Try:

BM Shaker Beige,

BM Manchester Tan,

BM Muslin and

SW Kilim Beige

It's hard to tell from your photo exactly where your tile falls in the color wheel, so I have given you a range that often works with this era of tile. You should test by painting large sample boards, and not your wall. This tile is very bossy and the way to "subdue" it is to add more. Then your eye will be drawn to your Blue accessories. As you have already painted your Vanity SW Naval, which is a purple- blue, continue adding Dark Blue accessories. I think your shower curtain is too light for the tile.

If you want to play down the orange tones, blue was the wrong color to choose. Blue and orange are complementary, and a color intensifies its complement when next to it.

Here is a close up of the tile. Thankfully most of the bathroom is the larger format tile and the orange is an accent so the blue vanity doesn’t play up the orange much. The rest of the accessories are all navy as well (other than the shower curtain, which I know does not really go, but it was purchased before we bought our condo).

Taupe or bronze would look good.

Can you a post a pic of your blue vanity? im struggling w whether or not i should paint my vanity dress blues SW. it is also a small north facing bathroom