Software
Houzz Logo Print
nleev

builder did not specify which level of Timbertech

5 years ago

We looked at our contract again to see what the builder included for our decking and he simply wrote down Timbertech for the deck. He did, however, specify a certain type of vinyl for the railings. When we went to look at Timbertech, we found a color that was nice, but when we told him what we liked, he told us that we had to choose among the lowest cost line of Timbertech, which the contract does not state. Do we hold to the contract and tell him we want what we want, and there's no mention of the level of this product, or even the cost that we are allotted? We don't want to be difficult about it, but he's not budging on things that aren't mentioned (like shower doors) and we are being forced to purchase outside of the contract, but wants us to overlook things that he didn't specify (such as decking).

Comments (31)

  • 5 years ago

    It depends on what hill you want to die on. Is this a custom home or a tract/developer type home?

  • 5 years ago

    It’s custom. He’s built it before as a spec house, but we changed the design to suit our needs and have been continuously upgrading things throughout the process. Garage doors, interior trim, windows. We look at what he recommends and quite often ask for something different. The deck is becoming a sticking point. We’re okay with paying more for a better product but are distrustful of what he’s quoting and wondering if we should hold him to the contract.

  • 5 years ago

    Like I said is this a hill you want to die on? He can and will extract money from you somehow if you hold his feet to the fire long enough. There are plenty of ways he could get back at you.

  • 5 years ago

    It is also partially your fault for agreeing to a contract with "Timbertech" as the only definition used, so he is not incorrect either.

  • 5 years ago

    My experience has been if it is not spelled out exactly you get the cheapest.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    As millworkman said, you can butt heads with your builder going back and forth to-no-end, but from a legal point of view, he should have specified in detail the manufacturer of decking (which he did) and the decking grade which was included (that he didn't)... instead he left this in the open and in the past, I have heard and seen quite a few contractors get burned because of the same issues (lack of the material "type/grade" description in the contract) and homeowners took the legal course of action and won.

    This why including specific details of materials to be used required by law in many states especially those that have consumer protection agencies, to avoid "bait and switch" tactics.


    That said if there was a good relationship with the builder throughout, there is not a big deal for him to upgrade the decking and make you happy... not to mention what are we talking about here... let's say from $48 per board to an upgraded $58 dollar board and if you need 30 boards we talking about $300 difference, and to be stingy about that amount it makes no sense at all on a new construction home, not to mention he screwed up, to begin with.

    Good luck



  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    At least you got a brand name.

    Always read the specifications before signing the contract and remember ... they're supposed to be specific.

    You both made a mistake so perhaps you can negotiate the up charge at cost without a markup.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    If the spec is simply "Timbertech" he can meet that spec by installing any product they make.

  • 5 years ago

    If you had originally asked for the best TimberTech product do you think the project price would have increased? If so, this is what your contingency is for.

  • 5 years ago

    It seems to me you are just as much at fault as the builder. You signed the contract that did not have things specified. If the contract said Timbertech and the builder installs the lowest level Timbertech wouldn't that part of the contract be fulfilled? You say you are continually having to upgrade throughout the process. It sounds to me like you didn't do your homework before signing the contract with the builder and now are not happy you have to pay more.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    This is the reason why builders/contractors get screwed for not specifying the exact product that is being used on the job and included in the contract price.

    I will use this situation as an example... The builder in this case his contract specified "TimberTech deck" is included in the price, which only means in anyone's mind (including the judge) that the selection can be made from any collection ThimberTech has to offer. It's common sense.


    Now if the builder would specify in the contract "TimberTech Premier Collection decking is included with the house", it would be a different story and you cannot dispute anything and the customer clearly knows that the "Premier Collection" is free, and if a customer wants to select decking from Reserve Collection or any other collection they know that would be an upgrade.



  • PRO
    5 years ago

    "He’s built it before as a spec house" is key as this is common. Both builder and client would be reasonable to expect the home it was based upon to serve as the specification model unless otherwise addressed in either the plans or proposal.


    Likely when you asked the builder for the cost of construction that it was used.



  • PRO
    5 years ago

    @vinmarks They not at fault at all.

    It's Contracting 101 The most important thing of the contract is to specify the exact scope of work and material specification you include in your price if you don't want any disputes and get burned.

    Just think about it... You go to a restaurant that offers a buffet setting all-you-can-eat for X amount of dollars.

    You come up to a buffet and you load up on shrimp and they tell you this is extra... Is it your fault that now they tell you that only rice was included in that price?

    This is the reason why you have to deliver what you put down or you will have a problem and I can give you a dozen of examples how people lost money because of that.


  • 5 years ago

    GN Builders I get it but the OP signed the contract without the specifications in it. They have to take some accountability for that. If they wanted a particular Timbertech then they should have made sure that was in the contract. I think there were a lot of assumptions being made. So are you saying they take the builder to court if he doesn't give them the upgraded Timbertech? How much will that cost? Was the contract based on the builders spec house? OP indicated that they have been upgrading throughout the process.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    What level of Timbertech was installed at the spec house?

  • PRO
    5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    @Mark Bischak, Architect I think they entered into a contract in the mids of construction before the deck was installed, and now is the time to select the decking materials.

    P.S.

    Mark, the builder never specified what level of decking was included. OP said " he simply wrote down Timbertech for the deck"

    By leaving out The Specific Type of decking to be used i.e Grade/Style, etc... Builder's specification can only be interpreted in one way, that the customer can select "Any decking" that comes from a ThimberTech manufacturer.

    All he had to do is specify in the contract "Deck with Builder Grade decking by ThimberTech manufacturer is included in the price" or " Allowance X amount of $$$ for TimberTech deck is included in the price" if he would do that you cannot question that in any other way but for what it is...

    It's a common practice to specify something as "builder grade" because it is always interpreted as " builder will install the most minimal and inexpensive material made by such and such manufacturer".

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    When the OP stated "He’s built it before as a spec house, but we changed the design to suit our needs and have been continuously upgrading things throughout the process. Garage doors, interior trim, windows.", that would presumably set the basis of the materials and price unless an agreed upon change was made. I would assume the Timbertech that was used in the previous "spec house" would be used in the OP's house unless they agreed to use a different Timbertech.

    That is why I inquired, "What level of Timbertech was installed at the spec house?"

  • 5 years ago

    "we had to choose among the lowest cost line of Timbertech, which the contract does not state"


    Do you even contract, bro?

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    By leaving out The Specific Type of decking to be used i.e Grade/Style, etc... Builder's specification can only be interpreted in one way, that the customer can select "Any decking" that comes from a ThimberTech (sic) manufacturer.


    I couldn't disagree more. It is not the homeowner's responsibility to meet the specification; that's the builder's job. The builder can furnish and install anything manufactured by TimberTech and meet a specification that reads "TimberTech deck."


    On a separate, but related, note, customizing a builder's spec plan beyond some level puts the homebuyer and the home in a different category. If you find you need to make a lot of changes, you may be in custom home building territory. That implies a different design route and a different class of builder.

  • 5 years ago

    Just my 2 cents...

    A couple of notes on contract deficiencies. Typically when a provision in the contract is deficient courts will look at other information that was material to the formation of the contract but not included. In this case the existence of a spec home on which the contract was based is a strong indicator of the intent of both parties. I doubt you can successfully overcome that in this situation.

    If there is no evidence otherwise, the law generally favors the party that didn't write the contract, so long as the action remains reasonably within industry standards. The idea being the person who controlled the contract has the obligation to spell things out.

    Finally, and most importantly, who cares what the law says about the resolution? Under the American system you are going to have to pay your own legal fees for this. Since the attorney fees are going to be far more than the upgrade cost, you are really going to get what you can talk your builder into giving you. All of the opinions here really don't mean your builder is going to absorb this loss... if he decides not to, then all the expert, and now legal analysis, isn't going to get you anything.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    "The builder can furnish and install anything manufactured by TimberTech and meet a specification that reads "TimberTech deck."

    How you figure that especially when you have a customer and what does your customer suppose to expect when TimberTech has 6 give or take grades of decking?

    That is BS and you know it and if this is how you structure your contracts and conduct your business with customers...you still have lots to learn.


    Now, what's the deal with "custom home building territory" and "tract home territory" I hear this all the time, as a matter of fact, I hear this so much lately that it becomes a bit overrated.

    It seems everyone you run in nowadays it's "custom this" and "custom that" in the meantime, they can't build a dog house.


    The way I look at it building a 300k home or $2m home the construction quality should be the same.

    Any builder with a customer who is willing to spend money on upgrades, make design changes with an architect/ builder from the "basic home" to more well-designed home, is considered nothing but a nicer home, much better designed, and of course, it will have more features in it.


    Other than that if the same experienced builder today is building a 300k home and the next day he is building a $2m dollar home and he got his hands on the entire project (as he should) the quality of builds will be the same.






  • PRO
    5 years ago

    @bry911 I agree with you to a point.

    1st of all this is not an attorney/client case. We talk about the disputed amount of a few hundred dollars between the material grades, so this is a small claims court matter (if it gets to that), the filing fee is about $18-30.

    Every story I heard involving these types of matters, builders/contractors lost because of lack of material specification in the contract. Nobody saw the judge in most cases, it was settled with a court-appointed mediator but it was always ruled against the contractor.

    There are certain requirements that NJ builders/contractors have to meet when it comes to contract language and what must be included and there are also consumer protection guidelines since we have that in the state.

    With that said, and not knowing what else was going on there, I would work this out in 2 seconds, because some things are not worth the headaches unless they have something to do with principles and fairness.


  • PRO
    5 years ago

    The way I look at it building a 300k home or $2m home the construction quality should be the same.


    You're welcome to look at it any way you like, but what matters is the buyer's expectation. No reasonable buyer expects the same quality level in a Toyota Corolla and a Lexus LC even though Toyota Motors designs and builds both. You don't get the same quality level in a $300K home or a $2 million home either. If a builder used the same quality materials and trade labor the $300K home, he would not be competitive at that price point.


    Now, what's the deal with "custom home building territory" and "tract home territory" I hear this all the time, as a matter of fact, I hear this so much lately that it becomes a bit overrated.


    That's not what I stated. I never even used the word "tract." You did. There is a fundamental difference between builders of spec homes where the buyer is purchasing a product and a custom home where the buyer is purchasing a service. The spec home builder may offer some "options" but they really don't work in the custom home builder's territory where the client has a nearly unlimited range of choices. At a certain point it makes more sense to retain a custom builder than to try to morph a spec home into a custom home where there are a great number of changes.


    That is BS and you know it and if this is how you structure your contracts and conduct your business with customers...you still have lots to learn.


    How I produce my plans, specifications, and contracts is not the subject of this post. What is at issue is the OP's builder's specification of "TimberTech" deck which is an incomplete specification. If the spec read "composite decking" it would be more ambiguous. It's reasonable, in my opinion, to assume the builder is referring to the same material as found in the spec home. To assume the buyer is entitled to choose whatever they want that's manufactured by TimberTech is not a reasonable assumption, in my opinion.

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    1st of all this is not an attorney/client case. We talk about the disputed amount of a few hundred dollars between the material grades, so this is a small claims court matter (if it gets to that), the filing fee is about $18-30.

    Which I happened to mention and also largely negates a discussion of mediation. The concept of who is right or wrong or may prevail in mediation is irrelevant to a discussion of whether or not you are going to get a builder to budge. If you are not going to fight this through the legal system, which you are not, then any analysis of past solutions involving the legal system are irrelevant. It doesn't matter if the builder was wrong if the OP doesn't manage to get a favorable resolution.

    Every story I heard involving these types of matters, builders/contractors lost because of lack of material specification in the contract. Nobody saw the judge in most cases, it was settled with a court-appointed mediator but it was always ruled against the contractor.

    Being aware of the outcome of multiple cases isn't the same as understanding the rationale behind those decisions. Of course, builders sometimes lose these types of situations because, as I stated, they wrote the contract and ambiguity is typically against the creator of the contract.

    However, that is not always the case. Anything that was instrumental in the formation of the contract will be used to construe the intention of the parties. Just because you have seen this before doesn't mean the facts in those situations correspond to the facts in this situation.

    If you point to a painting and say can you paint this with these changes, you can't then go back and say that you wanted a completely different size and type of painting just because it wasn't specified in the contract. The law is not that stupid and neither are most mediators. Now if the contract was for a completely original painting then it is a different situation, because there was no original painting that formed the basis of the agreement.

    So find cases of a builder who was asked to modify a spec home in particular ways, who then lost a case for constructing the same spec home with the stated changes.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    @bry911 So go out and find me cases of a builder who was asked to modify a spec home in particular ways, who then lost a case for putting the same items they put in the spec home.


    I don't have to go too far, it's right here... The OP said "It’s custom. He’s built it before as a spec house, but we changed the design to suit our needs and have been continuously upgrading things throughout the process."

    It's not a spec house anymore... Maybe it was before they came into a picture and since he changed everything to fit their need, anything he planned to use before in his spec house it's history.

    I'm sure when they entered into the contract, some specifications were added/changed by him so they could agree, the only thing he missed to add the type of decking board that was included with the deck. instead, he only noted the name of the Decking Manufacturer who makes 6 or more grades of decking board. So now how he plans to prove that he meant the lowest grade board and not the top-of-the-line board? If it gets to that.


    Here is another example, a good quality builder a friend of mine, sold a house to a couple, his contract stated "wall-to-wall carpeting, customer choice of color" but he never included allowance or brand...

    The time came to select a carpet, he started showing them samples of builder-grade and a sample of upgrade carpeting, they said they don't like the color, they want this color... he said this color only available in the upgrade... Most people would say ok and stick with the builder grade, or some would pay extra for an upgrade...

    This couple took the contract out and said look "wall-to-wall carpeting, customer choice of color" he tried to explain, they end up pissing him off and after back and forth now they got pissed off and they end up in court...the arbitrator said, there is no carpeting grade or allowance included the contract, settle it or take a chance with the judge... his attorney suggested to find common ground and he ends up giving them an upgrade.

    His lawyer said if there was "builder grade" next to it, it would eliminate all the hassle they went through.

    When I spoke to him he said I know I screwed up and missed including the allowance and he should have gone with what they picked, the difference between didn't break his bank, his stubbornness did.




  • 5 years ago

    "Continuously upgrading..."


    Well, theres a few more things that need upgrading. Like the deck boards.


    When you find yourelf in a hole...


    (Stop digging!)

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    I am not going to argue first year contracts with a builder using anecdotal stories.

    Do a Google search on ambiguity in contracts and stop with the B.S. It is a waste of time and a silly debate.

    There is quite literally a mountain of precedential case law on contract ambiguity and parole evidence... Which all agrees with me, because you know... it turns out my professor in Contracts 1 wasn't a moron.

    ETA: I don't want to get into a big argument or debate about this. Nor do I want to get into a big discussion on contracts and when parole evidence is admissible. I assure you that your understanding needs some work. You are arguing about the definition of a spec home and that only further illustrates your misunderstanding. I don't care if it is custom or if it is spec.

    The OP obviously didn't intend at the signing of the contract to demand a better deck than the one supplied with the original home. The OP can't create a condition today that can clearly be shown to not be there intent at the beginning of the contract. It just isn't going to work, as that is not the way contracts work. The courts will attempt to decide the intention of the parties WHEN THEY SIGNED THE CONTRACT. You can't tell the resolution of any case until you see the arguments, but this one is a dog from the get go. I know this, I don't know how to convince you of this.

    Good luck

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    @bry911 I'm not arguing with you, and I'm not a lawyer, so if you say you one, I would hope you know more than me when it comes to the law, at the same time I don't throw words in the wind, I just state the facts that I know happened.

    I don't think your contracts professor or judges, etc that you know, have anything to do with anything, I'm sure some of them also view things in a different light, that's only normal we all humans but that aside I don't doubt that all of them a bunch of fine and educated attorneys, and I'm sure you know better than me when it comes to any case the only thing that matters is how the judge will rule on the case and I'm sure some rulings will make a jaw drop from the outcome, and this is why they appeal cases, and other judges reverse the rulings, etc.

    I will also add that I built homes for a few lawyers/ judges, and some are screwed up in the head and I told them that over a drink but it's all good, they're nice people and good friends.

    The small court cases are a different animal, it doesn't take much to tip the scale in order to win the case, all about the preponderance of the evidence, etc., and like anything else, they also can go in the wrong direction.

    That said, here we only go by bits and pieces based on the one-sided story, I base my advice on real-time cases, and not here to prove anything or try to be who I'm not.


    I think I'm done here, take care and enjoy your weekend

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    I still want to know, "What level of Timbertech was installed at the spec house?"

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    @Mark Bischak, Architect I think it was deck level. ;-) Happy Friday!

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    Et tu, @Jeffrey R. Grenz, General Contractor?


    You have now descended to @Mark Bischak, Architect's level which we've established is "deck level."