Software
Houzz Logo Print
jinjudo

chimney cap advice needed

6 years ago
last modified: 6 years ago

We had our chimney caps replaced by a chimney company last year and recently had an inspection by a different chimney company. They said that the caps were installed incorrectly. The company that did the inspection said that the adapter was installed incorrectly for a triple pipe and that it wouldn't allow for proper ventilation.

I'm not sure who to believe. Can anyone tell from the picture if this was installed correctly?




Comments (9)

  • 6 years ago

    Hi Tom,

    Thanks for responding and providing your expertise. We actually have three fireplaces and I've provided pictures of the makes and models below. The same caps are installed on all three. There are two Majestic wood burning fireplaces and one Marco wood burning fireplace. Majestic is still in business but Marco isn't. What type of caps would you recommend for these?


    Separately, can I get your opinion on our Marco fireplace? I've attached a couple pictures of it. One picture is the actual firebox and one picture is the gasline in our crawlspace that is hooked up to the gas logs. The previous owners of our house converted the wood burning to a gas log. They drilled a hole in the box, subfloor and drew the gasline through to the crawlspace. From the looks of the makeshift stand, they may have used a propane tank? The chimney inspector who saw this said he had never seen anything like it in his 15 years in the industry. He also said that it is no longer UL listed since the firebox was altered. He recommended a complete replacement. He quoted $9000 to replace it with a Majestic Royalton 36” zero clearance with a gas log set. I don't know if I want to replace it with gas, since there's no existing gasline to the fireplace and would have to get a gasline installed, so was thinking of going electric with a Dimplex fireplace. Can the existing firebox be repaired, or is it a lost cause that needs to be completely replaced? Any suggestions would be great. Thanks again!

  • 6 years ago

    pics here:








  • PRO
    6 years ago

    Thanks for the photos and info!


    Marco has been out of business for a long time, so the factory-supplied chimney and termination cap are unavailable, as you have likely guessed.


    Although the Majestic name is still around, all of that product has been gone as long as the Marco brand has been gone. The triple-wall chimney on those fireplaces has been gone for 20+ years.


    So you have a couple of choices on the chimney caps. Some fireplace/chimney professionals insist that nothing should ever be used except the original factory components, even the OEM wood grate & fire brick. That means if any of those components wear out and the OEM part is not available, only a complete replacement of the entire fireplace is appropriate. That may be the position of the last person to look at your fireplaces.


    However, there is a large aftermarket of fireplace products that could be considered "equal or better than" the originals, and some professionals don't mind recommending those. I am in the latter group. Although I would not suggest using a different chimney, I think the "equal or better" caps that are on the market will do the job without adding any risk. But let me be clear: Whoever is making that decision is assuming the risk.


    The downside of these "universal" replacement caps is that they are very open, and here in the South they do not provide much, if any, protection from horizontal rain.



    These caps are sold by the nominal size of the inner chimney.


    I'm pretty sure the inner on your Majestic chimneys is 8" and the inner on your Marco is 10", but I would recommend actually measuring to verify that.

    ______


    As for the gas logs in the Marco fireplace, if there wasn't a "knockout" for a gas line in the original fireplace, then drilling a hole in the floor and sticking a gas line in there is wrong. If the fireplace was not designing and tested for use with gas logs, installing a gas line and logs is a potentially dangerous modification to the firebox. Replacement is the only option. And the regulator setup in the basement is not cool either, but you probably knew that. You aren't even suppose to store 20# cylinders indoors.


    As far as replacement goes, an electric fireplace might be a nice, relatively simple project. The new Revillusion electric models by Dimplex have been very popular with our customers. Sadly, electric fireplaces, like many electric appliances, can have a fairly short lifespan. You just need to have the right expectations moving forward.


    If you really like having fireplaces in those rooms, and would like them to be more convenient, I'd suggest changing them out to gas direct vent fireplaces. We can talk about how and why if that kind of investment is worth discussing.


    I would never recommend a wood burning fireplace with gas logs. It's the worst of both worlds. Expensive to install, terrible heat efficiency and problematic operation, since an open vented fireplace requires "bought air", heated inside air, to go up the chimney to draw properly.


    Let me know if any other information would be helpful.

  • 4 years ago

    Found a leak in my house and it is around the chimney tube. I can see water marks etc. The bottom grate/holes are at least 4 inches from the chimney tube. This is a Marco fireplace. Could this be the reason for leaks in heavy rains?


  • PRO
    4 years ago

    Usually, the leak is at the collar (red arrow), which I can't see well in your photo.



    If you happen to live where you get some horizontal rain occasionally like I do, some may get some rain into the cap, but you won't see the water anywhere but around the fireplace itself, not in the attic, not at the ceiling.

  • 4 years ago

    Thank you so much for your help. I have attached another picture. Thanks again!!!


  • PRO
    4 years ago

    That's not really the orthodox method. When the chimney warms up, it moves, expanding with the heat, putting stress on that sealant.


    The correct method is to solder a collar to the flashing, like this:



    Then use the storm collar to attach to the round pipe and shed the rain. The collar shouldn't actually be caulked down.




  • 4 years ago

    Thank you again for all your help. Much appreciated!!