Software
Houzz Logo Print
erielias

Help ugly colonial exterior

5 years ago

we are about to buy an 1880 colonial that a developer ruined with unfortunate design choices. We are lost as to how we can fix. thinking of adding a 4th upstairs window to create symetry. Painting it white? We like a porch but it would require a variance. ideas?



Comments (15)

  • 5 years ago

    Yes add the 4th window and make those two rounded or arched windows square at the top. Definitely paint the house a warm white.👍I’m sure it’s a lovely house and it will look great with some changes.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    The 4th window on top is good idea. And I would paint it with any light color from your brick. May be wider porch/portico.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    Definitely a 4th window. Those arched windows look very odd. If it were me, I'd remove them and replace with something more appropriate (like the others on the first floor). I think the porch and roof are odd as well. A portico would be a welcome change.

  • 5 years ago

    I would widen the overhang at the front door to reach past the windows with the arches and also square off the rounded windows. The white trim on the house is much too bright with the deep green of the house. Either change the trim to a soft white/cream color or the house to a warm white.

    Think about landscaping the front of your house when spring comes.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    Looks like there may be an issue with the roof. Looks like there is a sag that should be investigated

    I added the additional window & note, the second-floor windows don't match the proportion of the first-floor windows.

    I removed the arched windows and provided a door with sidelights.

    I don't know how much more you want to do. I would seriously consider walking away.


    erielias thanked BeverlyFLADeziner
  • 5 years ago

    So I noticed the sagging roof as well, but the house was built in 1880 (the previous owner managed to make it look like a 1970’s split level by adding the thin brick). I feel like I have seen a lot of older houses (this is in Northwest Connecticut) with the sagging roofs so didn’t think it would be a problem. Thanks so much. I think you are on to something with the door with side lights.

  • 5 years ago



  • 5 years ago

    This was the original house before the previous owner renovated.

  • 5 years ago

    I think the house needs a full front porch, but the porch roof should not reach the upper windows as the current porch roof does. Replace the arched windows with windows to match the rest. I would consider a fourth window upstairs if it makes sense with the floor plan.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    I'd never consider buying an old home and paying for someone's "remuddling," then having to spend more money on fixing it. I'd rather find something old in its original condition, then bring it back to life. Pass on this one and move on.

  • 5 years ago

    As the owner of an historic house, I would be very, very leery about the abilities of the people who ruined the outside of this house. I suspect the wiring, the flooring, the heating, the room arrangements, etc are not true to the history of this house. Who on earth would install those horrid arched windows and how did they chop up the interiors to make those changes? “First do no harm” should always be the mantra when restoring an old house. It looks like these people had no taste, no sense of history, and a budget crimped so they only did “ cosmetic” ( and inappropriate) changes. The original photo is charming and should have directed all the work on the house.

    erielias thanked remodeling1840
  • 5 years ago

    The front door is very pretty but u feel like it should be rounded. I would use that blue door on the side of the house. In place the of the rounded windows I would add rounded French doors leading to a bit extended porch. For sure add a window upstairs. Paint it white with black trim. Redo the landscaping and add lighting. Cute house

  • 5 years ago

    Please tell me you’ve had an inspection of this house. The seller has made a mess of an historic structure and the outside makes me worry what’s on the inside. And in the walls... Unless you are desperate, pass on the house. If you love it and the location and school district and neighborhood, be prepared for serious renovations to make it anything like the “old” photo. The shingles should never have been removed. Taking off that stone (?) stuff would be a good idea. Add the fourth window and replace all the arched ones. Have the roof and attic checked for leaks. Take it slow before you sign the papers. Connecticut has many beautiful old houses without this remuddling.

    Where is this in CT?

  • 5 years ago

    Update on the ugly house! We backed out. too Much of a mess! Thank you everyone for the feedback!

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    Wow, that was a very wise decision! Good luck finding a new home!