Software
Houzz Logo Print

Ah, 2021 ordering continues, and I've been bitten by the "designer rose" bug and have gone on a wee bit of a David Austin streak.
Though and thankfully other nurseries still provide Austin's roses via their registration name codes (AUS****), not all are available, and considering DAR's propensity to treat their varieties like disposable goods and eliminate varieties, I feel that I'd better start ordering any and all that interest me while I actually can.
So far, I have coming from DAR-USA:
-Princess Alexandra of Kent
-Bishop's Castle
-Harlow Carr
-Lady Emma Hamilton (2nd plant!)
-Fighting Temeraire
-Eustachia Vye
-Gabriel Oak
-Falstaff
-The Dark Lady
-L.D. Braithwaite
-Darcey Bussell
-Thomas à Becket
-Heathcliff
-Sophy's Rose (for my friend, not me)
-Huntington Rose/Alan Titchmarsh
I have a few others like The Lark Ascending, Tam O'Shanter, Sir John Betjeman, Jude the Obscure, and Benjamin Britten still sitting in my cart at DAR-USA, but I'm waiting to check out Palatine's offerings too!
My The Ingenious Mr. Fairchild (received mislabelled as Tradescant which I got the following year (and isn't as good compared to TIMF regarding vigour and general performance)) has been a real trooper. It's survived digging out my monster William Baffin, getting moved and upset, and suffered badly from winter 2016-2017. Looking again at a recent picture of it, it really is starting to fill out on the canes and it's this vigour and general will to grow that I need here up North. Hardiness is good too, but if the dang things don't grow, what's the point?
I have a thing for crimson roses (ESPECIALLY the bluers) with fragrance, so I basically ordered every single crimson Austin they still offer.
I already have Tess of the d'Urbervilles from 2020's season. It came from Regan's. It and JtO were a couple I had ordered way back in 2003/2004 when I was in highschool, and I remember them growing like gangbusters arching all over and blooming nicely too. Tess's scent reminded me of aged rose, crayons (an odd "waxy" smell to me), and a little something else while Jude was punch-my-nose fragrant. JtO smells intensely of grapefruit to me.
Othello is coming from Hortico, and I'd like to try Prospero (do not prune this one is something I've learned from a wonderful and knowledgeable rosarian on the Pacific Coast!), The Prince, and maybe The Squire if it's offered from Palatine.
If any do not succeed, it's better to have discovered so than forever wonder "What if..."
Steven

Comments (14)

  • 5 years ago

    Wow Steven! Color me impressed.

    That makes me smile to think of a high school student ordering roses!

    I too am wild about the crimson Austins. I have seen pictures of Tradescant and it looked fabulous so hearing that it wasnt the heartiest is good to know. Even though in my zone it migjt be stellar there are others with bettet reviews.

    It will be intetesting to see what Palatine offers wont it ?

    I still may cave and try for the Prince or the Squire.

    Good luck with your new additions. Thank you for being a caretaker for those old beloved Austins

  • 5 years ago

    I am humbled by your kind words and wish to thank you deeply.
    I'm only now at a point in my life where I feel I've obtained enough stability across several life aspects that will allow improved care and attentiveness and at the same time, continue learning about home maintenance and upkeep.

    I still feel the same excited thrill about new roses as I did then, but tempered with age and experience because I'm undoubtedly frigid in winters and reality doesn't always follow and conform to our most idyllic gardens of fantasy.
    I just wish I weren't quite as prickly as our "risky" hobby itself!

    Regarding Tradescant, the first couple of years were decent and some of the autumn blooms were truly, truly dark. Winter 2017-2018 was hard on him, and this year I'm hoping to push some growth on him and/or attempt to root some. Currently, he's a literal one cane wonder with some twiglets. Honestly, I want to try him on R. multiflora because it does so well here as an invasive (when not hideous and dying from RRD), and since most of the Huey roses just never seem to develop roots very well here. Mt TIMF was going own-root the last time I had dug him up and the Huey part still looked about the same as when I planted him in 2015. I do like my vigorous own-root plants. They take a bit longer to settle in but seem to progress better in general unless too tender.

    I would feel aside from rust (which I don't get here) and black spot (biggest fungal pathogen here), the hardiness of Tradescant shouldn't be an issue for you, and he may well do better than in my -20°F (average annual minimum) to 90°F (on the higher side) Z5b. I believe Paul mentioned before that Tradescant was a terrible rust bucket (iirc).

    I'll check for some old Tradescant photos and a newer one... Ah! I found a couple! Except for the one, the others were darker than the image suggests. Hard to photograph those reds!
    So far in my garden, I'd say Munstead Wood is a definite improvement aside from prickles.

    I was even carting rose books around while in middle school too.
    Now, I'm not a hoarder by any means, but I do save things like old rose magazines even though I know I've gotten rid of more than I've kept, but I have things this older ARE brochure. It's also a reminder to me of how precious and lovely PHYSICAL print is. Digital can never replace actual physical media and literature for me.

    Preservation in gardening,

    Steven

  • 5 years ago

    Munstead Wood; sometimes looks like Tradescant. Sometimes it's PINK.

  • 5 years ago

    What a range of colors for MW, Steven. It's so beautiful. I just planted an own root MW in October. I really hope it does well. I've heard so many great things!


    I have quite a few new to me Austins in my garden this year--either planted last fall or hopefully coming bare root this spring.


    It was an OGR that made me fall in love, so I certainly have a soft spot for Austins. (I am planting a bed of OGR this spring, too)

  • 5 years ago

    I hope it does well for you! Mine is still growing up. I like it so far and I don't mind the prickles because R. eglanteria is worse! It's black spot resistance and hardiness are certainly better than any crimson and scented HT I've tried.
    I'm aiming for more red hybrid perpetuals and a couple of the purple gallicas like Cardinal de Richelieu and Belle de Crecy.
    MW's fragrance is absolutely lovely but I have experienced it to be shy from time to time. One of the pictures I shared of MW where it's opening but had rainwater in it- I read a comment from an old thread and my curiosity was piqued, so I slurped up water from that opening bloom. Goodness! Not sweet tasting, but intense, lingering, pervasive essence of rose washed over my senses of taste and smell. Absolutely magical and lingering.

    Rose petal jam is something I need to consider making.

    Steven

  • 5 years ago

    I'm a heretic, I know, but I'm not a huge Austin fan. However, your roses are lovely and look so healthy and happy!

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Steven, I read in one of your comments that Dr. Huey rootstock doesn’t seem to always thrive in your area? Do you assume it’s due to the cold winters, or because of your soil type? I really want to try bud grafting (realistically I won’t get to it until next year) and it would be great to know what a good rootstock would be for zone 5 Midwest conditions.

  • 5 years ago

    Oh, I wouldn't say so at all Seil! It's acceptable in my book to dislike things for their sameness of appearance, poor fluctuating winter temp hardiness, spottiness, short-lived blooms, floppiness, lack of vigour, style, floriferousness, or anything else!
    ... If I imagine Austins and being particularly disappointing, my imagination's picture is of a sun bleached, dry, and hot week of weather with burnt and ratty semi-single blooms on a mostly naked gangle of canes with nasty remaining foliage spotting and yellowing as well. Nightmarish!

    Thank you for your kind words. They're usually not quite so pretty by the end of the season because I'm not really a spray kind of person, but I have been considering exceptions for only certain things (like the Soleil d'Or coming this spring) and by the directions only.

    I do get enough nice blooms and they do tend to perform better than most hybrid tea/floribunda types although some newer Kordes like Madame Anisette impress me aside from thrips liking pale flowers.

    Steven

  • 5 years ago

    @Madison Post so far that seems to be the results of my very UN-scientific views regarding Huey. I'm still watching and waiting to see more because I do have a Chianti from DAR-USA that is on Huey, and I know Chianti is hardy, so maybe that makes a good difference as well. It'll be three years old this spring and seems to be happily putting on size. Its bud union is below grade though.

    Rosa multiflora definitely thrives and is cane hardy in winters that will kill Huey to the ground. Rugosa are also happy here and definitely NOT chlorotic.

    I've only just added a couple of multiflora grafted roses last spring so I'm looking forward to seeing how they develop.

    What I'd really like to do is get the same variety each on Huey, multiflora, and own-root (if vigorous enough, naturally) and compare. I know Fortuniana is non bien here from common knowledge and experience (I had a Medallion on Fortuniana my grandparents picked up for me in the deep south RV'ing in retirement). It just never stops!

    A pH test across several of my beds is in my scheduled spring plans. I'm suspecting to be more on the acidic side if only because farmers apply lime to fields often around here.

    Steven

  • 5 years ago

    In my opinion, it is hard to beat the beauty and fragrance of Munsted wood.

    kristine_legault's ideas · More Info


  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Seil you made me laugh. I can see many reasons why someone wouldn't like an Austin. I love that this forum has so many active participants who share from their different likes and experiences.

  • 5 years ago

    My Mom got the first DA rose, Golden Celebration, the year it came out, 92, I think and it is still here. Later I got Graham Thomas as a mislabel. About 5 years ago I thought I'd try something pink so I got Queen of Sweden and Jubilee Celebration. I'm not real impressed with any of them. GC can be gorgeous when it's in its spring flush and it does smell divine but so far the rest aren't anything to write home about. Also, they are all water hogs and spot magnets for me! Having been an exhibitor I guess I just prefer the HT form better myself. I have no trouble wintering any of them really but I'm a full zone warmer than you, Steven.

    Madison, Dr. Huey and Multiflora are the preferred root stocks for cold zones. Dr. Huey was almost exclusive for decades until the Canadians started using Multiflora with good results. Now almost all the roses from the Canadian mail order nurseries are on Multiflora. The only root stock I wouldn't recommend is Fortuniana. It is marvelous in warm climates and really pushes big, fast growth but it has a habit of rooting very shallow so it is very freeze tender. I know a few people who have managed to get it to survive but it takes a lot of effort and protection.

  • 5 years ago

    Thanks Steven! I hope you share your results if/when you get to comparing grafts on the different roots you mentioned. That would be a super interesting thing to do.