I like the dark. It meshes with the dark door and recedes nicely

dark

The dark seems a little ominous, but I like it better.

love the dark

(look at Urban Bronze too)

if you try and bring in some cedar wood somewhere, it will also help soften the dark look

black and darker gray

and you could consider lime washing the brick

Liking the light color - agree that somehow the all dark looks ominous. I see the “shaded gray” clearly around windows but it looks white for fascia at roof line -maybe just photo? The entry looks too cave like with dark doors & trim around window. Any thoughts of color on door & the lighter trim color around the window trim? Can you try that with your photo shop trick? BTW my vote is no!!! If you’re even considering suggested lime wash or paint on that brick as an option.

I think the bronze would be a good choice not so dark but IMO the light ones are too light and look like cheap vinyl replacements I sure do hate those 2 arched windows so I think the dark will also make those less in your face. Landscaping IMO is what is desperately needed and no cedar on that home. Why are the windows on the left closed in ?

I'm not a pro, but I vote for the dark.

Dark, but make sure you purchase a quality product if you are in an area that sees high temperatures. As the less expensive (cheaper vinyl) windows do not do well in that type climate.

Dark as well.

Dark

Dark definitely. White very blah imo

I prefer white. IMO dark windows are depressing.