Correction: option one and three are my ideas. Middle photo is my current situation.

I think the semi gloss paint is throwing things off. Repaint the brick a flat white (same as walls) and update the mantle with something a bit lighter and less chunky and get a more modern screen.

I would change the paint to a flat paint also. I think it looks fine otherwise.

I agree with simply changing the paint to a flat white and replacing the screen.

I agree with other - change to a flat paint instead of semi-glass. Definitely need a more stylish screen. The mantel doesn't seem quite right either. The color and the style are off. I would suggest different artwork above the mantel as well - something brighter and more cheery. Good luck!