Software
Houzz Logo Print
kathleenfitch

Responsibility for tile installed without spacers

6 years ago
last modified: 6 years ago

Hello,

We had new tile installed in our kitchen 2 years ago. For the kitchen renovation we used a designer and contractor. A few months after the completion of the project we noticed 1 chip in the tile and then a few more. We brought this to the attention of the contractor and designer, they were fixed with epoxy and paint. In March our designer called us and said the tile was installed without spacers, apparently no one read the instructions!! the space should have been 1/8“ she said that the only fix this issue to

prevent future chips/cracks is to reinstall the tile and that the cost should be divided in 3–the designer, contractor and us. This seems crazy to me, why should we be responsible when there was clear negligence on their parts? Any advice from this group would be appreciated. Thank you!

Comments (5)

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    (not a pro) I think people will want more information.

    • Do you have a written contract for the work, from either the designer or the installer? Does it say anything about how the tile is meant to be installed? (Does it say anything specific about spacers?)
    • How thick are the grout lines now? More that 1/18" (which sounds tiny), none at all...?
    • Who picked the tile? Who hired the installer? If the designer did both, then the designer might shoulder most of the blame, but only if you have a good contract specifying responsibility, quality of work and time frame for any kind of warranty or fix.
    • Photos would help

    Since the work was done 2 years ago and you have likely paid in full by now, I think a 3 way split on a fix is the best you can hope for. It stinks so it would be great if I'm wrong.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    I've never heard of improper grout size as a reason for cracked or chipped tiles...maybe a tile guy can chime in here. I always thought the grout line by the tile manufacturer was purely a RECOMMENDED grout size.


    Spacers are not required....really good tile setters will scoff at them.


    Unless you specifically asked for a certain grout size, I would think the designer and installer should replace it at their cost. If the designer just helped with the color and ordered it for you...and the tile guy is the one that billed you, then it's on him, not the designer.


    Really just depends who was in charge of your job. Did you act as GC? Did the install guy act as GC? Or did your designer act as GC? Did you pay the designer or the installer? Blame game can be tricky without designated who is in charge....and is getting paid to be in charge.

    IMO, interior designers sometimes act as GC and get ALL the liability without the pay that a GC gets. I tell my Interior designer friends all the time, they need to charge what they are worth and for what liability they are taking on.


    so many gray lines here....let us know who hired who?

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    Maybe I misread the OP. Are you saying they didn't use grout at all? I thought I read that they fixed the chips with epoxy and paint.


    Yes to what Scylla said above!

  • 6 years ago

    They did use grout but didn’t use tile spacers when grout was applied. Does this make sense?

    Our designer thinks the chips ocurred because the space between tiles is not as was specified in the instructions—to be honest I’m not sure what to think.

  • 6 years ago


    Here is one of the chips and you can get a sense for space between the tiles. when we brought this use up to the designer—who purchased the tile—and the GC who had it installed—we paid him. The designer called the tile company and found out that they had not installed it as per the directions.