Software
Houzz Logo Print
brandy_foster59

Mansard Refresh In Serious Jeopardy!

5 years ago

We have a drab, 70's brown Mansard roof and have been planning an exterior refresh for over a year. Last Spring, we received a wonderful design from @ourfarmhouse on Houzz that we plan to implement. We've already contracted with a roofer and are going with Owen Corning True Definition Duration shingles in Estate Grey. We've already had a few quotes from contractors about transforming the upper story windows to grey. However, the latest contractor/designer was the first to tell us it would be a terrible idea to paint the upper windows (fiberglass) because the paint wouldn't stick. We were really impressed with him and value his expertise. But, we're not going to replace perfectly good windows just to change the color. However, he doesn't think our current color would look good with the grey roof. He actually suggested going with a dark bronze shingle roof or picking a color that works with the current window color.


We have no idea what to do now. If we can't paint the upper windows, is it possible to add some sort of overlay that is paintable? Is it possible that the the architectural detail could frame the window just enough to cover the window frame without actually touching or modifying the window or interfering with its operation?


If we are truly stuck with the upper windows remaining the same color, should we reconsider the roof color? Which shingles would you suggest? How would a new roof color impact the entire palette of the exterior? I don't believe that the lower story windows are a different color in the "after" photo, so maybe it's just a matter of contrast on the upper story (settling for a contrast using the current color instead of the more monochromatic look).


Here's our house currently, followed by the "after" look we're trying to achieve and the grey shingles we want:





(We'll be getting rid of those horrid wood pieces behind the lights by the front door, and we won't be adding the muntins on the windows)



Comments (5)