Software
Houzz Logo Print
dragonmastercoolkid

Leaf Guards - any recommendations?

6 years ago
last modified: 6 years ago

We are choosing between box gutters with downspouts vs half round gutters with outside brackets. Any recommendations between these? Half round gutters are more expensive.

Builder is recommending Leaf Guards for the gutters. Any recommendations which brands or what to choose for Leaf Guards? I have read mixed reviews about leaf guards and am not sure if I should go for it. What are the pros and cons? Appreciate input from forum members.

Comments (4)

  • 6 years ago

    We have standard box gutters. We have Leaf Relief. Life-changing, probably life-saving! We have a lot of trees, mainly oaks in the back yard. In front, mainly small leaves from two large honey locusts, and the “blow-over” of ours and neighboring oaks. DH still goes on the roof once or twice a year to inspect, but no longer has to clean them, except . . .

    The front of our house faces north. Our prevailing winds are from the west. The house is two story, and in front is slightly U-shaped, with a porch between the two short legs of the U. The gutter over the porch is protected from the winds by the house, so the small leaves from the locust trees do not blow off as easily, especially when they get wet. That is pretty much the area we have to clean a couple of times a year. BUT, it is so easy to do, so accessible, it is totally worth it.

    I don’t know how well they would work with half-rounds, I don’t have experience with those. But if you do a standard box gutter, I share my good experience with Leaf Relief.

    AB thanked bpath
  • 6 years ago

    We have normal gutters. We have a narrow city lot and our neighbors have a ridiculous silver maple that has a 80 foot canopy that stretches about 2/3 across our property and drops all sorts of crap multiple times a year. And in fall, the leaves don't drop until after the first snow, so it's impossible to get them out before winter. Worst tree ever. Anyway, we thought about putting leaf guards on it and had the company (I forget which) come out to give us a spiel but ultimately decided against it. The price we were quoted would have taken about 20 years of 3x per year gutter cleaning cost to recoup. We have a 2 story house so we aren't getting up on a ladder to do it ourselves, and decided that we'd just pay for gutter cleaning in the likely chance that we won't be living here in 20 years, and even if we are, it's not such a huge difference anyway. So, for us it was a cost/benefit.

  • 6 years ago

    We are choosing between box gutters with downspouts vs half round gutters with outside brackets.

    I can't help you with the leaf guard issue. Since you're debating between the two different styles--those outside brackets are good for accumulating dirt, gunk, etc.. Box gutters w/ hidden brackets are a lot easier to clean. This only matters if you're doing the cleaning work yourself.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    I think you've got two separate, but related questions: First, whether you use a K-style or a half-round gutter. That depends on the architectural style of the home and how much alteration is required to the existing cornice in order to install them. Half-round gutters can look beautiful on one home and downright ugly on another.


    The second question is what type of gutter cover to use to help keep debris out of the gutters. In the case of half-round gutters, the answer may be none at all because they detract from the look. For a K-style gutter, I don't think there is much difference between the various options.