Thanks for your message! We actually ended up going with the cobblestone gray. The pewter definitely read way too blue for us, and the colonial slate was a bit darker than I was looking to go, and the red flecks didn’t help. I tend to gravitate towarda lighter roof colors, particularly on white farmhouses, so hopefully we don’t regret our decision. The cobblestone just looked the best with our other exterior selections below.

Excellent! That’s the color I’m considering for my ranch but still not 100% certain. Please post a pic! Also, Did you go with the 30 year or40 year shingle?

Once the roof is on I will definitely post a pic. We just went with the 30 year. Selecting a roof color is much harder than I ever imagined it would be. What color is your house?

My ranch home is a painted cedar that is a soft grey color. I’m open to painting it a different shade once I do the roof. I’ll snap a pic so you can see the pitch

Side slope.

Front of home.

Landscaping and new front deck/walkway will be next this spring

Any suggestions on roof color are welcome. The paint color may go softer grey. Right now it has a touch of green in the paint color

I’m no expert on roof colors, but I think that with your home’s siding also being gray, that a lighter roof color would brighten it up and make it stand out more. Just my opinion, but everyone’s tastes are different.

You could also do weathered wood which has some nice variation between gray and tan tones.

The roof on here now is a Tamko Weathered wood. CertainTeed weathered wood is a little different and it might be an option but it has some brown in it.

Why has my roof w/Landmark Arc shinles turned black where an oak tree overhangs on than portion of the roof?