Floor & Decor does all types of tiles in all kinds of colors.....Dal Tile has been around for years....I think you can email them and get samples.....

I have a Dal Tile showroom locally, it's very nice. They have designers to help you with your choices.. much better than Floor and Decor. A higher end tile store manager recommended their quality also. I bought my backsplash tile from DT, and it was easy to cut and install, zero broken tiles. I got my fireplace tile from Emser, they had some modern shapes also... and their quality is also great. Daltile at Home Depot is very limited and HD doesn't even offer all the possible colors or tiles.

Dal Tile is good quality. I don't like to buy anything at Home Depot, but Dal Tile has many showrooms around the country. Try looking them up.

Thank you. I will look at Dal Tile. I have decided we should do a 3 inch hex tile, which makes the search even harder. Does anyone have experience with Fireclay Tile?

I feel like Tile bar has a few options: You can get 4 samples for $10. https://www.tilebar.com/meadowmere-cement-white-3-hexagon-matte-ceramic-tile.html

I have used Dal Tile and they are good quality.

I also love Complete Tile, which are hand made in upstate New York. You can order samples, if you are interested.

They have a true white that comes in various square and rectangle sizes.

Also, a Fused Laminated Glass, in a hex pattern.

Thank you all for the input, we went with Fireclay Tile. Fingers crossed the size is right.