Software
Houzz Logo Print
annabee68

Bay window above a Fireplace?

6 years ago

We have an old 1950 fire place in our small living room (13' x 15') that was once wood burning and is now natural gas burning. Long story short, I would like more light in the living room and we need to remove the chimney and do not want to reinstall it, and the current fire place design is a not-so-awesome bat entry point. So I know windows have been placed above fireplaces before, but does anyone have thoughts on a bay window above a fireplace? (Fire place would be vent-less style or rerouted to vent with our natural gas furnace flue)

Comments (9)

  • PRO
    6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    What???? Post a picture , and how is the FP being vented now since ventless gas FPs are illegal where I live and should be everywhere .

  • 6 years ago

    As I mentioned we have a chimney and a furnace flue. Chimeny is for the fireplace, furnace flue is for the furnace. Our fire place is natural vent style so it pulls intake air from the room and then vents out the chimney. If we stick with our exact FP style we'll have the contractor re-route the FP over to the furnace flue. For vent-less, they make fire places for ethanol, propane, and natural gas and yes they illegal in places but not all. There is also electric fire place which as you know is naturally ventless as it's not needed. We could also do direct vent and not reroute to our furnace flue but then I'd probably have two pipes going up the house and not sure how I feel on that.


    I can attach a photo but basically it's a full remodel job for the fire place, mantel, and area above the mantel as well as the siding on the other side because the chimney needs to go so does the bat-entry points. My question is simply has anyone seen someone using the mantel of a fire place o put a bay window over. I've seen plenty of wide or arch windows above fire place (assume electric, ventless, or re-routed direct vent) options, but not a bay).

  • 6 years ago

    I just can’t picture how a bay window would work in this situation. What about just adding a window above and to the sides? Would that be possible? If not, I think I’d just do a flat one above.








    Anna S thanked Jilly
  • 6 years ago

    Thanks Jinx! In my head I just want a place for plants (thus bay), but that last photo with the mantle lined up nicely with the window would work really nicely to check the boxes we are trying to obtain (more natural light (us) not redoing the floors (him), place for plants (me)),


    Any guesses on if that's an electric fireplace in the photos? It looks electric. (I wish photos would allow us to see what the outside of the house looks like too lol)

  • 6 years ago

    Everything is possible$$$

  • 6 years ago

    We have a bat box in our yard so I knew they want a tiny entrance. However I was shocked to google “bat entry size hole” and discover some species need only 3/8” (!!!) hole to enter a space. You need a pest control company that can capture and relocate these critters. Removing the chimney just to remove the bats might be an expensive solution to a problem. As a point of humor, our first house had no kitchen cabinets! 35 years earlier the owners had ANTS so they tore out the cabinets. The ants had the last laugh as they migrated ever spring through my kitchen and out the back door over a period of two days! I was just happy the problem had been bison!

  • 6 years ago

    Remodling1840 - Chimney has to come down no matter what - it was built improperly and guessing it also got struck by lightening at some point in its life. We've done a temp fix, but it's pretty much non-repairable now and there's no masonries in the area. The fireplace (ash trap and the way it was done to convert from wood to nat gas) is the source of the bats. Nothing like sitting in the living room and then from the corner of your eye (also only 8ft away) see a bat fly out of the fire place right in front of your face... So I want to replace the current fire place and all it's bat known holes with one that's properly designed.


    Kate - so agree, but for things like windows ducting sadly we spend sweat and time, not just $$$ (it takes so much more time though, so it's nice to know what's a good and appealing idea before all that effort.)


    Jinx - !!! I love those window wall fireplaces! Especially the vertical long window with the flames, so amazing. I wonder if someone rents an Airbnb with that setup, I'd love to see it first hand!

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    If you want your gas fireplace to still resemble a fireplace, you might want to keep a center post with windows beside it rather than a "bay window".

    A house nearby that was originally built with a fireplace on an outside wall has been altered by adding a small room -- a hallway with mostly glass exterior walls -- so the owners can now walk all the way around the fireplace. The "roof" of that new hallway/room is a copper colored metal shed roof. The hallway room itself is in the shape of a box bay window -- straight sides rather than angled sides -- and the windows start about knee high.

    https://www.evolutionwindows.com/windows/window-styles/bay-windows


    https://www.pinterest.com/pin/299559812703851737/