Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_928827909

successful tree plantings

I love this site. I learned more from this forum than I did on any Facebook page, website, or article. I spent countless hours reading about almost every tree possible for my treeless yard. My wife was pissed that every night I was reading about trees in bed haha. This site at least for me can be hard to navigate, which is what makes it great. I think only people truly interested in plants and trees come here for information due to the fact you have to work a little harder to find good information. Unlike Facebook groups which seem to always have some drama and people joining just to ask questions they could easily answer with some simple research. With that being said last year I finally decided to plant 4 trees. I went with two Kentucky coffee trees and two black gums. These two trees are the ones that very few people mentioned any cons about and they also seemed underused so the select few that had them loved them. I went with a green gable and wildfire Nyssa. I was nervous about the wildfire and dieback especially after out harsh 7a Philadelphia winter. I saw posts on here where people suffered big time die back with this tree. Only a few tips on mine died back which I was ecstatic about. Surprising I am liking the green gable more than the wildfire ! The tone of the green is beautiful. I also bought two espresso coffee trees. They were hard to find ( specifically the espresso ) . My dad is involved in a building company and suggested checking out a guy he knows people use for mass tree plantings. He doesn’t really deal with a home owner looking for a tree or two. But he was kind enough to let me buy two espresso trees off him. As you can see they were huge, not many people are interested in them I was told so they have been at the nursery for many years. They are an ugly duckling, but I know the potential they have. It was a long stressful transport in my trailer. I didn’t think they’d be as big at they were. Lost a few branches in the process. I know why they call them dead trees now. This spring was super stressful waiting to see if they would bud out. They finally did, with tons of new growth at that. I know all these trees will need attention until the roots are established. They are off to a great start though. I appreciate anyone who gave me tree input on this site being that I posted about both trees and had great responses ! My next move is a serviceberry and fringe tree.

Comments (14)

  • 5 years ago

    Nice. On your coffee trees, make sure the ties are loose enough that the trees can sway some to develop stronger root systems so you can remove the supports in a year or two. Those coffee trees are really leggy. Low-down leaves on one of my coffee trees:

  • 5 years ago

    Yeah I read a bunch of stuff about supporting the trees. I’ve got it set up nice and will be taking them off next year. Yeah they are very leggy. I am guessing they were all growing in a very tight area over the years. Now they have plenty of room to take off !

  • 5 years ago

    after out harsh 7a Philadelphia winter.


    ==>> this MI boy chuckles at z7 being harsh.. what happened .. did you have to pull out your windbreaker in january .. lol ..


    my ground freezes.. and we hover near zero for weeks on end .. thats harsh .. z7 isnt ..


    sure.. you had an event ... so what .. lol ... they roll thru every decade or so ... its the circle of life ...


    see link below ... reread section one ... you are moving out of prime planting time ... you can buy potted stock anytime.. but hold it over until the next proper planting time ... many of the hardcore.. laugh at the hundred pots we have to plant in fall ...


    and to make it a lot easier.. buy smaller.. not only can you buy more plants .. but smaller plants get established faster. and usually outgrow the larger instant gratification plants ... inside a few years ...


    glad you found us .. and may FB rot in hell ...


    ken


    https://sites.google.com/site/tnarboretum/Home/planting-a-tree-or-shrub



  • 5 years ago

    Two of my very favorite native trees, James. My Espresso coffeetree is just waking up - buds are finally visible and beginning to show a little green. I have two of the Nyssa sylvatica, one a species tree and one ‘Autumn Cascade’. Good luck with yours, they look off to a good start!

  • 5 years ago

    Nice trees! Interesting take on the site design acting as a filter for people who really value the information here, never thought of it that way. This is by far the worst designed forum I've ever used, but it's also one of the best and most helpful online communities out there imo. I think you may be on to something...

  • 5 years ago

    This is by far the worst designed forum I've ever used, but it's also one of the best and most helpful online communities out there imo.


    ==>> probably because it was one of the first ... and a lot of us have been here from way back ... one might suggest we made it what it is ... we are gardeners.. not a social group ... we have no vested interest is anything but sharing knowledge ... and in my case... a few jokes.. lol ...


    never forget.. one of the prime reasons for adults to garden.. is to have a reason to play in the dirt .. lol ... yeah yeah.. soil.. and dirt is what is all over you and the house after you are done playing in the soil ...


    now go do the right thing,.. dig a hole.. we'll worry about filling it later ... lol


    ken

  • 5 years ago

    Good job James!

    Don't forget to wood mulch that bare soil. Keeps roots cooler and retains moisture longer.

    And no fert until until the tree can stand on it's own. Excessive growth makes for a heavy crown. And only then if a soil test says it needs something.

    Stay in touch with the requisite updates :-)



  • 5 years ago

    Hope the coffeetrees’ roots were in good shape, you said they were at the nursery for years. I have made the mistake of buying stuff that has “been there a while”. Stunted trees/ dying trees is what I’ve ended up with

  • 5 years ago

    Only time will tell ! I figured I’d give it a shot !

  • 5 years ago

    "I was nervous about the wildfire and dieback especially after out harsh 7a Philadelphia winter."


    You don't need to be. You must not have been gardening in 2013 if you thought the last winter was harsh.


    I worry about those coffee trees though. If the roots are extremely knotted you are setting up disappointment, possibly years down the road.

  • 5 years ago

    @david there is a whole forum conversation chat on here about wildfire dieback in a similar zone, hence why I said that for that specific tree. What would make you think the roots are knotted up ?

  • 5 years ago

    Well James, to make things clear, checking for root problems before placing the tree in the ground is pretty much standard procedure for just about any potted tree, especially if one has reason to believe that the trees may have been in the pots for quite some time. And I just assumed you had done that.

    Trees that are planted in the field and dug before delivery (B&B) are less likely to have root problems unless they have been previously potted too long then planted in the field then dug again and B&B.

    And from what I am reading, KCT are more likely to have problems because of this?

    imo: Now is the time to check for that even if it means digging them up again.

  • 5 years ago

    The espresso coffee trees were dug out of a field before delivery. If trees that big are sold in pots I’d love to see the process. David specifically mentioned Kentucky coffee trees and root knotting which I don’t understand. The black gums however were grown in pots. Air pots to be exact. Grown by a great tree guy local to me. Those roots were in excellent condition.