Software
Houzz Logo Print
ericka_omalley

Kitchen reno, can’t decide on sink.

5 years ago

I’m about to spend quite a bit on new marble countertops and a new sink. I’ve been leaning towards an undermount Kohler Whitehaven farmhouse sink. My other option is a Blanco undermount granite/quartz composite sink. I would prefer the Kohler, but keep reading about hairline cracks. I don’t want to put in a sink that would possibly need replacing, mostly because I do not want to ever have to pull up my brand new countertops to replace anything. Suggestions on a sink that will pretty much never need to be replaced?! Too much to ask 😉?

Comments (21)

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    A stainless sink will last virtually forever.

  • 5 years ago

    Changing an undermount sink does not require pulling countertop. Another possible choice is the Corian 690 Farm Sink which comes in several shades of white - one of which will compliment your marble.

  • 5 years ago

    Is the white haven cast iron? I personally think that the hairline cracks add character to cast iron and I don’t mind them. If your style is traditional, then I would go with that. I opted for a cast iron drop in sink (haven’t installed yet). And we are buying a sink rack to help with this issue. I chose drop in because we can replace it if we ever need to and countertop installation is cheaper because they don’t have to polish the edges. It’s just as large as the farmhouse sink and less risk for messing up the cabinets with installation.


    The fireclay material is much more durable if you are wanting a farm sink and don’t want cast iron. The granite/quartz feel plasticky to me so that wouldn’t be my first choice, personally. Stainless steel is very durable and timeless so you would definitely never have to replace it. It‘s a hard choice. Good luck!

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    Stainless steel will never need to be replaced. All the sinks you mentioned are fine. Tops aren't pulled to replace sinks. Ever.

  • 5 years ago

    Good to know that countertops don’t have to be removed. I hope that’s true, I’ve just been reading a lot of comments from people who’ve mentioned that.

    I agree stainless is the most durable and I may go with a stainless farmhouse option. But I just don’t love the look of stainless.

    Thanks for everyone’s feedback.

  • 5 years ago

    I don't like the look of stainless it reminds me of military grade cookware (I ran the dining hall in the Air Force) which evokes a sense of longevity and durability, also reminds me of sterility.

    I chose Kohler Cairn Neoroc undermount in matte brown for my upcoming home. I had a silgranite sink in my past house and I loved it. I'm afraid I'm going to nick the crap out of an apron or farmhouse sink.

  • 5 years ago

    I‘m on my third Kohler case iron In 40+ years of moving and remodeling. No problems, no hairline cracks. My last sink was stainless — one of several I’ve had — and it was fine, but I dislike waterspots and find them a bit noisy. Currently have a Whitehaven and really like it. Just wish I’d gone from 33” down to 30” or maybe even 27”. These are roomy sinks.

  • 5 years ago

    MizLizzie, that’s good to know. I’m still leaning toward the Whitehaven.

  • 5 years ago

    I should also say about Kohler cast iron, hairline cracks will not even bother me. I was more concerned about anything that would cause a failure of the sink and requiring it to be replaced. But maybe I’m just overthinking it. I should stop reading reviews 😏

  • 5 years ago

    I think you should go with what you want. I love the cast iron look. Reminds me of my mother's and grandmother's kitchens.

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    “Just wish I’d gone from 33” down to 30” or maybe even 27”.”

    It’s funny you say that, because I have a 30” sink (interior is about 28”). It’s not an apron front, it’s an undermount. I always wish I’d gone UP a size to a 33”!

  • 5 years ago

    I love my large undermounted stainless steel sink. It accommodates large pots too. You should get whatever you heart desires. Check out the reviews first of any sink you are considering.

  • 5 years ago

    I don’t want to put in a sink that would possibly need replacing

    Then it is stainless steel. Will never chip, will never crack, no glazing to wear out, no aluminum pot marks. SS can easily be refinished/ buffed.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    The Whitehaven is a good choice. We put one in our client's new kitchen last year.


    Redwood City Kitchen and Bath Remodel · More Info


  • 5 years ago

    I've had several cast iron Kohler sinks with no problems or cracking. I currently have a Blanco Silgranit Precis and love it, also. I will never, ever have a stainless steel sink - my personal opinion - I don't like anything stainless.

  • 5 years ago

    Thanks all, I’m going with my gut and getting the Kohler Whitehaven. May not be as durable as stainless but it just really love it.

  • 5 years ago

    Good choice. I have a 36” Whitehaven (with the short apron since I put it in five years ago as a retrofit). I am now redoing the kitchen and am moving the Whitehaven to the laundry room and getting a new 36” Whitehaven with a tall apron for the new kitchen, I really love the sink. Get the grids. They are great. They come in two pieces so are really easy to maneuver and clean. Since they are not cross-hatched, you can stand plates up in them to dry dishes if you need to. The grids let water run underneath anything you have resting in the grids, whether dishes or food. A bit of Soft Scrub a couple of times a week keeps the sink sparkling!

  • 5 years ago

    Yes I will definitely get the grids! Glad to know you still love yours!

  • 5 years ago

    You might consider Kohler's Riverby farm sink. It's a new introduction for the older Riverby line. Riverby has a beveled ledge around the upper perimeter that allows for accessories to be parked on that ledge and this ledge automatically allows for a positive reveal at install. Riverby comes with a cutting board and utility rack. I think the bottom of the Riverby sink is larger than the Whitehaven. Compare the two models below, Whitehaven is first, Riverby is second.