Software
Houzz Logo Print
alison_wingo33

New floor stain

6 years ago

Our floors are red oak stained 50/50 special walnut and weathered oak. The new wood upstairs was stained first and came out looking lighter than the portion that was stained downstairs (refinished red oak- 40 years old ). The flooring guy recommended adding a second coat of stain on the new wood floors to better match the old. But now the new floors look a bit darker than the old. I think overall it blends well maybe I’m overanalyzing. After all, the floors with two coats of stain are different rooms. Thoughts?

Comments (11)

  • 6 years ago

    It's hard to tell from a picture. On my monitor, it looks great. (Different lighting is going to make it look different in different places anyway, so it's impossible for me to tell whether it actually looks significantly darker.) I think you're going to just have to decide if it's going to drive you crazy. Keep in mind that once the furniture is in, you won't be staring at just the floor nearly as much.

  • 6 years ago

    Issue #1...NEVER use two coats of stain. You can and will have bonding failure in the future.


    Issue #2...New wood has different grain presentation than 40 year old wood. Different growth cycles, etc.


    Issue #3...(possible issue...can't say for sure) The new wood is a different GRADE of wood with a different cut.


    Please have the wood professional REDO (sand off the two coats of stain) the sections that have 2 coats of finish. That is an absolute NO NO.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    SJ, I have always seen the recommendation to do more than one coat of stain. Are you talking about a certain type? Minwax Polyshades, for example, specifically says to use 3 coats for the deeper color. Their floor stain is 2 coats.

  • 6 years ago

    Yes it does not look that much darker but I can tell a difference. Jslazart you’re right once furniture is in doubt I will be as fixated on it!
    SJ so you think it is worth it to pay to have them completely refinish and restrain floors?
    I just can’t imagine having them start completely over

  • 6 years ago

    No one will notice.

  • 6 years ago

    It is definitely not worth starting over. It is very close and most likely will never get closer. I think it looks great!

  • 6 years ago

    Most stains do NOT allow two coats. The reason: the second coat will sit on TOP of the wood. That coat of stain will prevent the polyurethane from 'grabbing' onto the wood in the way that it should. The only thing the polyurethane (the really expensive stuff you are paying for) can only grab the second coat of stain. It's kinda like grabbing onto a cloud...there's nothing to grab.


    The failure rate (that's when the polyurethane begins to peel off of the floor = adhesion failure) gets higher with every coat of stain. A single coat of stain = very little chance of adhesion failure. Two coats of stain = good chance of adhesion failure. Three coats (who DOES that?!) = excellent chance of full adhesion failure.


    To be clear, you do not pay to have a flooring professional (ahem...how much of a pro is this person?? really??) to correct a technical mistake such as 'two coats' of stain. The pro takes it on the chin (and in the wallet) and corrects his/her mistake BEFORE they apply the polyurethane.


    If this is at the 'stain' level, it is a very light sanding. It won't take much effort to get that stain off. They do not need to do all the sanding over again. That's already been done. They just need to remove the stain from the floor with 2 coats of stain on it.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    I'd go ahead and ask what stain was used and verify if the stain used should only be applied once or not. Every flooring stain I've looked up says 2 coats. Highly unlikely it was a polyurethane one coat stain, which can also be used over existing stain. So I'm very confused on the recommendation. Stain doesn't adhere, it soaks into the wood. Polyurethane is used after staining unless it is a one coat product.

  • 4 years ago

    How difficult is it to sand off one layer of stain? I don't like the color and they have not applied anything on top of the stain yet.

  • 4 years ago

    @UserThank you for your feedback! So if I don't like the color of the stain (it's too light/red toned), is it better to restain (losing life to the wood) or adding a second coat of stain?

  • 4 years ago

    Agreed, but should have gone towards a brown that had more green like Jacobean (hindsight!). Will an oil finish deepen enhance the color?