Software
Houzz Logo Print
carla_cox85

Black hot water--again!

5 years ago

Our hot water turns jet black at random times (can't see to the bottom of a white bathtub!). It leaves behind a black powdery substance that settles to the bottom of whatever it goes into, not oily.

We are on a well with only a pressure tank, no holding tank.

Our water hardness is literally off the charts. It can't be measured beyond the top of the range. Our water comes from limestone aquifers.

We have a Kinetico water softener.

We have a typical hot water heater.

We have a hot water recirculator because of the length of our house.

Our pipes are all copper.

We recently replaced the HWH anode from magnesium to aluminum at the advice of our plumber. The magnesium anode we took out had decomposed to just the core after just 6 months (we have had 5 HWHs in 20 years). We had clear water from the hot water side for about 3 months with the aluminum anode and now we're getting black water again.

We love our plumber and we've had many. He thinks it's just the decomp of the anode, but it's driving me batty! I can't trust the hot water to not ruin clothes, dishes, bathrooms, etc.

Help!!

Comments (4)