Software
Houzz Logo Print
wyliwf

Help! Black or white countertops?!?

5 years ago

Trying to go very modern/mid-century

Comments (39)

  • 5 years ago

    black on perimeter white on island

  • 5 years ago

    I like all black. Cool space, and that skylight is great!

  • 5 years ago

    You're going to get 50/50 here. White fits kitchen and looks better, black is more modern IMO.

  • 5 years ago

    Not only black counters on both island and surround, but mat black backsplash tiles as well. I would chose something that shows texture like herringbone or a hexagon design. Then paint all the walls white (BM Chantilly Lace) which will co-ordinate with your white cupboards. Your wood ceiling, etc. will add the warmth that’s needed.

  • 5 years ago

    Never posted a “discussion” before. Soooo helpful! Thank you for the feedback

  • 5 years ago

    Another vote for black.

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    go white on the island, black on the perimeter. or do something like Silestone Eternal Charcoal or Serena.


    Or, go both black.

    don't like the white on white

  • 5 years ago

    Boy oh boy I can see why you posted. They both look FANTASTIC. I want to vote but I keep scrolling up to see the options again. I have had black counters (virginia Jet mist granite ) and loved the look. Right now I have a white gray marble and also love the look of lighter counters.


    Truly white or black it is going to look GREAT.

  • 5 years ago

    Black

  • 5 years ago

    I like the white but that may be because it's what I'd like to do in my kitchen, white on medium brown stained slab fronts.

  • 5 years ago

    Current state of things...

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    I vote black!

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    Beautiful home and views!

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    I think either would work! great space! where is this located?


    I like the black but maybe doing something different on the little island.

    found one w/black on perimeter, and a marble look on island


    what are your plans for backsplash tile?

    Is this the black you're using? (it's actually Charcoal by Silestone)


    what do you think about this one?
















  • 5 years ago

    Beth H, Thank you so much! I’m thinking negresco honed granite, (pic attached)?? LOVE that first kitchen you showed me with the White Island! Im a little concerned that having the walnut cabinets on top and white cabinets on the bottom, it may busy things up if I don’t have cohesive counter color🤷🏻‍♀️ If all my cabinets were walnut, I’d do that in a second!

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    I love Negresco!

    ok, so if you do all black, would you at least consider doing a bold tile?

    Fireclay tile




    I like a zellige tile, handmade, in one of these warmer goldenrod tones.


    kind of looks like this w/the walnut.




    or, what about this blue/gray/periwinkle? would look great w/your floors and the walnut


    Or, what do you think about the cement tile? with the black and your gray floors, I'm loving this look


    I guess you could try a removealbe peel and stick wallpaper to see how you like the look!


    I just think a bold pop w/tile w/this kitchen is the perfect accompanyment. anyone can do white tile. you don't have a kitchen like everyone else and I'm jelly! lol

    the Zellige tile in a white of soft gray looks like this. I like the colors better


    Go to FireClay tile and look at their yummy colors.

    https://www.fireclaytile.com/subway-tile/colors

    you could go w/a glazed subway or brick and lay it like this


    but i think something w/a bit of color would look better, especially w/the black

    even a ceramic elongated picket in a bold color would look nice.




  • 5 years ago

    OMG!! LOVING the crazy cement tiles! Now, I’m excited! Thank you so much for your help. My husband is wanting to bring the negresco up the backsplash. I was kinda wanting to install the counters and see how we feel... I win!

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    oh no!! you have the perfect home, the perfect kitchen, and the perfect amount of light to do some color.

    mcm was all about color. If you use the black and bring it up the wall too, I just think it's a missed opportunity to really take advantage of your unique kitchen.

    I'm going to show you a million pictures below, so hang in there with me! I just want to show you options so you can consider everything.


    your black on black slab will basically have this appearance.

    except you have the white cabinets here. this is nice, but it's kind of boring.


    there is back painted glass. that's another option. (or you could do this in any bold color!)


    If he wants black, how about a black tile? black zellige or the black finger tiles w/light gray grout could work.


    I did the black zellige tiles in a herringbone inset in my wood floor.


    It plays off the black/white cement tiles I did w/my walnut shelves on my coffee bar.


    I have that matte gray Serena quartz on my perimeter and walnut around my black window.

    I also have black appliance, charcoal island, so I had to be careful about doing a black backsplash. I went w/the Calacatta



    but you have a more modern mcm vibe and can totally do some color

    Have you heard of Japanese 'finger tiles'? It's smaller, finger sized tiles glazed in sorts of cool colors


    if he really wants black, instead of doing the countertop which is boring, do a black tile. it will look more interesting






    herringbone


    Now, if you could find a piece of marble or stone that looks like this, go for it up the back!


    have you heard of Panda White marble,


    or seen this "white Soapstone" ?? pretty cool looking huh.


    or Bianco lasa Vecchia. I love this one as well


    this is the calacatta macchia version, but it gives you an idea of how it looks up the back.


    you could go w/the black quartz w/the distinct white


    Youre on a lake or ocean, yes? a deep turquoise or azure would look great w/the black and your home


    found a blue w/the black and the walnut




  • 5 years ago

    Seeing the actual space makes me convinced the black will be dramatic but work well because you have so much natural light.

  • 5 years ago

    Can’t thank you enough for all your time and suggestions!! So much to look at and think about. Thank you, thank you, thank you!

  • 5 years ago

    Please post us your final decision. Now we’re invested! ;)

  • 4 years ago

    I went black and LOVE it! But, I’m now totally locked up on backsplash😩 The backsplash will be one of the first things you see when you enter the home… HELP! Color is a no-go.

  • 4 years ago

    So none of the colored tile backsplashes are an option? That just leaves you with black (too dark) or white(kinda boring). You have a small area that needs a backsplash tile, so a bit of MCM color would really look amazing. A vertical turquoise tile would add a smile to your kitchen….

    I think you’re breaking @Beth H’s heart…..

  • 4 years ago

    Ha! I’m afraid a turquoise would clash with my green/gray floors. Also, worry I would tire of it. I love color in other peoples spaces, but struggle with it in my own…

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    What about a white with gold backsplash? Love your kitchen! Well done.

    Princess Marble and Brass Tile, Lena · More Info


    Medici Gold Pattern Stone Metal Mosaic, 10 Sheets · More Info


    Gentle Net Calacatta and Brass Luxury Waterjet Mosaic · More Info


  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    omg,,,looks so good!

    I don't think the glam marble/gold works w/this updated mcm.

    You need these finger tiles

    I like this glazed version w/the glazed 'dots'. not all of them have this, just certain colors.

    (houzz carries these. or search "glazed japanese finger tiles" plenty of outlets)


    this gray one might be a good choice. has the bits of black, a bit of color, will work w/the flooring and the furniture. I like color too, but at least this is a step up from plain old white



    Glazed Porcelain Mosaic Tile Sheet Sevilla 3.5"x0.5" Mini KitKat Glossy Black · More Info



    Glazed Porcelain Mosaic Sevilla 3.5"x0.5" Kit Kat Glossy Light Green, Sample · More Info


    I mean, Hello??


    the white is safe. but I think if you find a shade of that blue/green, it will look amazing w/the wood and play of the tones in the floor. how could you get tired of any color??

    safe and vanilla. yawn. beautiful, but yawnsville. you better bring in lots of color in accessories if you choose this one!




    they come in all colors, shapes, textures. I LOVE these w/your kitchen


    look at these colors! be a shame to do all white. sigh.


    this is the mini kit-kat.


    1x6 from Bedrosians. comes in many colors, but these are matte. I like the others.






    diff pattern.


    love the vertical. you don't have to do this exact color, but look at it next to black


    Modket Black Marquino Stone Marble Glass Mosaic Tile Kitchen Backsplash TDH289NS · More Info


  • 4 years ago

    Well Hello again Beth H! THANK YOU! That’s more of the look I’m going for…I think. Still toying with the idea of a slab, but the more I think about it, the more I worry it’ll be dated sooner and maybe a little boring?? I so appreciate your input!

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    ugh, no slab. I edited my comment above w/more pics. take another look.

    please,,,just order some samples of those in white, gray, blue/green, sage please???


    or if you want something bottle shaped, they have these


    Vetro D'Terra Dolomite Bottle Shaped Glass Mosaic Tiles, 1 Sq Ft · More Info


  • 4 years ago

    Ok, really LOVING that gray! Where did you find it? Love the variation and the bits of black.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    I actually like this smaller black one too. has the asian/mcm look. next to your wood and black countertops, grouted w/warmer gray-white grout, this would be a showstopper.




    this would be pretty w/charcoal grout. dark blue/gray/black tile.


  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    found the gray one.

    Glazed Porcelain Mosaic Tile Sheet Sevilla KitKat Fingers 6"x1" Glossy Gray · More Info


    charcoal grout might look good w/this one. not a bright white though.

    another source. a little bit cheaper

    https://www.presentusa.com/Glazed-Porcelain-Mosaic-Tile-Sheet-Sevilla-6x1-Finger-Glossy-Gray-Box-95-sq-ft/


    pages of other colors here.

    https://www.presentusa.com/brands/The-Mosaic-Factory.html


    lighter gray. I like the dark one though. this layout.


  • 4 years ago

    Yes. I actually, really, really LOVE this. Now, to convince the husband… Wish me luck!

  • 4 years ago

    Just ordered two samples. Dark gray and light gray. Progress!

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Order the white one too.

    and i'm guessing that darker blue/gray is out of the question?


    BTW, found a much better price on them here. they're on sale. 15.99 for the gray one.

    shipping might be an issue. not sure what they charge. (if you're near newark, you can pick them up for free)

    here's the white

    https://mosaictiledirect.net/mosaic-24/11-7x11-8-piano-white-porcelain-mosaic-tile.html

    and the gray

    https://mosaictiledirect.net/11-7x11-8-piano-grey-porcelain-mosaic-tile.html

    glass?

    https://www.build.com/product/summary/1319425


    black marble?





  • 4 years ago

    Getting samples may be the best way to convince your husband. Many people cannot visualize. Please just get ONE of the blue-green….

  • 4 years ago

    I love those finger tiles that Beth posted! And they are a little bit like the fluted textures that are really hot right now. I'm excited to see what you do here.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    I think if you found a lighter sage color, it would look great w/the wood/black AND completely coordinate w/your greenish slate floors









  • 4 years ago

    I showed my husband last night and he said the same thing! We MAY be opening up to a little color…

Sponsored
The Creative Kitchen Company
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars52 Reviews
Columbus Area Kitchen Remodeling and Refacing Professional