Software
Houzz Logo Print
lisarontrent

House color dilema - help!

6 years ago

We are looking to paint our house or a portion of it I should say, the house is mainly a stone cottage but with a wood extension (that is over a carport due to sloping land its a ranch house design) which is all you see from the street as its at the end of the driveway - and garage is behind it also stone but with doors painted same color. There is a lot going on, the stone, a red roof, and brown trim,




including the windows, very dark bronze brown not black. Beige would be safe but boring but I am laughably terrible at picking colors. green? grey? blue? some said red but that also scares me. we will be redoing the landscaping out front so ignore that sad site lol but all the lovely trees will stay. Any feedback is much appreciated!

Comments (33)

  • 6 years ago

    That is some house! Let's assume you are keeping the stone and not painting it.

    Let's start with the garage doors. Find a medium dark color in the stone and paint out the doors. It will then "disappear" into the stone and not draw your eye from the front on the house. It can disappear into your gravel driveway.

    Next the house: Medium or darker color of stone for the siding under the stone, so the base does not float. The left side can be the same or lighter version. Next paint the roof trim, Red. Add red window boxes under those upper windows and paint the front door red. Add a planter near the front door where you can tie in more red.

    The red roof is a dominant feature so you can't ignore it. Embrace it!

  • 6 years ago

    Ah thank you all great ideas, I had not thought about doing the garage doors a different color, that does makes sense. I love flower boxes but have a toxic thumb lol but will consider that it would add interest. thank you

  • 6 years ago

    I have a toxic thumb too but manage to keep begonias alive no matter what. There are also very good fakes if you are willing to invest and remove with the seasons.

  • 6 years ago

    Do you have a photo of the front entrance?

  • 6 years ago

    Hi the stone part is the front and mostly obscured as you can see I took a closer one, the paint color is around the brown doors and under the eves. the storms are brown and we will keep them but could paint the doors but they are mostly glass here is another shot,

    thanks

  • 6 years ago

    because of the red roof, I think a medium sage green would look really good.

  • 6 years ago

    Thanks for additional photo. I'd look at the blue spruce in front as a color guide. If that turns out to be too much color, pick one of the lighter rocks' colors. The underpart of the carport should stay a light cream or other light color so it's easily visible (especially the pillar supports) as you drive through toward the garage in the way back. I would paint the main front door and the overgrown front door the same light color. It looks like these photos were taken in the fall. It's often easier to make color decisions after doing all the pruning. The trees could be limbed up following an arborist's guidance if you wanted more head room underneath.

  • 6 years ago

    thank you so much so no I just took them lol the leave are just well still there. Actually I am going to redo the landscaping that massive bush will be gone and much will be redone, I though it made sense to paint first but maybe I should do the landscaping first but I thought maybe new plants would be co-ordinated. I know nothing clearly lol I want a new deck and will hire a landscape architect or something like that to help so they will advise on the trees etc clearly its a mess lol. the blue spruce might be nice blue on the color visualizers looked nice Im just gun shy at going bold since I am so terrible with color. this helps thanks for the feedback!

  • 6 years ago

    You have a very cool house. The red roof is a crime. And there's not much you can do about it. So, you have 2 choices. You can make your colour decisions and try to tie the red roof into the overall design. Or, you can ignore the red roof and make your colour decisions on what is right for your architecture. I would do the second option. Ignore that red roof and go for a sleek, earthy, modern colour scheme. I would pull a mid taupey grey colour from that great stone and paint the siding. For the garage doors, take that taupey grey colour and go a lot darker. You say your windows are a dark brown and not black. I'd keep them as is, they look great! When it's time to replace the roof, go with a dark charcoal. And while you are having work done on the roof, change the roof line at the front of your house to include some kind of overhang or separate roof for your front door. That would give your front door some much needed presence plus keep rain off you and your guests. Good luck! Very cool house!!

    Lisa W thanked Brown Dog
  • PRO
    6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    First, have. you considered taking down the pine tree? You will save those beautiful birch trees.

    I love the red roof. It needs to be washed.

    The carport needs some kind of door.



    Green Built Modern · More Info


  • 6 years ago

    thank you brown dog, we chose the red roof lol I told you we were terrible with color! lol thank you for the feedback very helpful.

  • 6 years ago

    Not a pro. Would a "peacock blue" work? I think that it might be both attractive and dramatic.

  • 6 years ago

    JudyG we had not considered taking any trees down, we are having a landscaper come in so hopefully suggestions will be made its all really overgrown and yes some things are choking others although I love all our trees and taking any down would be hard but the birch are beautiful the glow beautifully in the morning. thanks for the feedback

  • 6 years ago

    Or a shade of teal more to the blue than the green side of the spectrum.

  • PRO
    6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    I think (hope) the pine comes down. It doesn’t look strong and I would hate to see it land on that great red roof! Birch trees are dear in my state. I love to have yours in my yard. We settle for river birch, which in itsown way is beautiful, but there is nothing like a white birch.




  • 6 years ago

    JudyG which pine tree are you talking about? we have a few, in the front? by the front door? or to the side? I feel like the one in front doesn't look in good shape but a tree guy said it was ok but treating it for something I don't know its hard to trust people when they make money off coming back and treating things.

  • PRO
    6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    In photo #3…right next to the birch. That pine has been , I hate to say, butchered. It will never fill in.

  • 6 years ago

    I agree with others that a dark teal could look amazing! or some kind of dark blue. either way, make sure it's a tad greyed out -- not too bold, so as not to clash with the red roof. it will look amazing with the stonework.






    Lisa W thanked User
  • 6 years ago

    HI Judy thank you very much, yes that's the one that I don't think is doing well and its massive and right in front of the house. I would hate to see it gone but would hate more to see it down on my house lol. I am getting a landscaper in I will definitely ask about that! thanks

  • 6 years ago

    thank you Elaine another 2nded your idea its intriguing I will have to check it out

  • 6 years ago

    Hi Houssaon yes we lost quite a few big branches this last storm. thanks for the suggestions I will check those out!

  • 6 years ago

    If the spruce is not doing well, it's better to remove it than have it come down in a storm. Painters usually need at least a foot of space between the shrubs and the house. So prune first, paint second, replant third.

  • 6 years ago

    regarding trees: yes, you definitely want to get your trees checked every year if possible. you don't want property damage or somebody to die as a result of a failing tree. plus, if there are beetles or some kind of sickness, they might catch it and get it treated before it's too late. we don't have a lot of trees on our property, but one of them is a giant. we go ahead and combine our big tree checkup with pruning of our smaller trees to make it worthwhile.

    Lisa W thanked User
  • PRO
    6 years ago

    Black is such a huge exterior color now and your house is a perfect example of where black could be used. If not black a deep hunter green.

    Lisa W thanked Southern Drool
  • 6 years ago

    ah thank you apple pie great advise on the landscaping, makes total sense now that I think about it so I need to get on that plan lol thank you so much for all the advice !

  • 6 years ago

    Lisa W by the way, your house is amazing. please tell me it still has some cool mid century details indoors too!

  • 6 years ago

    Hi ILoveMod


    I don't think so? I'm not sure what that would entail but it sounds modernish and this is definitely not that its a woodsy house more in line with the stone cottage side vs the addition. Its all wood, floors walls ceiling. massive stone fireplace, cute and cozy




    surrounded by trees so greenery out all the large windows. Its odd but charming, much like my family lol. Best part of the house is the yard to be honest. some pictures for you, massive fireplace its tri sided with one part on the outside. wood beam ceilings are nice, stained green in the office with nice views all the rooms have massive windows.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    your stone fireplace and angled wood ceilings are stunning! that's what I was referring to. the angles are mid century while also bringing in some woodsy details. it's beautiful. thanks for sharing!

  • 5 years ago

    ok so its been a long time since I posted about this but we did finally get it painted - thank you all for your feedback in the end we went with a color very similar to what houssaon was suggesting. Interesting name is Gargoyle lol by benjamin moore, it took me a minute to get used to the darker color but I think it came out well, its a more harmonious color with the rest of the house and the property in general. To my naked eye its got more green in it but might just reflecting all the trees. ok next up landscaping! woot



  • 5 years ago

    Love it. Glad you are happy.

    Lisa W thanked houssaon
  • 5 years ago

    thanks for the update. looks great!

    Lisa W thanked User
  • 5 years ago

    Looks great!

    Lisa W thanked apple_pie_order