I have no recommendations, but wanted to say that I have I very similar fixture, probably from the same line (mine hangs from a chain and is in ORB but otherwise looks the same). I toyed with the notion of being offended, or at least mock offended that you think my fixture is dated, but decided against it. Good luck with finding something!

Oh my goodness! It’s about 60 years old. It’s rusted and beyond being cleanable. I’m sure brand new it would look great. No offense intended!

post a picture of the front door area. not an up shot but standing back on the sidewalk looking at it.

I would choose a dark sky compliant flush-mount fixture (example) that illuminates the porch where light is needed and does not illuminate the walls, flowerbeds, and lawn where it isn't.

Thank you, wdccruise!