Software
Houzz Logo Print
amanda_penna31

Do I accept this?

5 years ago
last modified: 5 years ago

Long story short, local contractor - lic. & insured... Redoing small bathroom with no architect, and contractor did a few things that are non standard without discussing prior. Previously he had to rip out a tub bc he put in a tub I didn't pick with super molded arms and backrest etc. inside that wouldn't have worked for my small kids who bathe together. Thankfully his worker stepped on it and it cracked so I had that fixed without a real discussion. Now there is the issue of door molding that's a very non standard 2.5 thick which he did bc the wall is bumped out which he said he had to do bc the tub didn't fit otherwise. The giant molding prevents the cabinet door from opening. He installed and plumbed that (no sink yet) without first showing me that the door doesn't open. I know it wouldn't have opened all the way anyway bc against wall, but some communication would have been nice, bc I would have suggested a smaller vanity with a filler piece by the wall. I don't want to bash the guy, but I'm unhappy. I'm not wealthy. I saved 11 years for this remodel. My house is not perfect or fancy but I expect a new bathroom to be done right. Do I accept this or request a smaller vanity and filler piece at no additional cost to me? We haven't paid the amount in full yet, just half. I feel bad because I do not like to offend anyone, but I'm not happy.

Comments (20)

  • 5 years ago



  • 5 years ago



  • 5 years ago



  • 5 years ago



  • 5 years ago

    Why can’t he just pull the vanity away from the wall an inch and put in a filler? Did he choose the vanity, or did you? Either way, no professional should be putting a vanity with full overlay doors that close to a wall. If you take a door to a paint store, they should be able to mix up a matching pint to,paint the filler.

    That door framing is out of this world! Does he know what he is doing?

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Editing this comment to add that the question I was originally answering in this comment seems to have vanished. If it seems an odd comment it's because I was responding to someone who asked who made this decision.


    -----

    The answer is the contractor. He installed all of this without saying a word to me about it. I didn't ask for 2.5 inch thick molding. It's crazy to think a non contractor would anticipate something like this, and as a contractor, it's crazy to install that knowing the door won't open without telling the homeowner first, as the fix (moving it a few inches from the wall) would have been simple had there been any communication.

  • 5 years ago

    @Nancy in Mich, he can't move the existing vanity bc it's a tiny bathroom and the vanity is already at the largest size possible to give the toilet room. Had he communicated with me about the molding and the door i would have suggested a vanity 3 inches smaller. :(

  • 5 years ago

    I'm so confused by that thick molding around the door. is the rest of your house like that? is that a choice you made? that's a weird thing for him to choose on his own.

  • 5 years ago

    Yes, he actually made it and installed it before ever showing me or speaking with me about it.

  • 5 years ago

    Sorry forgot to answer your other question - no the rest of my very small house is not at all like that.

  • 5 years ago

    I’m so sorry you have run into this problem! It’s so frustrating when things like this happen!


    The contractor works off specs given to him, including molding choice and how to position a vanity and if it needs a filler. I dont know if he presented himself as a design professional, in which case this is his responsibility to fix the vanity or if you didn’t provide a plan and specs to him, in which case it is your responsibility to pay him to change it to your liking.


    Even small projects benefit from having a designer on board! It’s not just about choosing finishes!


  • 5 years ago

    Are you sure you can't move the vanity over? You need 15 inches from the vanity to the center of the toilet to meet code.

    My sister bought a home with a worse problem. She had a drawer which could not open due to trim.

    I really don't see why you could not change the trim to a standard trim.

  • 5 years ago

    Thanks for your insight to all commenters... The vanity would need to move 3 inches to even begin to work with that door being able to fully open and the distance to center of toilet is now 17, so not enough wiggle room I'm afraid. I did not have a designer. I never anticipated having to tell someone not to do this, but I guess in hindsight I should have been better prepared and had a designer.


    The wall was brought in about 2 inches to fit the bathtub snugly. Again, I suppose a designer would have foresight to say, "This is going to cause a problem" but I didn't have a designer. So now because the molding is tied into the shower tile I suppose I'll have to pinterest my way into liking it. Maybe put chunky framed bath pictures next to it. Idk. I'm just so disheartened. I don't want to crucify the guy if this isn't his fault, but I am dismayed at his lack of communication and that he didn't think to ask me about this. He was just here and I suggested removing vanity to put a vanity 3 inches smaller along with a filler, but he didn't seem interested in doing that. He suggested adding an internal hinge to the vanity to prevent the door from slamming open into the molding.

  • 5 years ago

    Can you post a picture of the left side of the door? I can see how the wall to the left of the door was bumped out, but we can’t see the molding.

  • 5 years ago

    It's tied into the tile... I'll get a pic.

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    When you don’t hire out design work, you are the designer by default. There are several issues here with code compliance, that go beyond cosmetics. A hinge restrictor is a workable option for the door. It doesn’t solve the issue of the required 15” on center for the lavatory.

  • 5 years ago



  • 5 years ago

    Yes, I'm seeing that's the consensus... I didn't have a designer so by default I am responsible. Sigh.

  • 5 years ago

    Get another contractor and stop paying this one. You do not have the experience to manage a contractor and need someone who is more experienced to do the work. These project require a lot of communication and knowledge. It is really hard to find a good contractor who can work with you so I completely empathize and have had bad work done as well.


    I would redo now instead of trying to cover up the issues. Bumping in the wall was a weird thing to do and it sound like that needed to be redone and would fix the vanity and framing issue. Unfortunately you have tile laid down now so too expensive to fix. Vanity move is a good option but what width is it currently? 24 or 30? Is there a smaller width available?


    My contractor spent an entire day redoing the insides of a wall to adjust the location of shower recess so it looked more polished in relation to the tile grout lines. He is conscientious. Your contractor may be nice but he needs too much handholding to do this well and is overconfident in his abilities.

  • 5 years ago

    A designer isn't usually needed, but a contractor with common sense is required. My sister used a designer when she built her home. She stopped in every morning before work and every afternoon after work. The guys working on the install often pointed out things that they saw and thought could be done better.


    I brought in my plumber to do some work at my house and while he was here I asked him about a new tub that I picked out that is larger than the one I had. I thought I knew the answer on how to make it fit, but he saw another option that I hadn't thought of that would be far less expensive. A good tradesman would not have installed the tub without discussing how to make it work. The bump out to the wall could have been just as high as the tub and you could have had a small lip or ledge.


    I cannot imagine any of the tradesmen I work with picking out a tub for me any more than they would pick the floor coloring or the lighting fixtures. These are the choices you make.


    I don't know where you found this guy, but he is a yahoo.