and the only Cambria dealer in the city has just been told by Cambria that they are pulling their right to sell the product. Apparently they added a few quartz products from other manufacturers to fill a niche that Cambria doesn’t play in, and Cambria didn’t take kindly to that and is cutting them off. They only have four slabs of the Ironsbridge in stock, and I need three, and they can’t get any more. So if I want to be able to consider that I have to decide quickly or (once again) go to another city for both purchase and fabrication. Ugh.

  • PRO
    6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    I've traveled 3 hours to see marble - It's worth it. However, I would ask if they can hone a small section for you. I prefer honed (especially marble). Honing usually makes the colors softer and lighter. Not so jarring but more subtle if that helps.

  • 6 years ago

    @Design Girl I think you are right. It’s just challenging right now with COVID. Weekend hours were already almost unheard of in the design space and now it’s worse because the few places open on Saturday mornings will only allow one or two customers in at a time. I hate burning vacation hours during the week to shop, but I may have to.

  • 6 years ago

    Did you have them bring those slabs outside, to see the colors in natural light?

    I wouldn't buy them without being able to do that. My slab yard only took a few minutes to get the slabs clamped, lifted with the forklift and taken outside. I looked at them for a few minutes and then they took them back inside and put them back on the rack.

  • 6 years ago

    Hi @chispa, no not yet. I will do that when I go back. I had sort of thought I should do that but hadn’t realized it was that important. I also want to see the other slabs - so far I’ve only seen that one but there are four or five more I think.

  • 6 years ago

    @dsgts I got an alert that you left a comment but it’s not showing up. I can see the beginning of it and I’m really interested in your thoughts. Would you repost if you can? Thanks!

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    IMO honed stone is just not as good as polished for staining,for sure . I would always go polished with any stone except maybe slate.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    I am a fabricator. Polished slabs can be honed. However, it should be thought of as a "special order" where you bought it even if it doesn't look like you thought it would. If the fabricator owns the slabs he should be willing to break off a corner and hone it with the caveat that the honed slab likely will not look exactly like the sample since the sample will be done by hand with a small hand tool and the honing of the slab will be done on a piece of production equipment. The difference can be quite noticeable if the hand honed piece is compared side by side with the honed slab. After a couple bad experiences I won't hone a polished slab unless its 100% paid for up front.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    I had polished & sealed marble (carrara) in a previous home and, because it is a porous stone, it definitely will mark (oils soak into it and acids (eg: lemon juice) etch it. When we first moved in I was upset every time something happened and, in the end, decided to get over it and let it get it’s own patina - in Europe, marble has been used for hundreds of years (including exteriors) and still looks beautiful. My marble was polished, so these patina marks showed up in stark contrast to the shiny surface - I think honed would have been better. No matter how careful you and your family are, it will get marked up (think about juicing a lemon) and you have to decide if you’re okay with that or not. If not, choose another solid surface. Our current home has honed quartz, which we love and appears to be bulletproof.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    honed marble is better than polished as the etching is much less noticeable Marble should not stain if a good quality sealer is used and you don’t let spills sit there for days

  • 6 years ago

    Thank you everyone for the comments. The reason I prefer honed is partly bc I like the look, and partly bc as Sharon Brindley states, I am comfortable letting the stone develop wear over time, but I think honed is more forgiving while that is happening. I do know if stains more, but the foods used in my kitchen are rarely foods that would cause a stain.

    @oldryder you are describing exactly what the stone supplier told me - you can have it honed, but you adopt the risk that you may not like it, because you are stuck with it at that point. Thank you for the idea to hone a piece. If I can find a corner that has good color on it that’s a great idea, even though it won’t be totally representative.

    One of the things I have heard is that even within the marble family some stones are much more porous than others and that I need to “do my homework” on what I’m buying. I have no idea how to do my homework on a specific marble. I’ve tried googling and searching Houzz with no luck. Is this a real thing I need to concern myself with? Or is all marble pretty much the same porosity?

    Also @Patricia Cornwell, my understanding is that honed is better for etching and polished is better for staining, correct? Based on the foods I use I believe I’m more likely to have etching than staining.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    My marble did have a good quality sealer (even reapplied, even though it was a brand new house) and etching happened instantly - we never let things sit on the counter for long periods of time - just trying to point out the potential issues before extensive funds spent. Marble takes more maintenance than other surfaces.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    Yes, marble will etch - it's a given, no way around it. Staining shouldn't occur with a good quality sealer. I don't know where OP lives, but Danby marble is less porous than many from Europe. It comes from Vermont. Perhaps call some stone suppliers in your area to see if they carry it. Some places just sell stone, others sell and fabricate. I get Danby from yards that only sell stone - I then call my fabricator (who buys it from them and fabricates for me). These stone yards let you see the stone, but your fabricator must purchase it for you.

  • 6 years ago

    @Design Girl I live in western NY (Rochester) so not far from Vermont. I’m familiar with Danby and would love to find some. I talked to my designer today and she said going to another city will be challenging, bc the fabricators in our area will only work with local stone suppliers. So we would have to find someone in another city who would fabricate and then deliver and install here. I’m not crazy about that because it means it will be a fabricator my designer doesn’t know, so we will know less about how good their work is, and also if there are service issues I expect they will be reluctant to come back. So I’m going to go back to see the White Rhino and also my designer is going to call the fabricator and see if they can source some marble and give us photos. Fingers crossed 😊.

  • 6 years ago

    I have honed, hand-polished, unsealed carrara marble on my island. It's not a mirror hard polish, or a dull hone, but a silky sheen. It hasn't stained, although I've had to poultice a couple of things, most notably dark orange pollen from an oriental lily bouquet. There are lots of etches, which I used to polish out when they happened, but after 10 years I've relaxed--I tackle only the worst ones now. I knead bread dough on it, and roll out pie crust, puff pastry, and noodles, and haven't noticed it absorbing oil--but my stone has a lot of gray in it.

  • PRO
    6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    @lwfromny - Ok, so not that far from Vermont. I live in CT and have a few places that carry Danby. I would think in Rochester there would also be a couple places that would carry Danby. I bought mine about 45 minutes from my home and my local fabricator picked it up and fabricated it for me. There was a cost for that, but for me it was worth it.

  • 6 years ago

    @Design Girl it’s been hard to find ANY marble much less a specific type. I found a supplier in Albany called Marble & Granite, Inc. and they apparently fabricate beyond that area. Not sure if they will do work in Roch but I’m going to explore it. Their website says they have a location in Milford - have you had any experience with them?

  • 6 years ago

    My rhino white was originally polished and I asked the fabricator to hone it. It looks beautiful. I think it was an additional $5 a square foot to hone.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    Yes I have visited their showroom and they have nice products. I saw they had some Danby slabs in their Westwood Ma location. If you look at the actual slabs they have, and then go to the sizes it will tell you where they are located. My daughter lives close to there so I will take a ride when we are closer to install. They are a reputable company.

  • 6 years ago

    @jkt107 wow - $5/sf is a lot less than I expected it would be. Would you be willing to post some pictures? I’ve only found two or three pictures of it and none are super helpful.

    @design girl thank you for the advice on that source. I managed to find a place today that is here and may have marble. Going to see tomorrow - fingers crossed that they have some I like and I can afford it!

  • 6 years ago

    A friend bought a house that needed lots of updating -- a most impressive change was honing the shiney stone tile floors in the living room, in place!

  • 6 years ago

    Here you are, lwfromny. We've had them for year, and so far they are holding up great. Good luck with your decision!

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    That’s very pretty marble! Love the “softness” of it.

  • 6 years ago

    I love it, too, and, at least at my fabricator, it was reasonably priced.