Software
Houzz Logo Print

Comments (10)

  • 5 years ago

    In Consumer Reports testing, that Whirlpool dishwasher did better. But the Whirlpool WDT730PAHZ did slightly better and costs $170 less (on sale).

  • 5 years ago

    Everybody's criteria is completely different and we don't know what you really want from each appliance. After I've compared all the ratings from six or seven sites I then look at the reviews of these products on those sites. What are their complaints, what do they like, and what are the trends in the comments.

    Consumer Reports is great for reporting testing technical reports but that's only for one or a few of that model/ product at a time whereas the reviewers are using the product every day over a long period of time.

    Most people would assume that reviewers tend to lean negative, but I use reviews and recommendations more than a Consumer Reports or Good Housekeeping

  • 5 years ago

    My recommendation is Whirlpool for both. I've had too many friends have problems with Frigidaire dishwashers and fridges.

  • 5 years ago

    @Jen K (7b, 8a): "Consumer Reports is great for reporting testing technical reports but that's only for one or a few of that model/ product at a time"

    CR's current ratings include 11 Whirlpool and Frigidaire dishwashers which represent an additional nine similar models for a total of 20. All in all, its ratings include 113 tested or similar-to-tested 24" models.

  • 5 years ago

    @wdccruise - ok? By your snippet, that's simply 20 fridges being tested over a short period of time whereas comparing reviews of product owners (sometimes in the thousands) provides more value than simply using CR or GH lab tests. What you didn't post is that CR surveys product owners which, for me, is more important than their lab tests. However, they only survey CR paying members. Again, asking a forum of people to determine which product is better is useless. Boba said no to Fridgedaire because their friends have had too many problems, but if I've owned 5 Fridgedaires with no problems how is that evaluated? It's null.

  • 5 years ago

    @jenK "By your snippet, that's simply 20 fridges being tested over a short period of time"

    No, it tested 20 dishwashers.

    @jenK "By your snippet, that's simply 20 fridges being tested over a short period of time"

    No, dishwasher models are often on the market for years.

    @Jen K (7b, 8a): "comparing reviews of product owners (sometimes in the thousands) provides more value than simply using CR or GH lab tests.

    No, owners only have one appliance and cannot to perform comparative tests, Their opinions are anecdotal and biased.

    @Jens K. "What you didn't post is that CR surveys product owners which, for me, is more important than their lab tests."

    No, that makes no sense. Owners are surveyed only to estimate reliability, not performance. Estimated reliability is a component of CR recommendations.

    @Jen K (7b, 8a): "Again, asking a forum of people to determine which product is better is useless"

    That's why CR tests each appliance the same way.

  • 5 years ago

    CR tests things that are easy to test, not things that are necessarily predictive of how well the appliance works. I have yet to see a test matrix of different water hardness and different detergents. But from judging on this forum, that seems to be the biggest issue with satisfaction for dishwashers. Some models are better across a larger range of these parameters, whereas others will only work fine if you happen to have exactly the configuration that the manufacturer designed for.


    Similarly, everybody's dishes are different size. Some dishwashers are very adjustable and can handle a bunch of different dishes quite nicely. Other models are built for one particular set of dishes. If you happen to have dishes that are close to this reference set, you'll love your dishwasher. If you don't, it'll be extremely frustrating any things will never work well.


    Finally, the ability to clean is very hard to test objectively. We have both Kitchenaid and Miele dishwashers. The Miele without fail cleans everything perfectly, even when loaded to the brim. The Kitchenaid requires handwashing two to three items after every cycle no matter how carefully loaded. Nonetheless, testing organizations regularly claim that they can't spot any performance differences. Bullshit.


    CR is an entertainment company that is in the business of selling magazines. They are great at that. But don't offer what they promise to sell. Their tests might be 100% accurate, but they also are irrelevant, as the numbers that they measure don't mean anything.

  • 5 years ago

    I'd avoid the Frigidaire dishwasher. I've had two over the years and both had the main wash pump fail after five years.


    I have a middle of the line Whirlpool now and have been happy with it. Not sure about longevity but Whirlpool dishwashers are rated as more reliable than Frigidaire.

  • 5 years ago

    @M: "The Miele without fail cleans everything perfectly, even when loaded to the brim. The Kitchenaid requires handwashing two to three items... Nonetheless, testing organizations regularly claim that they can't spot any performance differences."

    You obviously don't subscribe to the magazine. CR does not claim there are no performance differences.

    @M: "I have yet to see a test matrix of different water hardness and different detergents."

    Ha ha! People who don't actually have to test anything can make up fantasies such as this. CR tested 63 dishwashers and 20 dishwasher detergents. If it had to test every dishwasher with every detergent it would have to conduct 1260 tests. If it had to conduct each of those tests with three water hardness levels, it would have to conduct 3,780 tests. Ridiculous.

  • 5 years ago

    I personally would go with a Bosch model dishwasher instead. You should be able to find a very nice 500 Series at that price point, that offers far better cleaning, and better reliability.


    As for the Refrigerator -- I would get the Whirlpool Fridge. The only thing I dislike, about the model you selected is the Ice / Water in the Door. A lot of times, these dispensers tend to fail long before the refrigerator dies (from constant opening & closing) and it's a costly repair.