Could you take a pic from further back to show the house better. I do see shutters that don’t belong and a very dark door

Door looks black but is dark green. It’s an expensive steel door that could possibly be painted black but not sure worth the effort! The black shutters are staying.

Hmm. I'm not a fan of either of them. The top one is too modern and the bottom one belongs on a farmhouse style home, not a ranch-ish one like you have. Simpler is better. I do, however, like the black color which could be applied to the styles, below:

Haas Doors- Custom Garage Doors · More Info

Garages · More Info

Of the ones you posted, the dark one is better, but without the grilles in the windows.

A few other suggestions

The first photo was for me to just get an idea on black vs white. The photo you enclosed looks like mine (stamped, rectangular) except different windows. Your photo is blurry though so not sure. Thx for sharing color preference.