Yes. I really like black windows, but I wouldn't put them on that house. I'd stick with white or an off white.

I think black would look amazing. Can you “sample” it out. Either do one window or paint one current window to see if your sold on it.

I agree with Ultra, that house style does not lend itself to black as they tend to be more modern in my honest opinion.

I like your white, but think black would look good, too. It gets a bad rap now because of the modern farmhouse trend, but was actually what was commonly used on old traditional houses back in the day.

I think tan would look nice, too:

But these aren’t your house and before such a big investment, I’d definitely get mock-ups done to see exactly how black/other would look.

I think they would look good.

I think Marvin Pebble Gray windows or something similar would be perfect. Black seems a bit harsh and I never cared for white with beige houses. Any change from White would also require some adjustments in color for your storm door and sidelight area.

It sounds like I could go either way based my taste and preferences. The mock up is such a good idea! I will do that and consider a less harsh color for the frames! Thank you!!!