Software
Houzz Logo Print
dornanl

Cement board and thin set only for shower?

6 years ago

We just signed a contract for a full Master Bath remodel. The designer went over the steps for building the shower: custom mud pan with liner extending 12 inches up each wall, cement board, thin set, porcelain tile and TEC grout. Their tile installers (they have 2) don’t use a vapor barrier or liquid membrane, such as Hydro Ban. They say that their process is waterproof.

I have looked and looked for clear, definitive standards that specify how to properly waterproof a shower. Some agree with my GC’s guys, some insist on a barrier or membrane.

I need something to show my GC, if it’s true that using Hydro Bam etc. is required. A link to share would be especially helpful, since I’m up to my neck in widely disparate opinions and views. I need clarity! I don’t know enough to some down firm on this, but I’ve been on Houzz enough to know a little.

I appreciate any expert guidance you may offer.

Comments (28)

  • 6 years ago

    You want something your tile installers do not do. Isn’t that similar to trying to buy a Ford from the Chevy dealer.

    Maybe you want a contractor who is TCNA certified and your installers are not certified.

    Maybe you should require installers who are certified.

  • 6 years ago

    Thank you, but do you have guidance as to my question? I can specify the Hydro Ban if necessary, but I’m checking here for advice from the pros.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    Cement board is NOT waterproof. True, water will not degrade the board, but moisture WILL penetrate it and go right to the studs behind. They either need to staple a poly barrier to the studs or use a surface applied coating on the face of the studs. Anything else, there WILL be water or moisture intrusion to the underlying wood framing. What they are proposing does NOT meet NTCA specs.


    Personally, I like and use the Kerdi system that eliminates ANY water from going past the tille. Choose wisely, grasshopper.....

  • 6 years ago

    Cement board is not waterproof, no way no how. Mud pan should be ok. But I am not thinking to highly of anyone who proclaims to be a tile setter who thinks cement board alone is waterproof enough for the walls.

  • 6 years ago

    Thank you, millworkman and Acanti Stone. I think, because these guys have been doing tile for 20+ years, they feel the “old” way is the best way. But, I can submit a change order to specify my desired waterproofing, such as Hydro Ban. Would you happen to have a link that outlines this, so I can share? I appreciate your help and advice.

  • 6 years ago

    Tartanmeup, thank you very much for sharing the article .. very very helpful! I will also look into the TCNA Handbook so I can actually know what I’m talking about. I appreciate your help

  • 6 years ago

    Most welcome, Linda. Best of luck with your shower. Hope you'll keep us posted.

  • PRO
    6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    For the Schluter Kerdi showers, just go to www.schluter.com and look for "showers."


    Actually, try this link. https://www.bing.com/videos/search?q=kerdi+shower+installs&qpvt=kerdi+shower+installs&FORM=VDRE

  • 6 years ago

    Avanti Tile, so with the Kerdi system, no additional liquid membrane is required? My GC said his tile guys also do use the Kerdi board. Should I just request that, instead of the cement board? I appreciate your time & assistance!

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    The link from Tartanmeup is a good one...

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    Linda...The Kerdi Board is a great way to go, but the corners on the walls need to be banded with at least a 2" overlap. The board is a bit pricey and I generally do the walls with white drywall and use the Kerdi membrane. The mud floor also is covered with the kerdi and KerdiBand is used around the perimeter to get it to be completely monolithic. Once all this has dried, you have a waterproof shower system. All the tile does is make it pretty.

  • 6 years ago

    Thank you, that is very helpful. And exactly what I was looking for - clear guidance with some good links to back it up. And hey, Mike Holmes uses Kerdi too (watched his review also on YouTube 🤣)

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    Hopefully if you are asking a tile installer to go outside of their "normal" they will follow the manufactrer's instructions be it Schluter, Laticrete, Wedi, etc.. These systems are fantastic but not hard to have a crucial step missed. Many times an installer watches a video and that's the extent of their product knowledge/experience. You sure don't want to be their learning curve I bet. Best wishes on your project!

  • 6 years ago

    Live_wire_oak, thank you for sharing the link. My designer did say that the crew uses the Kerdi board too, so I can state that as my preference. They have experience with its use. Would that be the best choice then? Since it offers proper waterproofing and they know how to use it? I really don’t want to walk away if I can get this settled and know I have the best product for long-term use. I interviewed 4 designers/GCs and love the design and ideas from the one I chose, plus they’re a well-known company in my area with an excellent reputation.

  • 6 years ago

    OP,

    Just a homeowner here. I totally sympathize with the struggle to find qualified tile professionals.

    It took me years, and a very bad experience with an unqualified tile "pro" before I found someone who was truly qualified. It's awesome that you are asking these questions now. Perhaps you should insist that the GC hire a certified and experienced tile professional. Here are a few sites that helped me when I was struggling to find someone.

    www.tile-assn.com

    Click on “find a contractor” and
    enter your zip code. Let the miles radius be fairly large, like 50
    miles or so. The excellent tile pro that built all my bathrooms was
    on that site in my area, but about 40 miles away bc he was near downtown and
    I’m in a suburb.

    www.ceramictilefoundation.org

    This site has lots of good
    information on it. I didn’t find my contractor on this site, but a
    lot of people have told me that they had luck with it.

    Here’s where you click to find a
    contractor:

    www.ceramictilefoundation.org/find-certified-tile-installers


    Also, if you are a nerd
    like me and you like to read, you could download a digital version of the TCNA
    handbook. It’s less than $40. It’s over 600 pages, but
    you don’t have to read the whole thing. Read the introduction (about
    50 pages) and then read the shower chapters. You can skip all the
    other chapters such as swimming pools, etc. Reading this helped me to
    learn about the process and industry standards for water proofing and tile
    installation; it helped me to ask more informed questions.

    www.tcnatile.com/products-and-services/publications.html


    Also, I went onto the Schluter, Laticrete and other company websites and watched their online tutorials so that I could understand how a shower should be built. When I finally did find a qualified pro, he told me he prefers Laticrete and he walked me through all the steps of building and waterproofing the shower. Since I had already looked at tutorials and read the TCNA manual, I knew he was explaining it exactly correctly, and it was a great relief to me.

    When I helped my Dad remodel his house, that tiler chose a different product. So I went onto that company's website and read their instructions. I noticed that tile pro had skipped a step and asked him about it. They remedied the situation and moved forward. It's very helpful to read the manufacturer's instructions to inform yourself of the process.

    I don't recommend looking at a lot of YouTube tiling videos, but there is one person that I looked at named Sal DiBalsi. He posts informative videos. I stopped there though bc I knew I could go down an online rabbit hole of misinformation if I wasn't careful!

    While I was looking for a truly qualified tile pro, I called probably 50 people in my area and asked 1 simple question: "How do you build and waterproof a shower?" You would not believe some of the answers:

    "You have to make sure the drywall is really flat, and you stick the tile on there." (drywall?)

    "Waterproofing is nice, but you don't really need it."

    And my favorite:

    "You don't need any waterproofing because you have central AC; that will keep your shower dry."

    Live wire oak is probably correct in that you might want to part ways with this contractor and hire a different crew; or insist that the GC hire a different tile sub. If they can't explain a correct waterproofing method to you, how do you know if they've ever done it? The answer "We've always done it this way, and we've never had a call-back," is not an acceptable answer. It's frustrating that we mere homeowners have to learn all this stuff and then explain it to unqualified tile "pros." When you find a truly qualified pro, they will be able to explain exactly how they build and waterproof a shower. If you have read through the TCNA, or looked at Kerdi, Laticrete and other tutorials, and looked at some of Sal's videos, this qualified pro's explanation should comport with the information you have learned. It was a great relief to me to find someone truly qualified; a huge weight of worry off my shoulders.


    Best of luck to you.


  • 6 years ago

    Sorry, I missed your last post.

    If they use Kerdi, maybe you could go to the Kerdi site and look at their tutorials. During the project, if you have any questions, you can call the local Schluter representative. You can even ask for a site visit.

    Make sure your contract comports with what Schluter says must be done. Make sure there is a flood test in your contract, and that you are there when it is done.

    Make sure you have language in your contract that says something like "All work will be performed in accordance to local building codes, manufacturer's instructions and industry standards, including TCNA requirements." Something like that. Maybe a pro on here can recommend the best language for a clause like that.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    Oh, and Sal is a pro and his videos are quite good.....

  • 6 years ago

    AJCN, wow! Thank you!

  • 6 years ago

    Okay so now here’s a question on my current situation. I have signed the contract and placed a sizable deposit. Obviously, I should have nailed down the whole shower construction thing before signing. I feel comfortable continuing with my selected GC as long as they guarantee they will use the Kerdi board with proper installation. However.. when you all say that I should select my own tile installer with proper certification... do GCs allow that? To piecemeal out that part of the remodel only and not use “their” tile guys?

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    Depends on your GC and how they do business....

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Linda, here’s the language I used in my change order for my Schluter shower system:

    11. The Schluter System will be used for moisture management/waterproofing and will include the shower base, curb, wall, bench, niche and drain assembly. The system will be flood tested to prove substrate is watertight prior to tiling. Installer will be a qualified skilled professional experienced with the Schluter System.

    12. All workmanship, materials and construction techniques for tiling, waterproofing and finishing details will meet industry standards and methods as specified in the current TCNA Handbook and ANSI, as well as the recommendations of the manufacturer’s products being used.

  • 6 years ago

    It has been my experience that GC’s only want to use their own stable of subs. Their vetted vendors and subs are their capital. That said, they usually have more than one option for each trade. And sometimes you have to fight to get the ”A” team.

  • 6 years ago

    Millions of showers were made with wall tile directly applied to greenboard, no waterproofing of any kind. Cement board was viewed as a big improvement over that system because the substrate didn't fall apart when wet. Most of those showers lasted long enough to get to the expected lifetime of a bathroom and the next remodel. So it's not necessarily the disaster some here make it out to be.


    That said, appropriate waterproofing is another huge improvement and these days I'd find a tile setter who does it at the current state of the art. In answer to your question you really don't want yours to be the first that an installer does with a new-to-them system. Talk to your contractor and be prepared to pay a little extra if he needs to bring in a different sub.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    youve not found a pro, GC or TILER if they at this late stage are still promoting use of drywall in a wet area. Full stop.


    Contrary to opinions, once youve torn out 10s of dozens of showers you may only then agree. ITS BEEN banned for years. Cheap cut corner hack move, drywall

  • 6 years ago

    Taliaferro, I really appreciate the sharing of how you worded your change order to specify the use of the Schulter system. That is very very helpful! I’m going to copy that for my use, if you don’t mind.